Antrim Football Thread

[NatSoSaff]

Is there any point in playing them? What about the claims on here a while back that the league structure was changing next year?

[NatSoSaff]

The whole thing is a farce top to bottom. League winners confirmed for how long now? Not a single congratulatory post/story on any form of Antrim GAA social media or website. Not even a trophy presentation. Its not hard lads, really it isn't. Promote the game.

[Milltown Row2]

The whole thing is a farce top to bottom. League winners confirmed for how long now? Not a single congratulatory post/story on any form of Antrim GAA social media or website. Not even a trophy presentation. Its not hard lads, really it isn't. Promote the game.

I'm a million percent certain I seen photos of them celebrating winning the league, not sure where but...

Also, no one is interested, well that's all we hear on this board

[inabsentia]

Any word on the relegation play offs?

I'm sure they'll wait till to see how the championship groups turn out before choosing who gets to stay up in both.

If St Endas are running riot in div 2, what happens if they do the double? Didn't this happen a few years ago where one team won both and only one team went up to div 1?

[Delgany 2nds]

There were no discussions or proposals from the football (non)development committee, on Monday evening

[NatSoSaff]

Rubbish, it's a farcical league structure with little to no meaning for the vast majority of clubs. It needs addressing now, not in 2028. Allow the league standings from this year to inform who is categorised into each division. Keeps it fair.

[BigGreenField]

Any word on the relegation play offs?

2 of the teams in the bottom 4 have one more game this Sunday (refixed from a rained off night), presume it needs to wait until after that.

[Hoof Hearted]

Any word on the relegation play offs?

2 of the teams in the bottom 4 have one more game this Sunday (refixed from a rained off night), presume it needs to wait until after that.

Yes cause those results obviously determines who plays who in the semis
Any of those 4 positions can still change, although it is quite likely, going by form, that it will stay as it is, leaving the following

Glenravel v Moneyglass
Sarsfields v Randalstown

I think these are neutral venues
They were 2 years ago anyway

Last years didn't happen due to Ahoghill forfeiting.

[Spike]

The Div 1 league is a farce, little more than challenge games. Creggan romped it and i am not even sure they took it that seriously.  There was little fanfare about it as very few people cared or care about it now due to the mess our board have made of it.

I fully agree the coaching in these development squads has to improve.  my experiences of it are that we are light years behind the likes of derry and tyrone in the quality of people taking it and we have to get away from the Dads taking it. 
While there are good quality players in there, a sizeable portion of each squad are taken up by dad's clubmates or the son's pals taking undeserved places. Some coaches, and I stress not all, aren't in it to improve Antrim football but to say Junior is a county player.

Parents will always be involved in club coaching but at county level we have to strive to have better. Perhaps this was a Gaelfast opportunity - yes promote the game in the schools but spend the money on improving the underage coaching across the board

 

[Saffsof82]

There were no discussions or proposals from the football (non)development committee, on Monday evening

Don't know if theres much happening with this anymore, a couple of the main drivers in it not there anymore

[Milltown Row2]

The Div 1 league is a farce, little more than challenge games. Creggan romped it and i am not even sure they took it that seriously.  There was little fanfare about it as very few people cared or care about it now due to the mess our board have made of it.

I fully agree the coaching in these development squads has to improve.  my experiences of it are that we are light years behind the likes of derry and tyrone in the quality of people taking it and we have to get away from the Dads taking it. 
While there are good quality players in there, a sizeable portion of each squad are taken up by dad's clubmates or the son's pals taking undeserved places. Some coaches, and I stress not all, aren't in it to improve Antrim football but to say Junior is a county player.

Parents will always be involved in club coaching but at county level we have to strive to have better. Perhaps this was a Gaelfast opportunity - yes promote the game in the schools but spend the money on improving the underage coaching across the board

 

You know the clubs voted on this? People complaining about the county board, knowing it was the clubs that do it themselves, while having the same conversation every year but its still the county board at fault!

[HTownlad]

I don't think that's 100% true MR2

As the old saying goes, turkeys don't vote for Christmas. Clubs will never vote on something that's impacting them negatively despite it being in the greater interest.

The county board own the competition and have responsibility to ensure its quality is  upheld. Now i won't be saying they where right or wrong, I wasn't in the room and without discussion or rehashing how we got here I'd be genuinely interested in hearing people's thoughts on what needs improved and how this is achieved

With regards the development committee, again, who's left and where is it at? Does this fall under the remit of the coaching officer in the county now?

I've no idea of the dynamics of the group but would be interested in learning.

