Ran a test for 2005 and 2006 league and Championships. No weighting for 2006 being more recent (equal value for both years). My Rules were: Add total league points, with double for Div 1A and 1B; 2 points for losing league semi-final, 4 points for losing league final, 5 points for winning league. 3 points for provincial championship win, 5 points for provincial win. 2 points for every qualifier win. 5 points for quarter-final win, 7 for semi-final win, 10 for taking Sam home.
Here's the rankings with point totals:
1 Kerry 96
2 Mayo 74
3 Tyrone 72
4 Armagh 71
5 Dublin 60
6 Laois 51
7 Galway 50
8 Cork 47
9 Derry 43
10 Meath 39
11 Down 37
11 Wexford 37
13 Kildare 36
14 Donegal 34
15 Fermanagh 33
16 Offaly 32
17 Monaghan 29
18 Westmeath 28
19 Cavan 27
20 Louth 26
20 Limerick 26
22 Roscommon 22
23 Longford 21
24 Sligo 20
25 Clare 18
26 Leitrim 16
26 Carlow 16
28 Antrim 12
29 Tipperary 8
30 Wicklow 7
31 Waterford 6
32 London 0
All work filed under "Fodder for the Pub, Winter 2006".
Here's the rankings with point totals:
1 Kerry 96
2 Mayo 74
3 Tyrone 72
4 Armagh 71
5 Dublin 60
6 Laois 51
7 Galway 50
8 Cork 47
9 Derry 43
10 Meath 39
11 Down 37
11 Wexford 37
13 Kildare 36
14 Donegal 34
15 Fermanagh 33
16 Offaly 32
17 Monaghan 29
18 Westmeath 28
19 Cavan 27
20 Louth 26
20 Limerick 26
22 Roscommon 22
23 Longford 21
24 Sligo 20
25 Clare 18
26 Leitrim 16
26 Carlow 16
28 Antrim 12
29 Tipperary 8
30 Wicklow 7
31 Waterford 6
32 London 0
All work filed under "Fodder for the Pub, Winter 2006".