Mayo V Monaghan Qualifier

Started by joemamas, May 23, 2022, 03:17:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

From the Bunker

Listened to the game on Madwest.

Martin Carney is comedy gold!

full moon

Cassidy got escort out few Monaghan fans gonna go for him it looked like

Captain Obvious

A few penalty calls that didn't go Monaghan's way towards the end. Mayo went 21 minutes without a score in that 2nd half and still won by 4. That should be the end of Banty, bizarre appointment to begin with.

greensandgold1

Thought it was a penalty
But why did he not try to bury it
Looked like he wanted to be fouled

straightred

Quote from: clarshack on June 04, 2022, 05:39:04 PM
Should have been penalty to Monaghan?
yes and even after that non call there was a 13m free. He gave neither.

J70

Didn't look much of a foul to me.

Think Cassidy got it right. Let's see what the replays show.

Shocking blind pass that led to it though.

thewobbler

Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.

straightred

Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

yellowcard

Cassidy is a poor referee but Monaghan can blame nobody but themselves. No doubt they will probably blame Cassidy and they may have reason to feel aggrieved but would need to have a good look at themselves first and their negative approach. If they had faced a better team today Mayo were out but all they had to do was get over todays match and they will be in better shape for the next match now.   

befair

Poor game, looks like the end of the great Mayo team, the only team to give the Dubs a match. Deserved the win, Monaghan too quick to blame the ref.
But Monaghan shouldn't be down-hearted; with a small population, they've been punching above their weight for years, are always competitive, and in McManus, have one of the true greats.

thewobbler

Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:47:34 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

The overturned 45 wasn't a major decision.

I can't see the Keegan tackle a penalty from every angle. The forward took a bump and hit the ground. That's not a foul if it happens in reverse so can't be a penalty. Imho.

straightred

Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:51:33 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:47:34 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

The overturned 45 wasn't a major decision.
I

I can't see the Keegan tackle a penalty from every angle. The forward took a bump and hit the ground. That's not a foul if it happens in reverse so can't be a penalty. Imho.
Mayo scored straight from the non 45 - that's why i highlighted it. That was one example. There were lots of others. The penalty. He wrapped him with both arms and let go. As McGuinness said its a foul anywhere else on the field. Then when the ball broke there was a clear push for a 13m free. He's a terrible ref - has been for a long time if indeed he was ever any good. Today he seemed to be on a mission and Mayo were on the right side of it.

yellowcard

Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:56:27 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:51:33 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:47:34 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

The overturned 45 wasn't a major decision.
I

I can't see the Keegan tackle a penalty from every angle. The forward took a bump and hit the ground. That's not a foul if it happens in reverse so can't be a penalty. Imho.
Mayo scored straight from the non 45 - that's why i highlighted it. That was one example. There were lots of others. The penalty. He wrapped him with both arms and let go. As McGuinness said its a foul anywhere else on the field. Then when the ball broke there was a clear push for a 13m free. He's a terrible ref - has been for a long time if indeed he was ever any good. Today he seemed to be on a mission and Mayo were on the right side of it.

I don't think Banty will be sending him a Christmas card this year anyway, there was an accumulation of bad decisions that all seemed to go against Monaghan. 

befair

Quote from: yellowcard on June 04, 2022, 06:00:08 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:56:27 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:51:33 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:47:34 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

The overturned 45 wasn't a major decision.
I

I can't see the Keegan tackle a penalty from every angle. The forward took a bump and hit the ground. That's not a foul if it happens in reverse so can't be a penalty. Imho.
Mayo scored straight from the non 45 - that's why i highlighted it. That was one example. There were lots of others. The penalty. He wrapped him with both arms and let go. As McGuinness said its a foul anywhere else on the field. Then when the ball broke there was a clear push for a 13m free. He's a terrible ref - has been for a long time if indeed he was ever any good. Today he seemed to be on a mission and Mayo were on the right side of it.

I don't think Banty will be sending him a Christmas card this year anyway, there was an accumulation of bad decisions that all seemed to go against Monaghan.
McManus kicked two very scorable frees wide; can't blame the ref for that.

yellowcard

Quote from: befair on June 04, 2022, 06:03:39 PM
Quote from: yellowcard on June 04, 2022, 06:00:08 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:56:27 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:51:33 PM
Quote from: straightred on June 04, 2022, 05:47:34 PM
Quote from: thewobbler on June 04, 2022, 05:42:37 PM
Every single major decision by the ref in that match went Mqyo's way.

But more importantly, every single one of them was correct.

Cassidy was superb. Actually understand the game.

——

On a side note, Monaghan deserve to go out. Any time they pressed Mayo, Mayo looked nervy. But no let's not do that again. Let's instead retreat inside the '45 and let the run the clock down for whatever the f**k reason nobody will ever be able to explain.

Idiotic from Monaghan. Leave the championship with a whimper.
I'm sorry but that's nonsense. He overruled a 45 - was that correct (clue - it wasn't). Mayo got soft decision after soft decision. Monaghan didn't.  Its a penalty (not the foot block) but the other one definatly was

The overturned 45 wasn't a major decision.
I

I can't see the Keegan tackle a penalty from every angle. The forward took a bump and hit the ground. That's not a foul if it happens in reverse so can't be a penalty. Imho.
Mayo scored straight from the non 45 - that's why i highlighted it. That was one example. There were lots of others. The penalty. He wrapped him with both arms and let go. As McGuinness said its a foul anywhere else on the field. Then when the ball broke there was a clear push for a 13m free. He's a terrible ref - has been for a long time if indeed he was ever any good. Today he seemed to be on a mission and Mayo were on the right side of it.

I don't think Banty will be sending him a Christmas card this year anyway, there was an accumulation of bad decisions that all seemed to go against Monaghan.
McManus kicked two very scorable frees wide; can't blame the ref for that.

Indeed, Monaghan would need to look at themselves first and foremost, they only have themselves to blame. But the best referees are the ones you don't really notice and unfortunately Cassidy tends to get noticed a lot.