Derry Club Football & Hurling original

Started by Loup Bandit, May 08, 2007, 04:25:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

?
18 (52.9%)
?
16 (47.1%)

Total Members Voted: 34

quit yo jibbajabba

Quote from: jb77 on February 27, 2026, 10:56:08 PMApologies, I have heard Mark Doherty is to begin training with Newbridge again, Sean Kearney is debating leaving and Jack Doherty left this week. Hopefully I'm wrong but I heard Conor McAteer had left from the same people.

I now have an image of Sean Kearney in that Pablo Escobar gif mulling over his life choices

SaffronSports

Its a massive commitment for boys on the periphery of things. Patience could be rewarded but theres not many patient people about nowadays.

Wildweasel74

Why Doherty think of leaving when started last week and played rightly!

Ryan O

To be honest I thought it would be hard for Sean Kearney to stay when Niall O Donnell and Charlie Diamond got a run out before him last week. Realistically it looks like theres Mc Guigan, Loughlin, Murray, Toner, O Donnell, Diamond all ahead of him for spot in full forward line.

Personally don't think the state of pitches at the minute would help but definitely its pity if he's left. I Would have been interested to see how he coped at that level.

Wildweasel74

God forbid u have to fight for a place on a county panel.Theres plenty of games coming this yr.

Newbridge Exile

Derry minors down by two against Antrim at half time , have the breeze in the second half

Newbridge Exile


zapped

It's unfortunate, but let's face it, two of them who left aren't good enough to play. Which is why they haven't played. McAteer had potential (and did play) so he's the only one that we can consider a loss.

As for Kearney, the fella has won the lottery currently as he'll probably never be on another county squad. So no idea why he'd walk away now. Byt he'll be further down the pecking order when the U20s are finished so who knows.

It's obviously a huge commitment for them but I wouldn't be losing any sleep. If Derry are to win an all Ireland it'll be with 18 or 19 core players not a raft of lads who blow in and out.

Ryan O

Quote from: zapped on February 28, 2026, 03:19:06 PMIt's unfortunate, but let's face it, two of them who left aren't good enough to play. Which is why they haven't played. McAteer had potential (and did play) so he's the only one that we can consider a loss.

As for Kearney, the fella has won the lottery currently as he'll probably never be on another county squad. So no idea why he'd walk away now. Byt he'll be further down the pecking order when the U20s are finished so who knows.

It's obviously a huge commitment for them but I wouldn't be losing any sleep. If Derry are to win an all Ireland it'll be with 18 or 19 core players not a raft of lads who blow in and out.
no sure of the winning the lottery analogy but 18/19 players will 100% not win us an all Ireland. It'll be a minimum of 22 odd all playing at a set standard.

Currently theres a gap between our best 5 and the next 12.
Its these squad players with potential that we really need to be holding onto. Massive commitment with very little glory but that's key to building the whole thing.
From the U20 squad who do you expect to join? Tommy Rogers and James Sargent are already floating about it.

Newbridge Exile

Quote from: Ryan O on February 28, 2026, 03:39:04 PM
Quote from: zapped on February 28, 2026, 03:19:06 PMIt's unfortunate, but let's face it, two of them who left aren't good enough to play. Which is why they haven't played. McAteer had potential (and did play) so he's the only one that we can consider a loss.

As for Kearney, the fella has won the lottery currently as he'll probably never be on another county squad. So no idea why he'd walk away now. Byt he'll be further down the pecking order when the U20s are finished so who knows.

It's obviously a huge commitment for them but I wouldn't be losing any sleep. If Derry are to win an all Ireland it'll be with 18 or 19 core players not a raft of lads who blow in and out.
no sure of the winning the lottery analogy but 18/19 players will 100% not win us an all Ireland. It'll be a minimum of 22 odd all playing at a set standard.

Currently theres a gap between our best 5 and the next 12.
Its these squad players with potential that we really need to be holding onto. Massive commitment with very little glory but that's key to building the whole thing.
From the U20 squad who do you expect to join? Tommy Rogers and James Sargent are already floating about it.
Eamon young and Conal Higgins are part of the panel

NotedObserver

Quote from: Newbridge Exile on February 28, 2026, 04:13:15 PM
Quote from: Ryan O on February 28, 2026, 03:39:04 PM
Quote from: zapped on February 28, 2026, 03:19:06 PMIt's unfortunate, but let's face it, two of them who left aren't good enough to play. Which is why they haven't played. McAteer had potential (and did play) so he's the only one that we can consider a loss.

