All-Ireland Series Sam Maguire 2026

[JoG2]

The moving up a mark free 50 metres is actually scandalous. A referee unaware of basic rules at this level.

Oh dear  🫣

What?

Calling out a ref who called it right

Foul = 50m

No the 50 metre advancement on foul at mark was rescinded earlier this year.

Oh, well there you go. Duly noted, as you were deeds 👏

[Puckoon]

Few right-thinking folk will weep for the demise of a county who dirty Joed two of their finest to install the most costly mercenary management ever.

Rumors of their demise are premature, Horse.

True, Horse. Logan and Dooher win that game.

G'wan. Giddy Up and away with ye

[DaleCooper]

Hard luck to Tyrone but Kerry had them at arms length I felt. Few more gears in them. Tyrone kept plugging away but never got in front and never looked like getting in front either.

The lead 7 to 4 at one stage, might have been 10-5 had morgan nailed the frees rather than let jordan hit them.

[gallsman]

Cahair mentions an incident where Kilpatrick fielded the ball and landed infield. I thought he landed with one foot either side of the line. Is there any formal language around the requirement of the player to land in the field of play in order to be awarded a mark?

There have been loads of incidents the last few years where a lad catches it but gets bundled over the line before getting his feet down and the ref has seemed to automatically give them the mark.

[Champion The Wonder Horse]

Few right-thinking folk will weep for the demise of a county who dirty Joed two of their finest to install the most costly mercenary management ever.

Rumors of their demise are premature, Horse.

True, Horse. Logan and Dooher win that game.

G'wan. Giddy Up and away with ye

Ok, but I never felt confident at any stage that Tyrone had it in them to win that.

Poor enough return for yourselves.

[twohands!!!]

David Clifford was quiet enough in the final third of the game. Banning the fisted points would knock a few points off his total.

You would think some of the Kerry players were feeling it, with no week off

Definitely looked like Kerry were feeling it with their 3rd game in 3 weeks compared to Tyrone who were playing their 4th game in 11 weeks. Paul Geaney I thought in the first half didn't look anywhere as sharp as he did against Armagh. There was a least 3 different incidents in the first half were he seemed off the pace of the game. I was very surprised he wasn't hooked at half-time.

[gallsman]

Dylan Geaney hasn't kicked a wide all championship apparently.

[twohands!!!]

Dylan Geaney hasn't kicked a wide all championship apparently.

Neither have I     

[OakLeaf]

Cahair mentions an incident where Kilpatrick fielded the ball and landed infield. I thought he landed with one foot either side of the line. Is there any formal language around the requirement of the player to land in the field of play in order to be awarded a mark?

There have been loads of incidents the last few years where a lad catches it but gets bundled over the line before getting his feet down and the ref has seemed to automatically give them the mark.

I dont think there's anything specific in the official rules but I've heard that the interpretation is that a players feet must be infield when he lands, to claim the mark. I don't know why that would be the case though. You'd think that as long as the ball is in play when the players feet touch the ground, that should be all that matters.

[gallsman]

Cahair mentions an incident where Kilpatrick fielded the ball and landed infield. I thought he landed with one foot either side of the line. Is there any formal language around the requirement of the player to land in the field of play in order to be awarded a mark?

There have been loads of incidents the last few years where a lad catches it but gets bundled over the line before getting his feet down and the ref has seemed to automatically give them the mark.

I dont think there's anything specific in the official rules but I've heard that the interpretation is that a players feet must be infield when he lands, to claim the mark. I don't know why that would be the case though. You'd think that as long as the ball is in play when the players feet touch the ground, that should be all that matters.

Could get all NFL into the details of "what is a catch?"! To me it's not as simple as it might seem. Probably need to define at what point a player has possession of the ball. Only at that point can they be awarded a mark.

[Milltown Row2]

It wasn't a mark, you have to claim the mark for it to be a mark

Thats not technically correct but sure you know that

What's not correct? Calls the mark, is fouled and the ball is moved up, don't call the mark is fouled it's free from that position?

The ref can award the mark wether its claimed or not

The ref will blow the whistle for every mark, it's down to the player to make that signal

[OakLeaf]

Could get all NFL into the details of "what is a catch?"! To me it's not as simple as it might seem. Probably need to define at what point a player has possession of the ball. Only at that point can they be awarded a mark.

True. Being a modern day referee is not easy. As long as we don't introduce VAR!! 😀

[oakleafgael]

It wasn't a mark, you have to claim the mark for it to be a mark

Thats not technically correct but sure you know that

What's not correct? Calls the mark, is fouled and the ball is moved up, don't call the mark is fouled it's free from that position?

The ref can award the mark wether its claimed or not

The ref will blow the whistle for every mark, it's down to the player to make that signal

Getting back to the original point. It can't be moved up wether claimed or not.

[Christmas Lights]

Aishling Reilly said 3 or 4 times Malachy O Rourke was in his first year as Tyrone manager. . Poor enough for someone covering Gaa.

Yes this is exactly the thing we should be talking about #priorities

[RedHand88]

Moving it forward was a mistake.