gaaboard.com

Non GAA Discussion => General discussion => Topic started by: thegael on April 24, 2007, 03:50:14 PM

Title: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: thegael on April 24, 2007, 03:50:14 PM
The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
As time has passed these two opposites seem to have merged any comments ?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Star Spangler on April 24, 2007, 03:55:18 PM
You'd need a virtual handshake of at least a second degree grip to get an answer to that one.  ;)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Lecale2 on April 24, 2007, 04:39:51 PM
The Masons played the Knights of Columbanus in a friendly football match back in the 70s to raise money for charity. The match was played in the Ormeau Park in Belfast. Nobody knows the score. It was a secret.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: brokencrossbar1 on April 24, 2007, 04:44:23 PM
QuoteThe Masons played the Knights of Columbanus in a friendly football match back in the 70s to raise money for charity. The match was played in the Ormeau Park in Belfast. Nobody knows the score. It was a secret.

Did they even get past the handshakes at the start of the game? ;)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: ziggysego on April 24, 2007, 04:46:50 PM
I believe they made Steve Guttenberg a star
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Orior on April 24, 2007, 07:18:32 PM
Quote from: ziggysego on April 24, 2007, 04:46:50 PM
I believe they made Steve Guttenberg a star

Another Simpsons cracker!
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: itsleftitswide on April 25, 2007, 11:18:34 AM
please desist from talking about such matters - you are dealing with forces more powerful than you can imagine that will destroy you in th end.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: ziggysego on April 28, 2009, 04:11:41 PM
Quote from: Orior on April 24, 2007, 07:18:32 PM
Quote from: ziggysego on April 24, 2007, 04:46:50 PM
I believe they made Steve Guttenberg a star

Another Simpsons cracker!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBav72i7I3s (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBav72i7I3s)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: johnneycool on April 28, 2009, 04:15:12 PM
Any of you heard of a 'gentlemens' club on royal avenue in Belfast called the Ulster reform club?

http://www.ulsterreformclub.com/home.asp

what are they all about?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Our Nail Loney on April 28, 2009, 06:13:11 PM
I never really got what these masons and whatever did
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Chuck Lidl on April 28, 2009, 08:03:29 PM
think they just sit around and remind each other of how successful they are

and sometimes they sacrifice live animals. mostly catholics
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 29, 2009, 09:20:56 AM
Quote from: johnneycool on April 28, 2009, 04:15:12 PM
Any of you heard of a 'gentlemens' club on royal avenue in Belfast called the Ulster reform club?

http://www.ulsterreformclub.com/home.asp

what are they all about?
I've been in there a number of times.  It's simply a private members club.  The web link you provided will tell you that too.  Nothing secretive about it at all, but like a lot of private clubs it is by invite only which just means you need to know a member to propose you and another to second your application. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 09:23:11 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 09:20:56 AM
Quote from: johnneycool on April 28, 2009, 04:15:12 PM
Any of you heard of a 'gentlemens' club on royal avenue in Belfast called the Ulster reform club?

http://www.ulsterreformclub.com/home.asp

what are they all about?
I've been in there a number of times.  It's simply a private members club.  The web link you provided will tell you that too.  Nothing secretive about it at all, but like a lot of private clubs it is by invite only which just means you need to know a member to propose you and another to second your application. 
A bit like a paramilatary group really then...
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: lynchbhoy on April 29, 2009, 10:12:57 AM
how old is your granny ?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 29, 2009, 10:21:33 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 09:23:11 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 09:20:56 AM
Quote from: johnneycool on April 28, 2009, 04:15:12 PM
Any of you heard of a 'gentlemens' club on royal avenue in Belfast called the Ulster reform club?

http://www.ulsterreformclub.com/home.asp

what are they all about?
I've been in there a number of times.  It's simply a private members club.  The web link you provided will tell you that too.  Nothing secretive about it at all, but like a lot of private clubs it is by invite only which just means you need to know a member to propose you and another to second your application. 
A bit like a paramilatary group really then...
It's non-Political and non-religious. 
If it was a paramilitary group it would be the Dad's Army of paramilitaries.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: SidelineKick on April 29, 2009, 10:27:43 AM
After having a look on their web site I must say, and I know this is a generalisation, I would think the majority of members are tw@ts.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 10:35:17 AM
Quote from: SidelineKick on April 29, 2009, 10:27:43 AM
After having a look on their web site I must say, and I know this is a generalisation, I would think the majority of members are tw@ts.
Exactly what I thought, pompous arseholes at a guess.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Lar Naparka on April 29, 2009, 11:50:18 AM
Quote from: SidelineKick on April 29, 2009, 10:27:43 AM
After having a look on their web site I must say, and I know this is a generalisation, I would think the majority of members are tw@ts.
Am I missing something here?
In what way is this club liked to the Masons? [I presume that the Knights are not involved.]
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Donagh on April 29, 2009, 11:54:44 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 10:21:33 AM

It's non-Political and non-religious. 


