Derry Club Football & Hurling original

Started by Loup Bandit, May 08, 2007, 04:25:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

?
18 (52.9%)
?
16 (47.1%)

Total Members Voted: 34

marty34


Jimmy

Quote from: outsiderlookingin on November 09, 2026, 04:45:18 PM3rd year in a row Derry champs beat at the 1st hurdle, hard draws mind you. You would have to fancy Desertmartin to reach final possibly playing Rock

Newbridge beat Dunloy in the preliminary round and Madden in 1st round last year.

p3427977


Maghera was Black

When's someone going to stand up to Beggan? He's now risen to Michael Murphy's levels of getting away with anything. He's reffing the game in the ears of umpires and referee's and going unchallenged. Hope we draw Monaghan in Ulster

Interstellar

Do you think Derry would beat Monaghan in next year's championship?

Topmarks

Quote from: Interstellar on November 09, 2026, 07:27:24 PMDo you think Derry would beat Monaghan in next year's championship?

Yeah, I do. We outplayed them for the majority of the game last year and looked a level above them. Monaghan to be fair hung in, battled back through a series of two pointers and got us on the hooter at the end of normal time and extra time. That game ruined our season so it would be nice get them back and no reason to think we couldn't. I have nothing against them but they did get a few winnable home draws after that and should have been able to beat a 14 man Louth in Croke park. If we start to fear playing Monaghan then we might as well play in the Tailteann.

screenexile

Quote from: Topmarks on November 09, 2026, 08:37:36 PM
Quote from: Interstellar on November 09, 2026, 07:27:24 PMDo you think Derry would beat Monaghan in next year's championship?

Yeah, I do. We outplayed them for the majority of the game last year and looked a level above them. Monaghan to be fair hung in, battled back through a series of two pointers and got us on the hooter at the end of normal time and extra time. That game ruined our season so it would be nice get them back and no reason to think we couldn't. I have nothing against them but they did get a few winnable home draws after that and should have been able to beat a 14 man Louth in Croke park. If we start to fear playing Monaghan then we might as well play in the Tailteann.

I agree with that... you'd also hope there's a bit if pride and added motivation to beat them after the manner in which we got beat this year!

zapped

Quote from: outsiderlookingin on November 09, 2026, 04:45:18 PM3rd year in a row Derry champs beat at the 1st hurdle, hard draws mind you. You would have to fancy Desertmartin to reach final possibly playing Rock
Magherafelt are the only Derry club who haven't won an Ulster SFC game in probably the last 20yrs. Beaten in the QtrF both years. Every other club has made either a SemiF or final, if not on the first go but in subsequent years.

marty34

When Magherafelt scored the free at the end, I said that Scotstown would work a shot and that's what happened.


They have the experience whereas Magherafelt just weren't cute enough to maybe take a card for the team.


Granted Scotstown worked the ball well under pressure off the kick out but an experienced team would have conceded a free just to get reset again.

LC

Quote from: marty34 on November 10, 2026, 07:30:50 AMWhen Magherafelt scored the free at the end, I said that Scotstown would work a shot and that's what happened.


They have the experience whereas Magherafelt just weren't cute enough to maybe take a card for the team.


Granted Scotstown worked the ball well under pressure off the kick out but an experienced team would have conceded a free just to get reset again.

Was surprised how easy the Scotstown forward won the ball, seemed to have loads of space.

marty34

Quote from: LC on November 10, 2026, 08:24:40 AM
Quote from: marty34 on November 10, 2026, 07:30:50 AMWhen Magherafelt scored the free at the end, I said that Scotstown would work a shot and that's what happened.


They have the experience whereas Magherafelt just weren't cute enough to maybe take a card for the team.


Granted Scotstown worked the ball well under pressure off the kick out but an experienced team would have conceded a free just to get reset again.

Was surprised how easy the Scotstown forward won the ball, seemed to have loads of space.



I think Magherafelt pressed well out on the ball and they had a lot of players in that middle third but Scotstown worked it well out through the gaps. Then Mc Carron with the longer kick pass.


Needed to foul a way out there - just to slow it down and reset again.

statto

Quote from: zapped on November 10, 2026, 06:22:23 AM
Quote from: outsiderlookingin on November 09, 2026, 04:45:18 PM3rd year in a row Derry champs beat at the 1st hurdle, hard draws mind you. You would have to fancy Desertmartin to reach final possibly playing Rock
Magherafelt are the only Derry club who haven't won an Ulster SFC game in probably the last 20yrs. Beaten in the QtrF both years. Every other club has made either a SemiF or final, if not on the first go but in subsequent years.

They did get really tough draws on both occasions to be fair.

Brendan

Theres that new rule if they had fouled way up the pitch at that stage the ref could have brought it forward 50 yards, basically into 2 pointer zone for Beggan

GTP

Quote from: Maghera was Black on November 09, 2026, 07:08:22 PMWhen's someone going to stand up to Beggan? He's now risen to Michael Murphy's levels of getting away with anything. He's reffing the game in the ears of umpires and referee's and going unchallenged. Hope we draw Monaghan in Ulster
The rules don't really apply to Beggan, he can take as long as he wants on frees and kickouts and time will only be added on if his side are losing. And he can take kickouts from wherever he fancies the centre point of the 20m line being a variable for him.

marty34

Quote from: Brendan on November 10, 2026, 09:19:31 AMTheres that new rule if they had fouled way up the pitch at that stage the ref could have brought it forward 50 yards, basically into 2 pointer zone for Beggan


What's that rule Brendan?