All stars 25

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

Morgan was. Probably about it.

[Armagh18]

Morgan was. Probably about it.

Make up for the one he robbed in 2024. Thought Shane Ryan had a brilliant year

[WT4E]

Morgan was. Probably about it.

Make up for the one he robbed in 2024. Thought Shane Ryan had a brilliant year

Agains it's just Armagh hating tyrone! Those little 2 all Ireland minnows. One of them lucky

[Armagh18]

Morgan was. Probably about it.

Make up for the one he robbed in 2024. Thought Shane Ryan had a brilliant year

Agains it's just Armagh hating tyrone! Those little 2 all Ireland minnows. One of them lucky

[thejuice]

Well done Oisin Conaty. Delighted for him.

Rest of the team probably as expected, Meath maybe underrepresented but not sure who you'd take out.

This is obviously bate?

Morris maybe hard done by? Meath topped their group and beat Dublin, Kerry and Galway in the one year, obviously didn't turn up against Donegal but they'd a good year.

Wasn't expecting more than one and it was always going to be Sean Rafferty. You could make a case for Morris given the injury he came back from but it's hard to look past Kerry and donegal. If Meath hadn't got trounced in the semifinal we might have got one more.

[Armagh18]

Well done Oisin Conaty. Delighted for him.

Rest of the team probably as expected, Meath maybe underrepresented but not sure who you'd take out.

This is obviously bate?

Morris maybe hard done by? Meath topped their group and beat Dublin, Kerry and Galway in the one year, obviously didn't turn up against Donegal but they'd a good year.

Wasn't expecting more than one and it was always going to be Sean Rafferty. You could make a case for Morris given the injury he came back from but it's hard to look past Kerry and donegal. If Meath hadn't got trounced in the semifinal we might have got one more.

Yeah fair enough, maybe an argument ahead of Mulroy but was mever going to happen.

The O'Donnells were better than Murphy for me but again was never going to be them over him.

[rodney trotter]

No, thought Murphy done enough for a All Star.Wasnt good in the final but few Donegal men were. I thought Morris or O'Donnell should got in ,infront of Mulroy. Still think Rafferty best keeper but the Kerry melt down counted against him.

Murphy was good in the first half of the All Ireland final. He didn't have enough support. Gallen didn't perform.

[Captain Obvious]

No, thought Murphy done enough for a All Star.Wasnt good in the final but few Donegal men were. I thought Morris or O'Donnell should got in ,infront of Mulroy. Still think Rafferty best keeper but the Kerry melt down counted against him.

Murphy was good in the first half of the All Ireland final. He didn't have enough support. Gallen didn't perform.

Gallen did OK. Scored 0-3 from play and set up another couple of points, hooked off on 45 minutes and his replacement had little or no impact.

[Captain Obvious]

OP can update the thread title to 26.

I'll take a stab at towards who could be selected.

If Kerry win the All-Ireland final

Shane Murphy (Kerry)
Jason Foley (Kerry)
Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
Enda Hession (Mayo)
Charlie McMorrow (Dublin)
Dara McDonnell (Louth)
Mike Breen (Kerry)
Mark O'Shea (Kerry)
Joe O'Connor (Kerry)
Brandon Kelly (Westmeath)
Paudie Clifford (Kerry)
Kobe McDonald (Mayo)
David Clifford (Kerry)
Dylan Geaney (Kerry)
Ryan O'Donoghue (Mayo)


If Mayo win the All-Ireland final

Jack Livingstone (Mayo)
Jason Foley, (Kerry)
Donnacha McHugh (Mayo)
Enda Hession (Mayo)
Charlie McMorrow (Dublin)
Dara McDonnell (Louth)
David McBrien (Mayo)
Mark O'Shea (Kerry)
Joe O'Connor (Kerry)
Brandon Kelly (Westmeath
Darragh Beirne (Mayo)
Kobe McDonald (Mayo)
David Clifford (Kerry)
Dylan Geaney (Kerry)
Ryan O'Donoghue (Mayo)

The selection process as ever the winner  gets 7 or 8.  Semi-finalists Louth and Dublin should get at least 1.

All star to Westmeath winning Leinster against the odds and I believe only David Clifford scored more from play in the championship than Brandon Kelly. Finally I think it will be a rare year of no Ulster player getting All Star.

[rodney trotter]

O Callaghan was more impressive then o Donoghue in the championship.  Played better opposition then O Donoghue.
Niall Scully would be unlucky to miss out. Ronan Wallace was solid for Westmeath in the half back line

[gallsman]

Joe O'Connor won't get one this year.

[blanketattack]

Goalie- Livingstone,I presume?

[Smokin Joe]

Goalie- Livingstone,I presume?

Yes

[AustinPowers]

All star to Westmeath winning Leinster against the odds and I believe only David Clifford scored more from play in the championship than Brandon Kelly. Finally I think it will be a rare year of no Ulster player getting All Star.

I hear that  line trotted out  alot. Same when it comes to AI semi finalists. You always seem to hear  "no Ulster teams in the semis this year". There has been  plenty of  times  where there's been no Leinster or Connacht  teams.

[Brendan]

Only 1 provincial winner going deep into the championship but surely can't overlook the provincial campaigns Roscommon and moreso Westmeath have had