The OFFICIAL Liverpool Supporters thread

[gawa316]

If City are serious about Keane then Liverpool should get their money back but if it's Spurs he returns to expect to get severly shafted on your £18M.  Was that figure dependent on appearances or how much have you paid to date?

Can't remember where I heard it or read it but think we have only paid 6 million or something like that

[Minder]

I read on another forum that Keane was told not to turn up on Sunday after he exchanged words with Benitez after the drawn league game on Monday night. Could be horses*it but it all sounds ominous for Keane...........

[Maiden1]

I'm sure this has been asked on previous pages but I can't be bothered reading all the pages but why did Rafa sign Keane and then not play him and look like he has never rated him?   I could understand if Houllier had signed him but he paid 20 million for him in the summer, given Keane's age etc. it was certainly an eye opener for me paying that much but it just doesn't make sense.  Even when Keane was not scoring at the start of the season he was working really hard and Liverpool where winning most of the matches.  Then in his last couple of games he has scored 3 goals and then been discarded.  I have always been a huge fan of Rafa's but he does some strange things at times IMHO.

Maybe if it was Chelsea or Manchester City they could sign someone for 20 million then go nah I don't fancy them that much but Liverpool don't have the resources to be spending that much and then Rafa not fancying a player.  Surely Liverppol had done there homework before pushing through the deal.  Everyone knows Keane is a yard short of pace in regard to being work class so I don't see how anything Keane has done has been such a surprise to Liverpool.

[Minder]

I'm sure this has been asked on previous pages but I can't be bothered reading all the pages but why did Rafa sign Keane and then not play him and look like he has never rated him?   I could understand if Houllier had signed him but he paid 20 million for him in the summer, given Keane's age etc. it was certainly an eye opener for me paying that much but it just doesn't make sense.  Even when Keane was not scoring at the start of the season he was working really hard and Liverpool where winning most of the matches.  Then in his last couple of games he has scored 3 goals and then been discarded.  I have always been a huge fan of Rafa's but he does some strange things at times IMHO.

Maybe if it was Chelsea or Manchester City they could sign someone for 20 million then go nah I don't fancy them that much but Liverpool don't have the resources to be spending that much and then Rafa not fancying a player.  Surely Liverppol had done there homework before pushing through the deal.  Everyone knows Keane is a yard short of pace in regard to being work class so I don't see how anything Keane has done has been such a surprise to Liverpool.

He always has been short of pace though and has performed far better at Spurs than he is now. As for Liverpool signing him the consensus seems to be Benitez had nothing to do with signing him, he was Rick Parrys "baby". I am actually really surprised we have managed to stay at the top all season, only losing one game, with some of the off the field s*ite that has been going on.

[Over the Bar]

As for Liverpool signing him the consensus seems to be Benitez had nothing to do with signing him, he was Rick Parrys "baby".

The same story came out when Shevchenko lost form at Chelsea about him not being Mourhino's signing.  Hard to believe on both counts.

[GalwayBayBoy]

As for Liverpool signing him the consensus seems to be Benitez had nothing to do with signing him, he was Rick Parrys "baby".

The same story came out when Shevchenko lost form at Chelsea about him not being Mourhino's signing.  Hard to believe on both counts.

I could easily see both being true.

Certainly Shevchenko was only bought because he was good mates with Abramovich. Mourinho probably didn't object but I doubt it was his idea.

As for Keane the way things are run at Liverpool at present it wouldn't surprise me in the least.

[Maiden1]

As for Liverpool signing him the consensus seems to be Benitez had nothing to do with signing him, he was Rick Parrys "baby".

The same story came out when Shevchenko lost form at Chelsea about him not being Mourhino's signing.  Hard to believe on both counts.

I could easily see both being true.

Certainly Shevchenko was only bought because he was good mates with Abramovich. Mourinho probably didn't object but I doubt it was his idea.

As for Keane the way things are run at Liverpool at present it wouldn't surprise me in the least.

Madness to sign a player over the managers head, makes sense why he won't sign a new contract until he gets more control over transfers.  What does Rick Parry know about football anyhow.  The Keane signing doesn't make sense, paying 20 million for a player that in 3-4 years is probably only going to be worth a couple of million.

[Minder]

As for Liverpool signing him the consensus seems to be Benitez had nothing to do with signing him, he was Rick Parrys "baby".

The same story came out when Shevchenko lost form at Chelsea about him not being Mourhino's signing.  Hard to believe on both counts.