Did they lose their vote on the Ulster Unionist Council then? That's a shame  :-\
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 29, 2009, 04:20:16 PM
Quote from: Donagh on April 29, 2009, 11:54:44 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 10:21:33 AM

It's non-Political and non-religious. 


Did they lose their vote on the Ulster Unionist Council then? That's a shame  :-\
I'm not sure they have a vote within the UUP as it's not party linked and doesn't have any Political basis as far as I know.  I know a couple of members and they wouldn't be UUP voters.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on April 29, 2009, 04:22:35 PM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 04:20:16 PM
Quote from: Donagh on April 29, 2009, 11:54:44 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 10:21:33 AM

It's non-Political and non-religious. 


Did they lose their vote on the Ulster Unionist Council then? That's a shame  :-\
I'm not sure they have a vote within the UUP as it's not party linked and doesn't have any Political basis as far as I know.  I know a couple of members and they wouldn't be UUP voters.


DUP die hards by any chance?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 29, 2009, 04:27:20 PM
Quote from: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on April 29, 2009, 04:22:35 PM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 04:20:16 PM
Quote from: Donagh on April 29, 2009, 11:54:44 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 29, 2009, 10:21:33 AM

It's non-Political and non-religious. 


Did they lose their vote on the Ulster Unionist Council then? That's a shame  :-\
I'm not sure they have a vote within the UUP as it's not party linked and doesn't have any Political basis as far as I know.  I know a couple of members and they wouldn't be UUP voters.


DUP die hards by any chance?
Definitely not.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Main Street on April 29, 2009, 04:57:45 PM
I was sure this was going to be another feckin rugby thread.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 05:00:58 PM
I have pasted most of my previous post here now to allow the other thread to concentrate on the matter in hand, namely the naked sectarianism that exists amongst an elected Unionist representative.


Where did I ever say they were mutually dependent? Or are you not sure yourself toger?  master of spin but full of shite as usual.

Fudge the issue as long as you want, my apologies though the Freemasons are a great bunch of people WHO DO NOT THINK THE PUBLIC VIEW THEM AS SECTARIAN HOORS - the head of the masons in Ireland thinks it is their fault we all view them as sectarian but you may choose to argue otherwise though.

In other news, Willie McCrea wins an Ivor Novello award for his latest ditty 'The people of Antrim are lovely and really like fen..sorry catholics'
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on April 29, 2009, 05:20:16 PM
Don't seem that sinister.

http://www.knightsofstcolumbanus.ie/home.php
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 05:26:33 PM
its not natural to be in groups like that.  Why people feel the need to be in such groups in this day and age is beyond me.

I am certain the Orange Order and or masons have strands or early connections with Knights also
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 29, 2009, 05:31:21 PM
Pasting from a different thread.......
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 01:04:36 PM
And like the kids at Tesco they have no choice but to accept this, people talk about groups like Freemasons, Knights etc as if they are little tea and sandwich groups yet these are exactly the kind of 'institutions' (apt) that perpetuate the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still.  
 
What hatred and sectarianism have you seen from the Masons?

I don't know anything about the Knights or even who or what they are. I have asked the following question... what is your knowledge of them, and what sectarian hatred have you witnessed / observed? Is it spin and shite to ask?

Your comments about the Mason and the PR disaster is out of context.  He stated that Freemasory's perception is their own fault because they don't get their message across and ignorance allows others to form ignorant opinions based on presumption and speculation and a few made up bogey man stories.  Kind of what you seem to be doing.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 06:01:13 PM
You have again twisted what I have said and used if for your own agenda.

I have no time for any such group, Masons, Knights of any religious persuasion, OO etc.  if people feel the need to join a secret society IN MY OPINION they are sad people. 