As for Kearney, the fella has won the lottery currently as he'll probably never be on another county squad. So no idea why he'd walk away now. Byt he'll be further down the pecking order when the U20s are finished so who knows.

It's obviously a huge commitment for them but I wouldn't be losing any sleep. If Derry are to win an all Ireland it'll be with 18 or 19 core players not a raft of lads who blow in and out.
no sure of the winning the lottery analogy but 18/19 players will 100% not win us an all Ireland. It'll be a minimum of 22 odd all playing at a set standard.

Currently theres a gap between our best 5 and the next 12.
Its these squad players with potential that we really need to be holding onto. Massive commitment with very little glory but that's key to building the whole thing.
From the U20 squad who do you expect to join? Tommy Rogers and James Sargent are already floating about it.
Eamon young and Conal Higgins are part of the panel

Are young, Higgins and Roger's still under 20?

zapped

Team from 2023 minor AI final (this year's U20s):
Derry: Karl Campbell; Fionn McEldowney (Capt.), Finbar Murray, Luke Grant; Cahir Spiers, James Sargent, Odhrán Campbell; Tommy Rogers, Cahal McKaigue; Éamon Young, Johnny McGuckin, Rory Small; Ger Dillon, Conall Higgins, Oisín Doherty.
Subs: Kevin Barry Mullan for Doherty (49); John Boyle for Higgins (58); Dara McGuckin for Rogers (60).

Of that squad - Campbell is away to college in USA.
McEldowney and Rogers were part of the panel last year.
Sargent, Young, Rogers, Higgins all part of the panel this year. Expect Cahal McKaigue to not be far away from a call up as well.

My point was that were better focusing time and money on these players rather than good club players like JD or SK who may or may not stick around until the league is over  :-\

Ryan O

Quote from: zapped on February 28, 2026, 04:26:40 PMTeam from 2023 minor AI final (this year's U20s):
Derry: Karl Campbell; Fionn McEldowney (Capt.), Finbar Murray, Luke Grant; Cahir Spiers, James Sargent, Odhrán Campbell; Tommy Rogers, Cahal McKaigue; Éamon Young, Johnny McGuckin, Rory Small; Ger Dillon, Conall Higgins, Oisín Doherty.
Subs: Kevin Barry Mullan for Doherty (49); John Boyle for Higgins (58); Dara McGuckin for Rogers (60).

Of that squad - Campbell is away to college in USA.
McEldowney and Rogers were part of the panel last year.
Sargent, Young, Rogers, Higgins all part of the panel this year. Expect Cahal McKaigue to not be far away from a call up as well.

My point was that were better focusing time and money on these players rather than good club players like JD or SK who may or may not stick around until the league is over  :-\
I totally agree but still think they should be trying get a few of that type of player on board. Yes it may be hard to hold them but we can't narrow player search to lads who just come through development squads.
I would expect Luke Grant to move into a senior squad too, maybe not this year but he's a very good young player.

Anyway this weekend not about future players, what we have is going good. Hope Celtic Park is packed tomorrow biggest game of the weekend in all divisions.

Newbridge Exile

Quote from: NotedObserver on February 28, 2026, 04:15:04 PM
Quote from: Newbridge Exile on February 28, 2026, 04:13:15 PM
Quote from: Ryan O on February 28, 2026, 03:39:04 PM
Quote from: zapped on February 28, 2026, 03:19:06 PMIt's unfortunate, but let's face it, two of them who left aren't good enough to play. Which is why they haven't played. McAteer had potential (and did play) so he's the only one that we can consider a loss.

As for Kearney, the fella has won the lottery currently as he'll probably never be on another county squad. So no idea why he'd walk away now. Byt he'll be further down the pecking order when the U20s are finished so who knows.

It's obviously a huge commitment for them but I wouldn't be losing any sleep. If Derry are to win an all Ireland it'll be with 18 or 19 core players not a raft of lads who blow in and out.
no sure of the winning the lottery analogy but 18/19 players will 100% not win us an all Ireland. It'll be a minimum of 22 odd all playing at a set standard.

Currently theres a gap between our best 5 and the next 12.
Its these squad players with potential that we really need to be holding onto. Massive commitment with very little glory but that's key to building the whole thing.
From the U20 squad who do you expect to join? Tommy Rogers and James Sargent are already floating about it.
Eamon young and Conal Higgins are part of the panel

Are young, Higgins and Roger's still under 20?

Yes and Eamon is under 20 next year also

GTP

SK named in squad JD and MD are not.
Dan Higgins on bench.