You dont honestly think Shevchenko was Mourinhos signing do you?

[Hound]

I don't believe for one second that Keane was not a Benitez signing.
Benitez simply wouldnt stand for it, and Liverpool wouldnt spend £20m on a player the manager didnt ask for.

The Chelsea/Shevchenko situation was totally different.

[anportmorforjfc]

Liverpool manager Rafa Benitez insists he has not suffered a falling out with Robbie Keane following the striker's Merseyside derby FA Cup snub.

[Main Street]

I read on another forum that Keane was told not to turn up on Sunday after he exchanged words with Benitez after the drawn league game on Monday night. Could be horses*it but it all sounds ominous for Keane...........

Keane while not being the brightest spark in the football world is not the type to forsake his sense of professional duty.

If there was some sort of row, I doubt that Keane is not man enough to rectify his part in any innappropriate conduct.

[corn02]

I don't believe for one second that Keane was not a Benitez signing.
Benitez simply wouldnt stand for it, and Liverpool wouldnt spend £20m on a player the manager didnt ask for.

The Chelsea/Shevchenko situation was totally different.

Correct. Jesus agreeing withHound on here, I feel dizzy.
There may be some truth in it, and it may have been Parry. But he would have had to of got the ok from Rafa somewhere along the line.

BTW, i still think it could work out well.

[The Real Laoislad]

Liverpool manager Rafa Benitez insists he has not suffered a falling out with Robbie Keane following the striker's Merseyside derby snub.

The £20million Republic of Ireland international has flopped since moving to Anfield from Tottenham in the summer and rumour has been rife that Benitez is ready to sell.

Keane's Liverpool career plunged to a new low on Sunday as he was left out of Benitez's squad for the 1-1 FA Cup draw with neighbours Everton, sparking speculation that the pair have suffered a difference of opinion.

But with Spurs boss Harry Redknapp - an open admirer of Keane - waiting in the wings, Benitez has included the forward in his plans for Wednesday's Premier League trip to Wigan.

And the Spaniard has rubbished reports of a bust-up with Keane, telling Sky Sports News when asked about a possible row: "No. He is in the squad and training well.

"He is in the squad for tomorrow and I would be very pleased if he scored.

"People are talking too much about Keane. It was just one decision about one player, he wasn't in the squad.


"It is nothing to do with whether he talked to me about the situation. Every player has trained very hard this week, as has Robbie, and he will be in the squad.

"He had a day off on Sunday. He trained on Monday and he trained normally today.

"Everyone is now important for us. We have a lot of games to play in the coming weeks, in the league, cup and Europe.

"When Fernando Torres was injured, Robbie was working hard and doing well. If he can continue to do this we will not have any doubts over his quality."

Benitez, though, did not confirm or deny whether Liverpool have been approached by another club regarding Keane's future.

When asked about possible enquiries from a rival side, Benitez added: "We are just thinking about using him tomorrow and nothing else."

Benitez recognises Keane's omission will cause controversy due to his 'high-profile', but he insists that is on a par to whenever Manchester United boss Sir Alex Ferguson opts to shuffle his pack.



"He is expensive and high profile, yes. But Manchester United have bought plenty of players who cost £20m or more every single year. Sometimes more than one player. But nothing is said about them being left out," added Benitez.

"If you want to be in a top side then you must have this mentality. You have to accept that some players will play and some will not.

"Robbie is a good player, we knew that when we signed him. Maybe he is not playing at his best level, but he wants to fight for his position.

"It doesn't matter the name or the price, we have to think about the best player for each game."

Benitez has revealed the title-chasing Reds have received interest for some members of their squad, but the former Valencia boss is adamant he is not looking to sell.

"A lot of clubs have been asking about some players, to buy or loan. But we have said we do not need to lose anyone, we do not need to sell anyone now," he continued.

"We do not want to lose players now if we cannot replace those players later. We need all of them for the race for the title

[peterquaife]

Liverpool manager Rafa Benitez insists he has not suffered a falling out with Robbie Keane following the striker's Merseyside derby FA Cup snub.

yeah right

[EC Unique]

Benitez recognises Keane's omission will cause controversy due to his 'high-profile', but he insists that is on a par to whenever Manchester United boss Sir Alex Ferguson opts to shuffle his pack.



"He is expensive and high profile, yes. But Manchester United have bought plenty of players who cost £20m or more every single year. Sometimes more than one player. But nothing is said about them being left out," added Benitez.

This man has an unhealthy obsession with Fergie... He needs to calm down