[Milltown Row2]

I don't think that's 100% true MR2

As the old saying goes, turkeys don't vote for Christmas. Clubs will never vote on something that's impacting them negatively despite it being in the greater interest.

The county board own the competition and have responsibility to ensure its quality is  upheld. Now i won't be saying they where right or wrong, I wasn't in the room and without discussion or rehashing how we got here I'd be genuinely interested in hearing people's thoughts on what needs improved and how this is achieved

With regards the development committee, again, who's left and where is it at? Does this fall under the remit of the coaching officer in the county now?

I've no idea of the dynamics of the group but would be interested in learning.

I'm going to say that the clubs put proposals to the the county, they are voted on and passed or deferred, or defeated

Some are amended and passed, but any, any changes to the leagues, the format and how many teams are involved in it, is done by the clubs, of course turkeys are not going to vote for xmas, but that's the way it is and should be..

If the GAA boarders what change, here's a few simple tips, join a club, pay your membership, go to the AGM's, join the committees, put in a proposal, speak to other clubs, gauge opinions and amend if possible present to the county at county convention and going through those channels, may, if voted on will be passed if the majority are happy with it

[SaffronSports]

I don't think that's 100% true MR2

As the old saying goes, turkeys don't vote for Christmas. Clubs will never vote on something that's impacting them negatively despite it being in the greater interest.

The county board own the competition and have responsibility to ensure its quality is  upheld. Now i won't be saying they where right or wrong, I wasn't in the room and without discussion or rehashing how we got here I'd be genuinely interested in hearing people's thoughts on what needs improved and how this is achieved

With regards the development committee, again, who's left and where is it at? Does this fall under the remit of the coaching officer in the county now?

I've no idea of the dynamics of the group but would be interested in learning.

I'm going to say that the clubs put proposals to the the county, they are voted on and passed or deferred, or defeated

Some are amended and passed, but any, any changes to the leagues, the format and how many teams are involved in it, is done by the clubs, of course turkeys are not going to vote for xmas, but that's the way it is and should be..

If the GAA boarders what change, here's a few simple tips, join a club, pay your membership, go to the AGM's, join the committees, put in a proposal, speak to other clubs, gauge opinions and amend if possible present to the county at county convention and going through those channels, may, if voted on will be passed if the majority are happy with it

This is whats supposed to happen. In reality whether its a club or county you'll have a few people coming up with ideas and then they'll strong arm them into being.

[Milltown Row2]

I don't think that's 100% true MR2

As the old saying goes, turkeys don't vote for Christmas. Clubs will never vote on something that's impacting them negatively despite it being in the greater interest.

The county board own the competition and have responsibility to ensure its quality is  upheld. Now i won't be saying they where right or wrong, I wasn't in the room and without discussion or rehashing how we got here I'd be genuinely interested in hearing people's thoughts on what needs improved and how this is achieved

With regards the development committee, again, who's left and where is it at? Does this fall under the remit of the coaching officer in the county now?

I've no idea of the dynamics of the group but would be interested in learning.

I'm going to say that the clubs put proposals to the the county, they are voted on and passed or deferred, or defeated

Some are amended and passed, but any, any changes to the leagues, the format and how many teams are involved in it, is done by the clubs, of course turkeys are not going to vote for xmas, but that's the way it is and should be..

If the GAA boarders what change, here's a few simple tips, join a club, pay your membership, go to the AGM's, join the committees, put in a proposal, speak to other clubs, gauge opinions and amend if possible present to the county at county convention and going through those channels, may, if voted on will be passed if the majority are happy with it

This is whats supposed to happen. In reality whether its a club or county you'll have a few people coming up with ideas and then they'll strong arm them into being.

That's then down to those who don't push it.. There seems to be a collective will on here that the leagues have no meaning, they haven't been a priority tbf for as long as county managers have had the extended seasons and full control of the players..

Supporters want to turn up to a blood and thunder local rivalry clash and bag the bragging rights, but that loses its appeal when its part reserves lining out. This imo needs looked at also, county v club, its as old as time lol.

Would we complain about over training, games, then fatigue if the county lads were allowed to play club and county, train for both or do we think that the modern day set up of county training and conditioning would be too much..

Strike a balance for sure, but be rest assured one or two clubs will feel that it doesn't work for them and so we go on...

I've witnessed leagues with 8 and 10 and 12 and so on, there has never been a big push on them, and there won't be until they actually have meaning towards, seeding in championship, a benefit of home games or whatever, but the league has to have a purpose