Whether you like it or not the Masons are viewed as inherently sectarian in Ireland (a fact acknowledged by their leader FFS, twist it how you like but that is what he said) and overhwelmingly Unionist in their composition. Hence my paralells with that idiot watson.

if you know nothing about any strand of knights maybe do some research then as there is no point us discussing something you claim to know anything about (I am no expert either) but that is no surprise as we can hardly claim to be epxerts on groups that are essentially secretive in make up. What I do know is that there is a lot of bigoted idiotic people out there who detest all things Irish and are determined to trample over anything remotely Irish in make up and quick to argue against those who are Irish.  Kind of what you seem to be doing. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Diet Coke on April 29, 2009, 06:28:21 PM
Ther are plenty of catholics who are masons including priests :o
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: KCGaelicFootball on April 29, 2009, 07:41:03 PM
Quote from: Our Nail Loney on April 28, 2009, 06:13:11 PM
I never really got what these masons and whatever did

Its a cult...
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: imtommygunn on April 29, 2009, 07:51:10 PM
What about the Royal Ancient Order of Buffalo.

I notice that there's one of Donegall street belfast - I assume they're the same principle?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on April 29, 2009, 08:01:28 PM
Quote from: imtommygunn on April 29, 2009, 07:51:10 PM
What about the Royal Ancient Order of Buffalo.

I notice that there's one of Donegall street belfast - I assume they're the same principle?

Its just off Writers Sq, facing St Annes Cathedral, there's another one on the Albertbridge Rd.

http://www.raob.org/

Fcuk me their in the south as well!!  :-\
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: ardmhachaabu on April 29, 2009, 09:14:23 PM
Quote from: Diet Coke on April 29, 2009, 06:28:21 PM
Ther are plenty of catholics who are masons including priests :o
I very much doubt that.

The Orange Order is part of freemasonry.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Pangurban on April 29, 2009, 09:19:53 PM
 I cannot understand why the catholic church condemns the Masons, yet has no problem with the Knights of Columbanus, who are basically a secretive organisation with no open membership. Is it just a case of our secretive socities good others bad
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: ardmhachaabu on April 29, 2009, 09:42:11 PM
Dunno the answer to that Pangurban.  Will ask a few people and let you know...
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 09:34:58 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 06:01:13 PM
You have again twisted what I have said and used if for your own agenda.

I have no time for any such group, Masons, Knights of any religious persuasion, OO etc.  if people feel the need to join a secret society IN MY OPINION they are sad people. 

Whether you like it or not the Masons are viewed as inherently sectarian in Ireland (a fact acknowledged by their leader FFS, twist it how you like but that is what he said) and overhwelmingly Unionist in their composition. Hence my paralells with that idiot watson.

if you know nothing about any strand of knights maybe do some research then as there is no point us discussing something you claim to know anything about (I am no expert either) but that is no surprise as we can hardly claim to be epxerts on groups that are essentially secretive in make up. What I do know is that there is a lot of bigoted idiotic people out there who detest all things Irish and are determined to trample over anything remotely Irish in make up and quick to argue against those who are Irish.  Kind of what you seem to be doing. 

I twisted nothing.  Read your quote again.  The Masons are not sectarian as far as I can see but you have stated they are and are "exactly the kind of 'institutions' (apt) that perpetuate the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".  All I have done is ask why you said that and your answer came from going off to google the Masons and taking some Masons view that Freemasonry have only themselves to blame if people think that about them.  He didn't say they were sectarian or hate-filled he was simply saying that the PR disaster on RTE was basically down to their inability to get their point across effectively.  As for the Knights, I have stated I know nothing about them and have asked you for information given that you claim the are "exactly" the kind of organisation that perpetuates "the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 30, 2009, 09:44:53 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 30, 2009, 09:34:58 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 06:01:13 PM
You have again twisted what I have said and used if for your own agenda.

I have no time for any such group, Masons, Knights of any religious persuasion, OO etc.  if people feel the need to join a secret society IN MY OPINION they are sad people. 

Whether you like it or not the Masons are viewed as inherently sectarian in Ireland (a fact acknowledged by their leader FFS, twist it how you like but that is what he said) and overhwelmingly Unionist in their composition. Hence my paralells with that idiot watson.

if you know nothing about any strand of knights maybe do some research then as there is no point us discussing something you claim to know anything about (I am no expert either) but that is no surprise as we can hardly claim to be epxerts on groups that are essentially secretive in make up. What I do know is that there is a lot of bigoted idiotic people out there who detest all things Irish and are determined to trample over anything remotely Irish in make up and quick to argue against those who are Irish.  Kind of what you seem to be doing. 

