Derry Club Football & Hurling original

Started by Loup Bandit, May 08, 2007, 04:25:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

?
18 (52.9%)
?
16 (47.1%)

Total Members Voted: 34

HonDerry

Magherafelt put Slaughtneil to the sword last night in what might be the last dance for several older players.

Brendan Rogers was immense, but there just wasn't enough contribution from those around him. I've said before that Slaughtneil's younger players haven't stepped up in the same way as Magherafelt's younger players, although, in fairness, they were missing Finn, RuairĂ­ and Cathal.

Magherafelt's defence was excellent throughout. Take away Shane being allowed his 10-plus steps for the goal and the winning margin would have been even more.

In fairness to Brendan Quinn, he didn't make the game about himself this time, though I thought some marginal calls tended to go Slaughtneil's way.

The first half was too one-sided, but the game came to life for about 15 minutes when Slaughtneil enjoyed their purple patch. Outside of that, Magherafelt were comfortably the better side.

I think the chasing pack will now see Slaughtneil as the team to target if they want to break into the top four next year. Having made the semi-finals nine times in the past decade, they have some record but the age profile of them and Glen is working against them.

Another interesting one will be whether O'Malley stays. It's a long way to travel if the team is heading into a period of transition.

Topmarks

Magherafelt much the better side and will be hard to beat in the final. They are very strong defensively, power around the middle and full of running. The only thing that might trip them up is their shooting, they do make a lot of chances but they miss a good bit which keeps teams in it. I think Eoin McAvoy has been playing some stuff this championship, serious battle between him and Rogers yesterday.

On another note, I caught a bit of the junior final and I thought the lad Oran Donnelly stood out. Don't know much about him, but maybe a worth a look at u20 county level and see if he can operate at that level.

GTP

Neither the intermediate or senior game yesterday were particularly good. Slaughtneil managing only 5 scores in 60 minutes left them with no hope I'd say it was as disappointing a performance that they could have put in.
Magherafelt look good but don't score enough to put teams away, will catch them out at some stage.

Derry Man

Could Paul McFlynn be any more bias on commentary

Ryan O

On championship displays this year so far, does Conor Glass start Derry? And if so in what position.

Wildweasel74

Derry need be putting in 7/8 new players in the league, that be more important than Promotion, where u go up, then straight bck down again the following yr. As u probably be losing Rodgers/McKinless after next yr.

jb77

Not sure what i was on about last night, reading too many stats. McEvoy and CD best midfielders in the county. Barry Cassidy tried his best to inject life into Glen

Norm-Peterson

God help us having to listen to Paul McFlynn at the final calling it "Macrafelt".

theticklemister


Champion The Wonder Horse

Quote from: Wildweasel74 on October 11, 2026, 05:57:36 PMDerry need be putting in 7/8 new players in the league, that be more important than Promotion, where u go up, then straight bck down again the following yr. As u probably be losing Rodgers/McKinless after next yr.

But we don't have the luxury to bed in that number of newbies. Start 7/8 new players and we'll be playing in the tailteann cup.

Ryan O

We have to bed new players in but we don't have a division 1 safety net which is the dangerous thing. If we get up you're buying 2 years of league football to settle lads in.
Not end of the world to go up and back down again, not ideal but still gives people a chance.
Lose our first two league games and the pressure is on.


Tickle mister hit nail on the head, its absolutely all about speed, pace, power and directness.
CD and Eoin MC Evoy and eventually when the game needed it Rogers put on midfield exhibition over the weekend, just driving forward at every chance, round and back football is thankfully totally dead in the water.
Two best teams in the final, Newbridge have went up a gear, Magherafelt I think still slight favourites. Cracking final ahead.

John100


GTP

Glen's place was top 4 in Derry, which is still the case, although the manner of the defeat does leave them with plenty of questions.
The split season and the danger of slipping into Division 3 and or the Tailteann Cup make rebuilding a team very difficult for county managers. We have some continuity this year with management staying in place, giving them a chance to pick their own squad rather than the last man's but there is no guarantee new faces will get the jo done in the league.
Glass and McGuigan didn't look like starting county players over the weekend hopefully form is temporary and class permanent and they get back to the top level performances they can produce.

John100

Quote from: GTP on October 12, 2026, 01:09:43 PMGlen's place was top 4 in Derry, which is still the case, although the manner of the defeat does leave them with plenty of questions.
The split season and the danger of slipping into Division 3 and or the Tailteann Cup make rebuilding a team very difficult for county managers. We have some continuity this year with management staying in place, giving them a chance to pick their own squad rather than the last man's but there is no guarantee new faces will get the jo done in the league.
Glass and McGuigan didn't look like starting county players over the weekend hopefully form is temporary and class permanent and they get back to the top level performances they can produce.

Key word WAS, Glen seem to think they deserve to be in the all ireland club final every year, they are not at this level no longer, although they have a few young players they are begining to look like a top 8-4 team , not top 4. Next year is a long way away but I can already see them being knocked out before the semi final.

Ryan O

Not sure I would just be as harsh as others on Glen.
Couple players off form but by no means at the age to retire ie. Glass, Ethan, Conleth Mc G partner that with players injured or not fully fit, Mc Faul, Dougan, Danny Mc Dermott.
Jody Mc Dermott and Conor Convery having to fill roles that probably not best suited too. There by no means finished.

I do think we have probably slipped into a top two bracket with a chasing group of clubs all capable of being eachother on their day if they give it another push in the below order:
Bellaghy
Slaughtneil
Lavey
Glen
Kilrea
Ballinderry
Steelstown
Swatragh
Glenullin
Banagher.