Ulster Club SFC 2024

[Wildweasel74]

Just seen that TK tackle on tv there now. G that doesn't even look a yellow card!

[Moonshine]

Winter football and teams that are operating at a high level will mean theres unlikely to be much more than a kick of a ball either way. (Kilcoo vs Scotstown would be the exception not the rule). Will come down to the fine margins, a bit of luck and who shows up on the day.

Kilcoo probably slight favourites for me but EC have the talent to hurt them. There will definitely be big plans for the Canavans anyway- I'd say the abuse TK got will look like an underage game by the time Kilcoo are finished with them!

What abuse did TK get? The man made about 14 fouls throughout game he was lucky to even be on the pitch at the time he was eventually sent off

[Mikhailov]

The foul when seen again on tv just now was a very debatable card. Normally you could argue it was, but there were many many worse hits and tackles throughout the game which were not dealt with the same severity from McQuillan

In saying that, TK should have known he was in a knife edge - would he have made that rash tackle playing for Armagh?

[Milltown Row2]

2 minor frees will be a tick, a third of similar fashion will be a yellow, and it would generally follow that path until they warrant a red.

But yes that should still be same  for both sets of players. Consistency

[Wildweasel74]

What did the EC 21 get who hit u man very late? I only see the replay of it, and not at the actual time.

[Armagh18]

What did the EC 21 get who hit u man very late? I only see the replay of it, and not at the actual time.

Sweet fa.

[general_lee]

Winter football and teams that are operating at a high level will mean theres unlikely to be much more than a kick of a ball either way. (Kilcoo vs Scotstown would be the exception not the rule). Will come down to the fine margins, a bit of luck and who shows up on the day.

Kilcoo probably slight favourites for me but EC have the talent to hurt them. There will definitely be big plans for the Canavans anyway- I'd say the abuse TK got will look like an underage game by the time Kilcoo are finished with them!

What abuse did TK get? The man made about 14 fouls throughout game he was lucky to even be on the pitch at the time he was eventually sent off

Dead on Joe

[GTP]

If the late hit had been given as a free CE would have had a tap over from where the ball landed and EC would not have got an easy turnover to launch an attack. Taken in isolation the two bookings do look harsh from TV pictures. But ref gets to see things once or not at all for the late hit, and sending off may have been for persistent fouling. Easy to blame him in a tight game but missed goal chance and the 45 sent wide show players make mistakes that can be equally as costly.
EC had two players who made a difference and won the game for them.

[statto]

McQuillan did not cost CE that game, would you all ever catch yourselves on. The fouls on Darragh were fouls. At one stage he was grabbed and swung around 360 and one of you was whinging about him diving. Too many CE names didn't show up. Ruairi Canavan was the best player on the pitch by a distance.

Don't think EC will have the legs for Kilcoo's running.

The decision not too black card for the penalty was a massive call mcquillan got wrong.

1. Deliberately pull down an opponent.
2. Deliberately trip an opponent with the hand(s), arm, leg or foot.
3. Deliberately body collide with an opponent after he has played the ball away or for the purpose
of taking him out of a movement of play.
4. Threaten or to use abusive or provocative language or gestures to an opponent or a teammate.
5. Remonstrate in an aggressive manner with a Match Official.

Go on then, which of these did McQuillan get wrong? Too many eejits banging on about rules they don't have the slightest clue about. Always the same with the square ball too. Someone was banging on about "a goalscoring opportunity" earlier FFS.

Just watched it back Daniel Magee turns his man heading towards goal  after his shorts are pulled and goes to ground.The defender has no intention of doing anything other than take him out and pulls him by the shorts and he ends up on the ground.Surely a deliberate pull down on an opponent and the reason why the rule was brought in.

[Moonshine]

Pulls the shorts that's a definite and definite penalty. the lurgan celtic dive that followed was pathetic

[Gold]

Just seen that TK tackle on tv there now. G that doesn't even look a yellow card!

It was arguably not a foul. Canavan slabbering to the ref for a Card after hitting the deck at 100mph and bouncing up again asking for a card

CE had the game up to then. Hate that shite so I turned it off as I knew CE were fucked without TK

[Gold]

Bitter enough defeat for Clann Eireann. Had it in their grasp to win it.  The county players are probably sick of football at this stage of the year.  Shouldn't be surprised by Joe McQuillan anymore. The Canavans are clinical with their shooting. 

CE lost because of Dublin Joe in my opinion. Sin e

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

McQuillan did not cost CE that game, would you all ever catch yourselves on. The fouls on Darragh were fouls. At one stage he was grabbed and swung around 360 and one of you was whinging about him diving. Too many CE names didn't show up. Ruairi Canavan was the best player on the pitch by a distance.

Don't think EC will have the legs for Kilcoo's running.

The decision not too black card for the penalty was a massive call mcquillan got wrong.

1. Deliberately pull down an opponent.
2. Deliberately trip an opponent with the hand(s), arm, leg or foot.
3. Deliberately body collide with an opponent after he has played the ball away or for the purpose
of taking him out of a movement of play.
4. Threaten or to use abusive or provocative language or gestures to an opponent or a teammate.
5. Remonstrate in an aggressive manner with a Match Official.

Go on then, which of these did McQuillan get wrong? Too many eejits banging on about rules they don't have the slightest clue about. Always the same with the square ball too. Someone was banging on about "a goalscoring opportunity" earlier FFS.

Just watched it back Daniel Magee turns his man heading towards goal  after his shorts are pulled and goes to ground.The defender has no intention of doing anything other than take him out and pulls him by the shorts and he ends up on the ground.Surely a deliberate pull down on an opponent and the reason why the rule was brought in.

Stop. Please stop.

[Hereiam]

You gota love the comments, better team won lads.
Sit back and enough the final

[Armagh18]

You gota love the comments, better team won lads.
Sit back and enough the final

Yeah the gobshites, discussing a gaa match on gaaboard....