I twisted nothing.  Read your quote again.  The Masons are not sectarian as far as I can see but you have stated they are and are "exactly the kind of 'institutions' (apt) that perpetuate the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".  All I have done is ask why you said that and your answer came from going off to google the Masons and taking some Masons view that Freemasonry have only themselves to blame if people think that about them.  He didn't say they were sectarian or hate-filled he was simply saying that the PR disaster on RTE was basically down to their inability to get their point across effectively.  As for the Knights, I have stated I know nothing about them and have asked you for information given that you claim the are "exactly" the kind of organisation that perpetuates "the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".
Are you serious 'some masons view'?  he was the head of masonry in Ireland FFS  :D.  Pick out the parts that suit you sure.  No point in debating this when you plainly twist everything for your own agenda.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 09:50:49 AM
Quote from: thegael on April 24, 2007, 03:50:14 PM
The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
As time has passed these two opposites seem to have merged any comments ?

To answer your question the Masons and Knights of Columbanus would not have any direct links. The knights of Columbanus would be exclusively be a conservative right wing catholic movement that depends on their want-to-be aristocrat type power and persuasions in the public. The Knights are actually recognised by the vatican and their members would include prominent doctors, politicians and priests. All of whom would command a certain respect in their community. The Knights job, in layman's terms is to conserve and protect the catholic church in subtle ways. They would use their influences to dampen criticisms and any conflicts against the church. I have a few stories in this regard but they are not for this board.

The Masonic Lodge or Freemasonry is much different. There cannot be crossover members as you swear an oth that you are not a member of another secret organisation. Masons have all the Holy Books open during their meetings. The Koran, Old Testament, New Testament etc are all opened at the start of the ceremony/meeting. This is to symbolise that Masonry dont have any particular faith and that all are welcome. Thats what would separate them from the Knights who are strictly catholic. The Masons would be more made up of prominent business men, politicians and the wealthy. It is an organisation that claims to have secrets passed on since the times of the renaissance. They say that politicians from Abraham Lincoln  to Bill Clinton were members. They also claim their members would include the great scientists of the past such as Galileo and Newton. Essentially there would be a trust there and probably a lot of back scratching and deals made between the politicians and businessmen involved. They have secret handshakes and things like that. What would worry me about the masons is that they are into their pagan symbols which would spell out that they are not exactly of any faith. Their symbolism would include compasses, bricks and mallets which is a nod to where they came from and what they stand for.

But there may be some cooperation between the two but for the most part they wouldnt be linked IMO.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 09:56:36 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 30, 2009, 09:44:53 AM
Quote from: Roger on April 30, 2009, 09:34:58 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 29, 2009, 06:01:13 PM
You have again twisted what I have said and used if for your own agenda.

I have no time for any such group, Masons, Knights of any religious persuasion, OO etc.  if people feel the need to join a secret society IN MY OPINION they are sad people. 

Whether you like it or not the Masons are viewed as inherently sectarian in Ireland (a fact acknowledged by their leader FFS, twist it how you like but that is what he said) and overhwelmingly Unionist in their composition. Hence my paralells with that idiot watson.

if you know nothing about any strand of knights maybe do some research then as there is no point us discussing something you claim to know anything about (I am no expert either) but that is no surprise as we can hardly claim to be epxerts on groups that are essentially secretive in make up. What I do know is that there is a lot of bigoted idiotic people out there who detest all things Irish and are determined to trample over anything remotely Irish in make up and quick to argue against those who are Irish.  Kind of what you seem to be doing. 

I twisted nothing.  Read your quote again.  The Masons are not sectarian as far as I can see but you have stated they are and are "exactly the kind of 'institutions' (apt) that perpetuate the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".  All I have done is ask why you said that and your answer came from going off to google the Masons and taking some Masons view that Freemasonry have only themselves to blame if people think that about them.  He didn't say they were sectarian or hate-filled he was simply saying that the PR disaster on RTE was basically down to their inability to get their point across effectively.  As for the Knights, I have stated I know nothing about them and have asked you for information given that you claim the are "exactly" the kind of organisation that perpetuates "the hatred and sectarianism against all things Nationalist in the 6 counties still".
Are you serious 'some masons view'?  he was the head of masonry in Ireland FFS  :D.  Pick out the parts that suit you sure.  No point in debating this when you plainly twist everything for your own agenda.
It doesn't matter if it was the chief wizard of world masonry, you need to read what he said. 

