A United Ireland. Opening up the discussion.

Started by winghalfback, May 27, 2015, 03:16:23 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

weareros

Hopefully the finer details will be looked at and won't be insurmountable.

Some of the costlier things:
How much of UK' £3 trillion national debt will be passed off to Dublin. Per head of population, around €100 billion on top the €200 billion already servicing.

North's annual fiscal deficit is a problem. Dublin has a surplus every year but if corporate tax went south, Dublin would have a deficit too.

Motability scheme - would Dublin keeping covering the 50,000 and also then have to extend to those in 26 counties.

Healthcare - is the proposed Slainte Care going to go down same sorry road as NHS.

Ara feck it, just get on with it. An island of 7 million people is easily sustainable between agri-food, tourism, and all the FDI that comes to Ireland because it's a safe country, highly educated, access to EU, speaks clearer English than the English (Conor Haughey notwithstanding).



OakLeaf


Rossfan

2026 the year of the 9 Cups

armaghniac

#5193
Quote from: weareros on October 31, 2026, 01:10:40 PMHow much of UK' £3 trillion national debt will be passed off to Dublin. Per head of population, around €100 billion on top the €200 billion already servicing.

Since Ireland has lower interest rates than the UK, currently 1.8% lower, they should do something on the debt. Someone can work out the mechanics, but offering Irish Euro debt for an appropriate amount of UK sterling debt would do the job. This would save London more than it costs Dublin.

So play hard ball on pensions etc, but do make a deal on debt.
MAGA Make Armagh Great Again

Rossfan

From D'Examiner

Calls for a border poll by 2030 were never realistic and were more an attempt to shore up Sinn Féin's party support than to unite Ireland, Taoiseach Micheál Martin has claimed.

"It was never realistic, and there was no proper engagement with people, it was just an 'our way or the highway' approach, and it seems to me that's the Sinn Féin approach," Mr Martin said.

"I do believe it was more about courting the short-term electoral base as opposed to a genuine reach-out to all voices on the island."

Mr Martin was speaking to the Irish Examiner after he announced to the Fianna Fáil parliamentary party the Futures Study Initiative to research the potential of a united Ireland.


The body will examine three core scenarios: a 32-county all-Ireland State; an all-island State with a devolved government in Northern Ireland; and maintaining the status quo.

The Taoiseach said the initiative would be led by an expert panel which "would oversee an independent, evidence-based approach to all of these issues".

"Whereas certain elements are advocating a border poll in a couple of years without due diligence, and also in a victorious, triumphalist way, 'our time has come, ignore the views of others', our view is we have to work with the unionists and loyalists, we have to build trust and we have to have all voices at the table and all voices have to be heard."


Everything before the Good Friday Agreement had failed, Mr Martin said, and there was no point in "nationalists talking to each other and saying we're great".

"Unity has to be about persuasion, and it has to be about ensuring that we live together in peace and harmony on the island," he said.

The initiative is part of the Shared Island Initiative, which has already allocated more than €1bn to projects such as the Narrow Water Bridge, the Ulster Canal, and improved rail links between Belfast, Derry, and Dublin.

2026 the year of the 9 Cups

Armagh18

He's such a sickening p***k. He'd be saying the same thing in 2130 if he was about

AustinPowers

"Unity has to be about persuasion"


It doesn't matter  what you offer the vast vast majority of unionists. You'll never persuade  them  to be in a United Ireland any more than you'll persuade someone in the 26 counties  to be a part  of  the UK.

Kick the can  perpetually down that road, Mehole.

Rossfan

2026 the year of the 9 Cups

Milltown Row2

Quote from: AustinPowers on November 06, 2026, 06:38:17 PM"Unity has to be about persuasion"


It doesn't matter  what you offer the vast vast majority of unionists. You'll never persuade  them  to be in a United Ireland any more than you'll persuade someone in the 26 counties  to be a part  of  the UK.

Kick the can  perpetually down that road, Mehole.

The clue is in the name, UNIONISTS.. it's like convincing a republican to stay British
None of us are getting out of here alive, so please stop treating yourself like an after thought.

weareros

Assume BelTel will have United Ireland results this weekend or are they too busy with a full front page profile of Jamie Bryson as the most popular leader in Unionism.

OakLeaf

Quote from: AustinPowers on November 06, 2026, 06:38:17 PM"Unity has to be about persuasion"


It doesn't matter  what you offer the vast vast majority of unionists. You'll never persuade  them  to be in a United Ireland any more than you'll persuade someone in the 26 counties  to be a part  of  the UK.

Kick the can  perpetually down that road, Mehole.

Technically unity comes down to two simple referendums North and South of the border. If both of those have a simple majority then that's that. The starting position would be a 32 county Ireland based on the structure of the 26 today, i.e. fold the 6 into the 26.

That said, it is much more preferable to have a good sense of what an agreed UI would look like, before the vote. That will involve negotiation and possibly a lot of it. However, make no mistake about it, there will only be so much that can be done to appease unionists before it would be unacceptable to nationalists North of the border. If Nationalists have the numbers to win a border poll, the unionists negotiating position will be limited. Thats why they should be engaging now. Will they? Doubtful.

tiempo

The EU will come to the table with a unification fund, if only to shaft England over Brexit

Rossfan

England will possibly be back in the EU by then?
Meanwhile a Blueshirt blueprint on the way

https://www.rte.ie/news/politics/2026/1107/1598338-fine-gael-ard-fheis/
2026 the year of the 9 Cups

marty34

Recent Lucid poll had British Andy Burnham (49%) and Chris Bryant (46%) more popular with nationalists than Micheál Martin (32%).


How embarrassing is that for 'republican' Martin and FF?


Just says it all.

Armagh18

Seen a few clips of simple Simon last, good to see him call out casual drug users, he'd the usual wee gimpy dig at the Sinn Fein bogeyman. Did he mention a UI at all?