NFL Division 1 2024

[RedHand88]

That's a good call for the square ball.

Yep. Bang on. Its the sort of one that could have been missed.

[marty34]

Tyrone deserved the win. Played well when down to 14.

[Captain Obvious]

That's a good call for the square ball.

Thought it was a very debatable call however Tyrone deserved the win.

[tyrone08]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

[Milltown Row2]

That Roscommon goal looked ok but disallowed.

Which part was a square ball?

The final pass

First pass looked or could have been off side too, tight margins and well done on ref taking his time to give it

Offside?

Was flicking between the soccer and bog ball 

Square ball

[Milltown Row2]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

He didn't 'catch' or collect the ball to throw it

[Cunny Funt]

Good and very comfortable win for Mayo, started with a strong team and moving very well for January. Galway poor and can't have many complaints about the margin of defeat.



In the 2nd live game I thought that goal should have stood for Roscommon but would have been a robbery had they got anything out of that game.

Tyrone missing some important players and their replacements all did well (helps to have All Ireland U20 team to pick from)

Roscommon lack of strength in depth without Enda Smith,Harney and Brigids players etc showed today.

[seafoid]

This is pretty pathetic from Roscommon so far. Extra man and offering absolutely nothing.

Roscommon struggling with the second album but it's only the League

[Hound]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

[tbrick18]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

I actually thought black card was correct and the yellow leading to red was correct too. It was a high tackle.
Was never a square ball.
Poor enough game.
Tyrone will be happy with the young lads and the points.
Roscommon might be happy given how close they were without so many players, but they didn't play well.

[SouthOfThe Bann]

It's amazing how different counties produce different player types.

For example Mayo produce unbelievable powerful runners but haven't produced a real classy forward since McDonald... Moran O'Connor O'Donoghue Conroy all decent but you wouldn't call them classy elegant footballers... Having said that there's not many in the country.

My home county Cavan have struggled to produce that type of player also.

1. Clifford
2. McGuigan
3. Shane Walsh very inconsistent though.
4. Dara Canavan starting to show signs
5. Rian O'Neill when on it
6. King Con
7. Seanie O'Shea
8. Conor Mcmanus

[weareros]

Roscommon black card - correct call
Tyrone red card - incorrect call
Roscommon square ball - incorrect call

Both teams very good at pretending to be injured when there was nothing wrong with them. 

Had a look at it again. Definitely the correct call.
The square ball for the final play is tight though I think it might just be one.
However, before that the ball comes in and a Roscommon player starts in the square, then runs across the square to collect the ball.
Tough one for Roscommon but officials got it right.

I don't think they did get it right. Glennon was in square but he collected ball outside square. It's not soccer. It's only a square ball in GAA when you are in square before the ball. The ball to Glennon never made it into square. He then quickly passed to Robbie Dolan who was also outside square and you can see from behind goal that Connolly was still outside square when Dolan released ball. I suspect that was the play umpires ruled a square ball, but was not correct.

But Tyrone were deserving winners. Got their scores much easier and were hungrier for dirty ball. We were poor. Did we win one Tyrone kickout with an extra man. Morgan a close man of the match to Canavan who was top class.

[Wildweasel74]

There was a point in the first half which just goes over the bar,the keeper may have got it but a Tyrone player contested the ball with him.Replay shows him well inside the square before the ball even kicked.

[marty34]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

That's the way all passes across the square are finished to the net nowadays.

[tyrone08]

He threw it into the net never mind the square ball. It wasn't a palm or a fist. Both hands were on the ball and he threw it in

That's the way all passes across the square are finished to the net nowadays.

Normally its a palm into the net at head height or so, as the ball was nearly below the knee it looked like he threw it in rather than palmed it in. Square ball call was tight but as Conn got a ridiculous red card it balanced itself out