Jimmy McGuinness

[shantygael]

That 'interview' with Rooney was silly by Mc Guinness.  Made him seen like a rookie manager. Instead of a very experienced manager.


Good point in the article there though.  Are there any managers in GAA who sit up high watching the game?

Brennan?
[/quote

Great response Main Street. 

Plus 1

[jb77]

Jim lives to fight another day

https://www.independent.ie/sport/jim-mcguinness-and-david-clifford-wont-face-bans-after-cccc-decide-to-take-no-further-action-following-killarney-report/a/153176265.html

[imtommygunn]

Lucky boy.

[gallsman]

Complete cop out. This might be a watershed moment for the "the ref dealt with it at the time so no further action can be taken" nonsense.

(worth it btw for all the crying the Armagh and Tyrone ones will do)

[Armagh18]

Right decision. Would have been hilarious if he was banned but in reality was nothing in it. Brennan will be annoyed!

[naka]

Right decision. Would have been hilarious if he was banned but in reality was nothing in it. Brennan will be annoyed!

Genuinely
Why is it the right decision ?
The Rule was clear and he deserved punishment .
There is no mitigation under the rule .

[AustinPowers]

So all managers are allowed to  go around shoving  opposition players? 

Hmm, fair enough.

[Armamike]

Complete cop out. This might be a watershed moment for the "the ref dealt with it at the time so no further action can be taken" nonsense.

(worth it btw for all the crying the Armagh and Tyrone ones will do)

Would think Dublin would have more reason to be annoyed than Armagh or Tyrone.
Didn't think he would get sanctioned. He's too big a figure in the GAA now. Same for Clifford and Murphy.

[gallsman]

Complete cop out. This might be a watershed moment for the "the ref dealt with it at the time so no further action can be taken" nonsense.

(worth it btw for all the crying the Armagh and Tyrone ones will do)

Would think Dublin would have more reason to be annoyed than Armagh or Tyrone.
Didn't think he would get sanctioned. He's too big a figure in the GAA now. Same for Clifford and Murphy.

There aren't many Dubs on the board.

[tyrone08]

Yet again gaa making a show of themselves. This was one of the clearest bloody rules the gaa had but they wont act on it. Disgraceful.

[AustinPowers]

Complete cop out. This might be a watershed moment for the "the ref dealt with it at the time so no further action can be taken" nonsense.

(worth it btw for all the crying the Armagh and Tyrone ones will do)

Would think Dublin would have more reason to be annoyed than Armagh or Tyrone.
Didn't think he would get sanctioned. He's too big a figure in the GAA now. Same for Clifford and Murphy.

So they get to play by different rules? Yeah, that seems fair

the GAA are becoming  more like FIFA every day

[Armagh18]

Right decision. Would have been hilarious if he was banned but in reality was nothing in it. Brennan will be annoyed!

Genuinely
Why is it the right decision ?
The Rule was clear and he deserved punishment .
There is no mitigation under the rule .

The rule is shite. I'm far from a fan of Donegal or Jimmy but a 12 week ban for what he did would be daft.  Maybe one game max

[JoG2]

Yet again gaa making a show of themselves. This was one of the clearest bloody rules the gaa had but they wont act on it. Disgraceful.

Mind is blown. Once ANYONE other than the players and officials enter the field to join in the book should be thrown at them. A manager shoves an opposition player and nothing is done. Anyone on here downplaying this is a complete 🤡. A rod for their own backs, again!

[2ndstringsub]

I doubt very much its the route they would go down. But is this something that Kerry could complain about to have looked at if they feel particularly aggrieved? I know its probably in their interest not to given the way they behaved also. Im asking purely from a rules and disciplinary structures point of view.

[Wildweasel74]

Not that i want McGuinness suspended as there little in it, but players have been banned in the past for stuff not dealt with the ref. Giving Brennan 3 months while Burns see a month for thumping someone doesnt make sense. So what happens if a supporter enters the field or aftergame celebrations and starts pushing players.