The Offical Glasgow Celtic thread

[lynchbhoy]

I'll say no more about caldwell. You know my opinion on him. I dont think its harsh at all.
Kennedy seems to have gotten better with time ....
he was a young untried unproven cb when he got selected for Scotland (no big deal there as they were and are sihte)
after his inj, people are saying they hope he gets back to as good as he was.
he was only a kid that was light years away from being actually any good tobe honest.
While I wish him well and hope he has a long and successful career, I dont think he was going to be much better than caldwell - unless he started being able to kick with his right foot as well. Way too one sided and soft imo.

[carribbear]

Caldwell is the new Tebily as far as I'm concerned.

[Doogie Browser]

Well done to Celtic tonight, that amazing home record remains and they did Utd a favour in the process!

[carribbear]

I wouldnt care too much about whether it helps united or not, still disappointing to come bottom of the table.

Perhaps best to concentrate on the league as we don't have the players for the CL.

[Lamh Dhearg Alba]

I'll say no more about caldwell. You know my opinion on him. I dont think its harsh at all.
Kennedy seems to have gotten better with time ....
he was a young untried unproven cb when he got selected for Scotland (no big deal there as they were and are sihte)
after his inj, people are saying they hope he gets back to as good as he was.
he was only a kid that was light years away from being actually any good tobe honest.
While I wish him well and hope he has a long and successful career, I dont think he was going to be much better than caldwell - unless he started being able to kick with his right foot as well. Way too one sided and soft imo.

Kennedy played an outstanding game for Celtic in the Nou Camp and due to being seriously injured shortly thereafter thats what he is remembered for. Bit like Ian Durrant who played some good games for Rangers in the late 80's and was then crocked against Aberdeen, and never managing to find consistent good form on his recovery saw the injury blamed for not realising his potential. I hope for Kennedy's sake he doesnt go the same way but he has plenty to prove.

As for Caldwell he was never a player I liked and his off the field antics make him instantly dislikable. Must be said though his performances in recent months have been very good and if maintained could see him head to a higher level.

[carribbear]

I wish Caldwell would shut up and stop speaking to the press...he's never out of it....if only he's spend a wee bit more time on the training ground...

[youngfella]

up the hoops !

[Gaoth Dobhair Abu]

I'll say no more about caldwell. You know my opinion on him. I dont think its harsh at all.
Kennedy seems to have gotten better with time ....
he was a young untried unproven cb when he got selected for Scotland (no big deal there as they were and are sihte)
after his inj, people are saying they hope he gets back to as good as he was.
he was only a kid that was light years away from being actually any good tobe honest.
While I wish him well and hope he has a long and successful career, I dont think he was going to be much better than caldwell - unless he started being able to kick with his right foot as well. Way too one sided and soft imo.

Kennedy played an outstanding game for Celtic in the Nou Camp and due to being seriously injured shortly thereafter thats what he is remembered for. Bit like Ian Durrant who played some good games for Rangers in the late 80's and was then crocked against Aberdeen, and never managing to find consistent good form on his recovery saw the injury blamed for not realising his potential. I hope for Kennedy's sake he doesnt go the same way but he has plenty to prove.

As for Caldwell he was never a player I liked and his off the field antics make him instantly dislikable. Must be said though his performances in recent months have been very good and if maintained could see him head to a higher level.

LDA agree with you re Kennedy, but can you explain what is meant by the bit in bold?

[southderryman]

I'll say no more about caldwell. You know my opinion on him. I dont think its harsh at all.
Kennedy seems to have gotten better with time ....
he was a young untried unproven cb when he got selected for Scotland (no big deal there as they were and are sihte)
after his inj, people are saying they hope he gets back to as good as he was.
he was only a kid that was light years away from being actually any good tobe honest.
While I wish him well and hope he has a long and successful career, I dont think he was going to be much better than caldwell - unless he started being able to kick with his right foot as well. Way too one sided and soft imo.

Kennedy played an outstanding game for Celtic in the Nou Camp and due to being seriously injured shortly thereafter thats what he is remembered for. Bit like Ian Durrant who played some good games for Rangers in the late 80's and was then crocked against Aberdeen, and never managing to find consistent good form on his recovery saw the injury blamed for not realising his potential. I hope for Kennedy's sake he doesnt go the same way but he has plenty to prove.

