Man Utd Thread:

[johnneycool]

Penalty. Had that been at the other end, Fergie would have, well, done a Fergie.

I didn't see that so clear in the game. That's a definite stone wall penalty. The ball was goalbound from 1m out.

Ball to hand FFS, 

[Minder]

I see some Utd fan in England phoned the police and asked them to arrest the ref 

[ballinaman]

I see some Utd fan in England phoned the police and asked them to arrest the ref 

Serious?

[BennyCake]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jH5t58FCs3k

Whats the difference between above video and the one below?

There's a hell of alot of difference. Nani used his foot to try and get the ball. Ebuoe's foot was nowhere near the ball.

[GalwayBayBoy]

Paddy Crerand took it well anyway.

http://audioboo.fm/boos/1249812-former-player-paddy-crerand-reacts-to-man-united-s-exit-from-the-champions-league?playlist_direction=reversed#t=8m3s

[trueblue1234]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jH5t58FCs3k

Whats the difference between above video and the one below?

There's a hell of alot of difference. Nani used his foot to try and get the ball. Ebuoe's foot was nowhere near the ball.

Both feet were too near the opposition players. That's the problem.

[EC Unique]

I see some Utd fan in England phoned the police and asked them to arrest the ref 

Serious?

Heard that on the radio there..   Wingnut!

[BennyCake]

There's a hell of alot of difference. Nani used his foot to try and get the ball. Ebuoe's foot was nowhere near the ball.

Both feet were too near the opposition players. That's the problem.

OK, if that's the case, why isn't this a sending off?

http://m.youtube.com/index?desktop_uri=%2F&gl=GB#/watch?v=pnSm8vzpwxA

[Billys Boots]

Em, he didn't kick anyone???

[nrico2006]

Why wasn't the Madrid keeper sent off for punching Vidic?

[Shamrock Shore]

Calm down calm down!

[BennyCake]

Em, he didn't kick anyone???

Yes, but isnt his foot too high? Too near the opposition? Dangerous play?

[laoislad]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jH5t58FCs3k

Whats the difference between above video and the one below?

There's a hell of alot of difference. Nani used his foot to try and get the ball. Ebuoe's foot was nowhere near the ball.

Surely the point is neither connected with the ball and both kick a player in the chest?
Both very similar for me.
It was ok though because the decision went in United's favour so it's quickly forgotten by their fans.
Rio is leading the pack on the Ref to get Eboue sent off,same player was leader of the pack last night complaining about Nani being sent off.

[magpie seanie]

It wasn't just the red card. Sure their keeper almost decapitated Vidic. Should have been a penalty and a red card. Also a clear penalty near the end on Young I think by Ramos who should have been sent off in both games. If Rafael's was a penalty then United should have had at least 2 more penalties - you can't give penalties for the ball hitting a guys arm.

It shouldn't have been a red card in a million years. The reaction of the Madrid players and management was enough to tell you that. Absolutely gutted cos United had their measure. Ferguson and his team had the tactics right, they never looked like scoring. Often in the past United have been tactically inept but not here.

Roy Keane is a legend but he is simply wrong about the red card incident.

[J70]

Em, he didn't kick anyone???

Yes, but isnt his foot too high? Too near the opposition? Dangerous play?

Looks like its not just EC, so you lads must actually be serious with this shite!