Down Club Hurling & Football

[Leftmidfield]

Hot of the press
Kilcoo is appealing the sending off on Saturday and a delegation of high-ranking club officials will be in headquarters this weekend.

It's a shame for choc that he's missing, but it'll be yet another absolute stain on the GAA's disciplinary processes if an appeal is successful.

For if smacking a man in the jaw on national tv doesn't deserve a suspension, then we should just get rid of suspensions completely.

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.

From what I could see it was a shoulder to the chest that warranted a yellow. Linesman who was consulted by the ref could not have had a clear view

[thewobbler]

I saw different but I'm happy to admit I'm wrong if it's the case.

Interesting that tg4's highlights of the game include that the free was called back and thrown up, but doesn't show the actual incident.

[ardtole]

There is a whatts app of the incident doing the rounds, it was a yellow card offence and no more than that. David Gough the linesman has a tendancy to seek the limelight in my opinion.

[Truth hurts]

I have been one to call out Kilcoos antics in appealing things over the years especially the minor final a few years ago which was sickening, also appealed big Greenan's suspension from this year final when he was running around after Ballyholland lads like Captain America but I do not think Choc warrants a suspension. Absolute stupidity in his part for getting involved with the Barrs man but I do not think he should miss the final.

Down fanatic, would you be favour of a few reserve sides entering division 4?

[manwithnoplan]

Hot of the press
Kilcoo is appealing the sending off on Saturday and a delegation of high-ranking club officials will be in headquarters this weekend.

It's a shame for choc that he's missing, but it'll be yet another absolute stain on the GAA's disciplinary processes if an appeal is successful.

For if smacking a man in the jaw on national tv doesn't deserve a suspension, then we should just get rid of suspensions completely.

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.

Which he had no need to do, and years of acting the big lad and getting away with it have led him to believe he could do that again. Stupidity of that level should be punished.

[urbangael]

Tg4 showed the incident. Choc shouldered the Barrs player. 100% he will get that overturned and rightly so. Co Board proposals for leagues will likely go though and will mean a lot of meaningless games half way into it.
Fear for our boys with Galway coming to town on sat night!

[Johnnysboys]

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.
[/quote]

Goading a man ready to hit a free kick and Choc did not approve... Are you shitting me?? It was Kilcoo that started that shite in our county shouting and roaring when men are standing over a free and 3,4,5 men in close proximity to the kicker shouting like they are trying to organise men around them.. Didn't approve - don't make me laugh. Got taste of his own medicine. Red card is a red card - it should stand. But I still expect them to beat Crokes by 6+ points without him..

[maldini]

Is there promotion from 2 to 1 and 3 to 2 under the proposed new leagues? Or just relegation the other way?

It'll be another year where a lot of clubs aren't taking the league serious

[Sandstorm]

Do you think for one minute that Kilcoo don't take the league seriously? They blood the young lads in the league and that is why they are in the All Ireland final next week. Other teams need to follow their lead if they want to be successful. I wish my own club would.

[Truth hurts]

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.

Goading a man ready to hit a free kick and Choc did not approve... Are you shitting me?? It was Kilcoo that started that shite in our county shouting and roaring when men are standing over a free and 3,4,5 men in close proximity to the kicker shouting like they are trying to organise men around them.. Didn't approve - don't make me laugh. Got taste of his own medicine. Red card is a red card - it should stand. But I still expect them to beat Crokes by 6+ points without him..
[/quote]

LOL Say it how it is then 

[manwithnoplan]

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.

Goading a man ready to hit a free kick and Choc did not approve... Are you shitting me?? It was Kilcoo that started that shite in our county shouting and roaring when men are standing over a free and 3,4,5 men in close proximity to the kicker shouting like they are trying to organise men around them.. Didn't approve - don't make me laugh. Got taste of his own medicine. Red card is a red card - it should stand. But I still expect them to beat Crokes by 6+ points without him..
[/quote]

Exactly, it's almost like some people are trying to paint him as a virtuous warrior who was standing up for sportsmanship. Acted outside of the rules, completely unnecessarily, against something his own club has been known for. Though maybe Moran has put the lid on that to a certain extent and increased the focus on their own game, and low and behold he got them to two all Ireland finals.... Wouldn't it be great for Down to have the senior club champions, even though I'm sure not everyone in the county would be a fan given past antics and reputations, it would surely motivate others to reach new levels in an attempt to beat them this year. I mean, there is no bigger scalp to claim in club football than knocking out the all Ireland champions in our championship.

[Lecale Gael]

There should only be junior bs in div 4 a and 4 b
The bigger clubs premier reserves shud be nowhere near the ACFl
Their thirds maybe

Ccc proposal is a disastrous quick fix. Wouldn't be in favour of it at all

[Lecale Gael]

It was not a smack in the jaw, it was a shoulder and as deets said the Barrs man was goading PD  when he was ready to hit the free which Choc did not approve of so he shouldered him.

Goading a man ready to hit a free kick and Choc did not approve... Are you shitting me?? It was Kilcoo that started that shite in our county shouting and roaring when men are standing over a free and 3,4,5 men in close proximity to the kicker shouting like they are trying to organise men around them.. Didn't approve - don't make me laugh. Got taste of his own medicine. Red card is a red card - it should stand. But I still expect them to beat Crokes by 6+ points without him..

LOL Say it how it is then 
[/quote]

When goading began ref should have stopped PD and advanced the ball 13 m. Not allowed to distract a free taker under the newly introduced rule in 2021

[ardtole]

He penalised Kilcoo for the very same thing about ten mins before the end of the game. The Barrs free kicker seemed to loose his footing as he struck the ball, the ball hit the upright and went out of play, but the ref moved the ball up for someone shouting at the free taker.

[Truth hurts]

There should only be junior bs in div 4 a and 4 b
The bigger clubs premier reserves shud be nowhere near the ACFl
Their thirds maybe

Ccc proposal is a disastrous quick fix. Wouldn't be in favour of it at all

If you took the top 25 out of the big clubs then you have left with a sprinkling of seconds and mostly thirds players as the games would take place at the same time.

I reckon that only Burren, Kilcoo, Mayobridge, Clonduff, and Carryduff would have the strength to do this. I am not even sure if they would have the appetite for it bar Burren who are losing more players than they are keeping by all accounts. Those named clubs' thirds team would compete well in division 4.

The county board should try to encourage more teams into the senior championship with amalgamations from div 3 and 4 clubs only

Lecale
Mourne
Iveagh lower
Iveagh upper

could people see this work? it was never given the right opportunity years ago