As for Caldwell he was never a player I liked and his off the field antics make him instantly dislikable. Must be said though his performances in recent months have been very good and if maintained could see him head to a higher level.

LDA agree with you re Kennedy, but can you explain what is meant by the bit in bold?

a bit curious about that myself!? 

[Lamh Dhearg Alba]

Caldwell's wife and young baby were in hospital, the child was born premature and in a bad way, and at the same time he was caught sh*gging a cheerleader.

[southderryman]

Caldwell's wife and young baby were in hospital, the child was born premature and in a bad way, and at the same time he was caught sh*gging a cheerleader.

fcuk, never heard any mention of that at all 

[lynchbhoy]

I couldnt care less (other than to feel some empathy for the poor wife) about caldwell off field. On field he's bad enough to worry about.
Kennedy effectively was a one hit wonder and while a great 'prospect' was no more than this - Celtic have had bucket loads of great potential that never get fully realised.

Good result last night. No coincidence that a more balanced team played well, and actually looked like a good side at times.

Villareal may have had a second team out, but even then they were still better then aalborg.

Celtic will be kicking themselves as their poor showing (imo largely due to the manager, his tactics and his poor coaching - eg brutal marking at corners) cost them a place in the last 16.
Should have easily beat aalborg both times, they had the chances. Could have beaten villareal away - had the chances, shoul dhave at least drawn. Fecked up by conceding that undeserved late goal to man united.
Strachan is to blame,he gets it right some of the time, but is a very hit and miss kind of guy. Lacks consistency - like his teams.
Concentrate on the league now, beating a poor but very confident rangers side should be his priority now, but dispatching hearts first !

[cavan4ever]

I couldnt care less (other than to feel some empathy for the poor wife) about caldwell off field. On field he's bad enough to worry about.
Kennedy effectively was a one hit wonder and while a great 'prospect' was no more than this - Celtic have had bucket loads of great potential that never get fully realised.

Good result last night. No coincidence that a more balanced team played well, and actually looked like a good side at times.

Villareal may have had a second team out, but even then they were still better then aalborg.

Celtic will be kicking themselves as their poor showing (imo largely due to the manager, his tactics and his poor coaching - eg brutal marking at corners) cost them a place in the last 16.
Should have easily beat aalborg both times, they had the chances. Could have beaten villareal away - had the chances, shoul dhave at least drawn. Fecked up by conceding that undeserved late goal to man united.
Strachan is to blame,he gets it right some of the time, but is a very hit and miss kind of guy. Lacks consistency - like his teams.
Concentrate on the league now, beating a poor but very confident rangers side should be his priority now, but dispatching hearts first !

You can hardly blame strachan for players not taking their chances.

[lynchbhoy]

I couldnt care less (other than to feel some empathy for the poor wife) about caldwell off field. On field he's bad enough to worry about.
Kennedy effectively was a one hit wonder and while a great 'prospect' was no more than this - Celtic have had bucket loads of great potential that never get fully realised.

Good result last night. No coincidence that a more balanced team played well, and actually looked like a good side at times.

Villareal may have had a second team out, but even then they were still better then aalborg.

Celtic will be kicking themselves as their poor showing (imo largely due to the manager, his tactics and his poor coaching - eg brutal marking at corners) cost them a place in the last 16.
Should have easily beat aalborg both times, they had the chances. Could have beaten villareal away - had the chances, shoul dhave at least drawn. Fecked up by conceding that undeserved late goal to man united.
Strachan is to blame,he gets it right some of the time, but is a very hit and miss kind of guy. Lacks consistency - like his teams.
Concentrate on the league now, beating a poor but very confident rangers side should be his priority now, but dispatching hearts first !

You can hardly blame strachan for players not taking their chances.

but can blame the poor tactics, team selection and bad caoaching on him - some of which lead to lack of , or missing chances

[lfdown2]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/c/celtic/7762250.stm

WTF is the Ginger **** at now?