Club Championships 2025

[SouthOfThe Bann]

Some finish. Ref was totally right to bring it up. Happened against Tyrone in the league a few times so guessing it doesn't matter that the player is trying his best to give it back since I've seen refs call frees exactly like that all year? Anyway it's a rule that a majority of people wanted apparently. Was never in favour of it myself but rules are rules! Harsh on Sherlock

How was he right to bring it up?

[Milltown Row2]

Not sure about the 50m infringement

Was a foul for sure, he'd been consistent on that in the game..

But the Dingle lad was 'trying it on' and the ref bought it!

[Captain Obvious]

That's bullshit of the highest degree there.

Questionable foul in the first place

What a nonsense way to win and lose a provincial title. The over the top rules added into the game in short space of time has made poor refs more confused than ever.

Ballyboden will take care of that Dingle side next.

[giveherlong]

That ref may hang his head in shame, The Cork man was fouled at the end,O'Connor was on top of the man
and he gives the free the other way playing for a draw.

Yeah Sherlock was fouled in top corner in the second last play
No free given

[skeog]

Robbery worse than 2011 in Croker against Louth.

[AustinPowers]

Watched that again.

Dingle no 12 with a  slight push on Finbarr's man. He was going down anyway , so not sure if there was enough force in the  push .

Regardless, No 5 picks up ball to give it back , and Dingle man barges  into him , crying  to ref for  it to be moved up. Which he did

That was absolute robbery.

[Armagh18]

Watched that again.

Dingle no 12 with a  slight push on Finbarr's man. He was going down anyway , so not sure if there was enough force in the  push .

Regardless, No 5 picks up ball to give it back , and Dingle man barges  into him , crying  to ref for  it to be moved up. Which he did

That was absolute robbery.

Naive, no need to lift it, let the man go and get the ball himself.

[thebigfullforward]

Some finish. Ref was totally right to bring it up. Happened against Tyrone in the league a few times so guessing it doesn't matter that the player is trying his best to give it back since I've seen refs call frees exactly like that all year? Anyway it's a rule that a majority of people wanted apparently. Was never in favour of it myself but rules are rules! Harsh on Sherlock

How was he right to bring it up?

Because I've seen those frees being given all year by numerous different refs. Couldn't count on 2 hands how many times I've seen frees being given for that. So assume they must be applying it right or else the rule is a balls and the refs don't know what they're at

[SouthOfThe Bann]

Some finish. Ref was totally right to bring it up. Happened against Tyrone in the league a few times so guessing it doesn't matter that the player is trying his best to give it back since I've seen refs call frees exactly like that all year? Anyway it's a rule that a majority of people wanted apparently. Was never in favour of it myself but rules are rules! Harsh on Sherlock

How was he right to bring it up?

Because I've seen those frees being given all year by numerous different refs. Couldn't count on 2 hands how many times I've seen frees being given for that. So assume they must be applying it right or else the rule is a balls and the refs don't know what they're at

The free was 50 50 could have went either way.

Barrs player couldn't have done whole pile more to give it back... If he drops it then it's definitely getting brought up.

In the spirit of the game it's totally wrong.

Barrs should have had it won anyways.

[Wildweasel74]

How was it not a foul with M O'Connor lying on top of the Cork man.

[thebigfullforward]

Some finish. Ref was totally right to bring it up. Happened against Tyrone in the league a few times so guessing it doesn't matter that the player is trying his best to give it back since I've seen refs call frees exactly like that all year? Anyway it's a rule that a majority of people wanted apparently. Was never in favour of it myself but rules are rules! Harsh on Sherlock

How was he right to bring it up?

Because I've seen those frees being given all year by numerous different refs. Couldn't count on 2 hands how many times I've seen frees being given for that. So assume they must be applying it right or else the rule is a balls and the refs don't know what they're at

The free was 50 50 could have went either way.

Barrs player couldn't have done whole pile more to give it back... If he drops it then it's definitely getting brought up.

In the spirit of the game it's totally wrong.

Barrs should have had it won anyways.

Sorry don't mean the actual free I mean it being brought up 50m. Have seen a minor player for my club being penalised for throwing the ball back to the opposition player to chest instead of running the 5 metres back be penalised for it. So I'm guessing the ref is in the right for bringing it forward 50m since I've seen it being given so many times

[Blowitupref]

Some finish. Ref was totally right to bring it up. Happened against Tyrone in the league a few times so guessing it doesn't matter that the player is trying his best to give it back since I've seen refs call frees exactly like that all year? Anyway it's a rule that a majority of people wanted apparently. Was never in favour of it myself but rules are rules! Harsh on Sherlock

How was he right to bring it up?

It wasn't right, it was an error by the ref.

[trileacman]

Anyone a clip of the last action?

[JoG2]

There's always 1 contrarian

Poor by the ref

[thebigfullforward]

There's always 1 contrarian

Poor by the ref

Not a contrarian. Have just seen that decision made numerous times over the course of the season by different refs so assume it was right. Maybe going by the comments here not all the new rules were the best thing since sliced bread? Did try to say when it was first proposed that this rule would be a balls but sure everyone was creaming themselves over the new rules so who cares