Now how exactly is Masonry and the Knights perpetrating hatred and sectarianism against nationalists "in the 6 counties"? 

Replying that the head Mason in Ireland says the PR isn't good and they have themselves to blame for that isn't an answer for your mindless accusation against the MAsons and you have never said a thing about the Knights.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 10:17:26 AM
Read my post above.

Some quotes:
Quote from: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 09:50:49 AM
The knights of Columbanus would be exclusively be a conservative right wing catholic movement ...are actually recognised by the vatican and their members would include prominent doctors, politicians and priests. All of whom would command a certain respect in their community.
....
Masons have all the Holy Books open during their meetings. The Koran, Old Testament, New Testament etc are all opened at the start of the ceremony/meeting. This is to symbolise that Masonry dont have any particular faith and that all are welcome. Thats what would separate them from the Knights who are strictly catholic
....
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 10:22:27 AM
Quote from: Pangurban on April 29, 2009, 09:19:53 PM
I cannot understand why the catholic church condemns the Masons, yet has no problem with the Knights of Columbanus, who are basically a secretive organisation with no open membership. Is it just a case of our secretive socities good others bad
I think historically it had something to do with control of the Masons and also that in the Masons the Pope / priests could actually be subservient to another member of any religion which they wouldn't be into. Therefore that church banned its members from joining the Masons with threat of excommunication I think.  Freemasonry doesn't ban any religion and it hasn't deterred many who have joined anyway. My understanding is that one of the qualifications to join the Masons is that you must believe in a god but no particular one.  Everyone refers to their own god in Masonic ritual but the substitute the term god with "Great Architect" which is masonry speak for whoever who want him to be.

If Abbeysiders view is correct then the Knights are an RC organisation under control of the church.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 10:23:38 AM
Quote from: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 10:17:26 AM
Read my post above.

Some quotes:
Quote from: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 09:50:49 AM
The knights of Columbanus would be exclusively be a conservative right wing catholic movement ...are actually recognised by the vatican and their members would include prominent doctors, politicians and priests. All of whom would command a certain respect in their community.
....
Masons have all the Holy Books open during their meetings. The Koran, Old Testament, New Testament etc are all opened at the start of the ceremony/meeting. This is to symbolise that Masonry dont have any particular faith and that all are welcome. Thats what would separate them from the Knights who are strictly catholic
....
I did read it and thought it an excellent post.

Still can't see how the perpetrate hatred and sectarianism towards nationalists, mind  ::)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 30, 2009, 10:32:25 AM
What he said and I have read it many times - "It is almost entirely our own fault that the public see us as sinister, secretive, sectarian and self-interested."  Not much ambiguity about that really.     ::) ::) ::)

I have already explained a few posts back that if anyone feels the need to join a secretive cult, group, organisation or order then IN MY OPINION it is plain wrong, regardless of religious make-up, persuasion etc and leaves them open to accusations of sectarianism, bigotry, hatred, characteristics shared by some of the good people of Antrim offended by 9 and 10 year old children.   The masons and I suppose Knights of any grouping until they allow a more open book policy will be viewed as sectarian, a fact readily acknowledged by the chief wizard of masonry or whatever minor role he has within masonry, knights in the same vein have to accept the same criticism.  So these are exactly the KIND of institutions (apt) that we can do without and perpetuate suspicion and sectarianism over here.

You claim to know little or indeed anything about Knights also, but I do feel you are being disengenuous here  ::), so I would find it hard to trust anything you say. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 10:52:40 AM
Quote from: Doogie Browser on April 30, 2009, 10:32:25 AM
You claim to know little or indeed anything about Knights also, but I do feel you are being disengenuous here  ::), so I would find it hard to trust anything you say. 
I didn't know anything about the Knights until Abbeysider's post.  You said they were "exactly" the sort of instituation that perpetrate hatred and sectarianism towards nationalism. I only asked why?  Your out of context google findings is a silly justification of your accusation on Masonry and I still can't see anything from you about the Knights or Masonry except you don't like secret societies of all kinds.  How's that against nationalism?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 10:56:09 AM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 29, 2009, 09:14:23 PM
Quote from: Diet Coke on April 29, 2009, 06:28:21 PM
Ther are plenty of catholics who are masons including priests :o
I very much doubt that.

