Messages

The answer still lies in reducing the number of clubs on the city (albeit people won't agree)

Remove the senior argument for one min
 that's a different story

Assume for one second this was to play out:

Two clubs amalgamate (just like the schools)
You have one less pitch
30 kids instead of 15
Two sets of coaches at the one session
More numbers
More fun
More quality across the levels (ie instead of having 3 outstanding players you'd have 6 and likewise instead of having 3 who are not as developed you'd have 6) 

If we think the amalgamation at schools beneficial to city games......

I'd amalgamate clubs at underage all over the place.

Aim for squads of 60+ and stream into A, B and C teams.

Pooling coaches and other resources.

Of course would never get the buy in from the characters at every club who would go to war for their own badge and burn everything of any value in the process.

But that's how you get closer to top end development (players, teams and leagues) while also catering very well for the more recreational types.

Sounds like a fair bit of inflexibility on display.

I never get why teams or committees get so precious about having to move if it is in the best interests of a lot of people likely to be in attendance.

Given the football is on national television I would have thought the Camogie would have accommodated accordingly in this instance.

Would have expected football to accommodate if it was the other way round.

Hopefully everyone gets from A to B safely.

Anything like that viable on up the county?

Randalstown, Ballymena, Ballycastle and Carnlough take a lot of clubs into their catchment.

Two Antrim teams, covering the majority of clubs, competing in A level colleges would be a great grounding for upcoming talent in the county.

Belfast a good start regardless.

Just seen the Intermediate fixtures

Moneyglass vs st treases Saturday 4pm @ the bear pit

Glenavy vs Sairsfields Sunday 2pm @pg1


2 very strange venues for these games.


Any word on the junior games.

So much for neutrality
St Teresa's can walk down ffs.

Venues for those games are a joke. Hightown or Hannahstown for those games.

If driving from Moneyglass to Hannahstown might as well drive another 5 minutes for the better viewing, and a seat if you so wish, at the Bear Pit.

But both a hell of a lot closer for St Teresa's.

think he meant hightown for MG/St.T game
Hannahstown for Sars/Glen
As i said earier myself, 2 decent neutral venues

👍

Bear Pit a strange choice alright given a few kick passes could get you from St Teresa's to it.

Just seen the Intermediate fixtures

Moneyglass vs st treases Saturday 4pm @ the bear pit

Glenavy vs Sairsfields Sunday 2pm @pg1


2 very strange venues for these games.


Any word on the junior games.

So much for neutrality
St Teresa's can walk down ffs.

Venues for those games are a joke. Hightown or Hannahstown for those games.

If driving from Moneyglass to Hannahstown might as well drive another 5 minutes for the better viewing, and a seat if you so wish, at the Bear Pit.

But both a hell of a lot closer for St Teresa's.

We really need to have a conversation about splitting the county in two and having a Country Championship and a City Championship.

I have heard very little by way of complaint from players of coaches about the current structure. 

And I talk to people involved across a number of clubs.

It's mainly on here.

No idea what way any working group would be thinking.  Maybe depends who would be on said working group too.

But surely we value our Championship higher than our League?

I believe the two paragraphs above the one you put in bold shows what we can take from any team's League face v Championship face.

What's happening with Junior Championship?

Have Laochra Loch Lao won group 2 on score difference in 3 way mini league with Na Piarsaigh and Éire Óg? With the latter 2 now in quarter finals?

Don't see any mention of a relegation final after group games.  Bottom goes down.

That's the way the competitions are set up and how a team did in the league is irrelevant.

Lot here saying all year that the league is irrelevant anyway.

And looking at how some teams have performed in Championship compared to league it's hard to argue that the league is the measure.

Aldergrove finished top half but got beaten in Championship by 2 teams finishing bottom 5.

All Saints got to league final but got slaughtered by Lamh Dhearg who finished 7 points behind them in the league and closer to the bottom 4 than the top 4.

And if we end up with further changes to league structures all 3 involved in relegation playoffs could end up relegated anyway.

All Saints are in the relegation playoff.

Competition regulations state that if 3 teams involved it's a mini league with each team getting 1 home fixture. Also nothing about being exempt if finish anywhere in Div 1.

Website maybe not designed for a group playoff but will probably see them appear in the next round of fixtures where they will play either Aldergrove or Randalstown.

Quickest path would be having them play the loser of the first game as an All Saints victory would remove the need for a third game.

Just checked and it is closer to drive from Creggan than walking from Shaws Road.

St Teresa's probably would have been a fairer choice but maybe not deemed suitable for parking or the like.

As for old or new pitch.  Are Rossa and Creggan not used playing on pitches that would be on the smaller side anyway?

Probably is if you are driving from Creggan and walking from Rossa.

Certainly have all the know how.

Only thing that would put any doubt in my mind is the new rules and if they have the potential to impact.

Time will tell.

Can't see past Cargin, St Brigids, Portglenone and Creggan coming through.

Be happy to be wrong.