The Orange Order is part of freemasonry.
Do you mean there are some within the OO are part of freemasonry as members or officially? As far as I am aware I don't think there is any link between OO and Masons except that there are OO members who are in the Masons but then there are also Catholics, Jews, nationalists, and even GAA members who are in the Masons. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Doogie Browser on April 30, 2009, 11:17:57 AM
I find it hard to believe you though Roger as you followed a certain route with your posts.  I will trust the word of the chief wizard of masonry though, I agree with him and his perception of how normal people view masonry.

I also said 'exactly the kind' of institution by the way, as in 'the sort of group' or 'the type of group' and I think it is clear the groups would have certain things in common, primarily their secrecy I suppose.

My opinions are worth as much as yours, but you don't seem to respect what I say, I don't expect your acceptance or agreement, but your instransigence, unwillingness to respect someone elses point of view and and patronising tone is something I am all too familiar with in the 6 counties.   ::) ::)  Sad really.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: nifan on April 30, 2009, 11:25:35 AM
The masons dont ban catholics as far as I am aware, but is it not the case that you can (or used to) be excommunicated from the catholic church for being a mason.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 11:27:00 AM
I follow a certain route? Wise up.  
You agree with perception about one organisation but you never mentioned perception in your original inflammatory and accusatory remarks.   Your opinions are indeed valid but your accusation is not. Nationalists are the victims of nothing here either from Masons or Knights.

But lets agree on one thing, we'll just leave this as there is simply no point.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: longrunsthefox on April 30, 2009, 11:32:34 AM
... so you can post something inflamatory on another thread...
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 11:38:38 AM
Quote from: longrunsthefox on April 30, 2009, 11:32:34 AM
... so you can post something inflamatory on another thread...
I'm quite interested to learn more about these two and any links.  I had wondered the Knights might have been linked to Masonry as masons call themselves Knights and there is a Knights Templar degree or some influence within Masonry.  I had not heard of Knights of Columbanus though and had wondered if there was an influence on Masonry.  If as Abbeysider says it is run by the RC Church then I can't see any links being possible as that church is officially very anti-freemasonry.

By the way, I'm not a mason or a knight.  Nor for that matter have I ever been a member of any political or religious organisation. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 12:00:21 PM
Quote from: Roger on April 30, 2009, 11:38:38 AM
Quote from: longrunsthefox on April 30, 2009, 11:32:34 AM
... so you can post something inflamatory on another thread...
I'm quite interested to learn more about these two and any links.  I had wondered the Knights might have been linked to Masonry as masons call themselves Knights and there is a Knights Templar degree or some influence within Masonry.  I had not heard of Knights of Columbanus though and had wondered if there was an influence on Masonry.  If as Abbeysider says it is run by the RC Church then I can't see any links being possible as that church is officially very anti-freemasonry.

By the way, I'm not a mason or a knight.  Nor for that matter have I ever been a member of any political or religious organisation. 

I never said that the Knights of Colombanus were 'run' by the Church/Vatican. However they are acknowledged by the Church. They would have no direct connection and running of the Knights but there is a recognition all the same. As I said, it is conservative Catholics that are members and they try and defend situations the church may be involved in. They wouldnt see the Pope as the leader and rule maker of the Knights' organisation or anything.
They would only see the Pope as any other catholic would define him.

The Vatican would however have stronger links with other organisations such as Opus Dei.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 12:09:36 PM
Fair point.  What you seem to be saying is that it's just a fraternal society which is supportive of that church for members of that church? 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: AbbeySider on April 30, 2009, 12:19:25 PM
Quote from: Roger on April 30, 2009, 12:09:36 PM
Fair point.  What you seem to be saying is that it's just a fraternal society which is supportive of that church for members of that church? 

Now you have it.
Essentially it is a private catholic men's fraternity. Many others exist in various countries around the world. They are all linked under an alliance that would be recognised by the church as a private international catholic association.

Going back to the argument about sectarianism. I have never found or heard of Masons or the Knights being a sectarian organisation, however its possible that sectarians exist in those organisations in the same way that they exist in every other group and walk of life. There is an aristocrat, business/powerful men ethos to the Masons though but i wouldnt see this as being sectarian as all denominations including Catholics, Jews and Muslims can be Masons.

But secret organisations of this type are dangerous for other reasons. Any secret organisation with powerful people involved is not really a healthy practice for obvious reasons. It is a step closer so what is known as "The Secret Rulers of The World" and the "New World Order" which may or may not exist.

IMO I think that cooperation between organisations like Masons and other secret societies leads to clues of the existence of such powerful movements and organisations. But thats another thread.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 12:49:36 PM
In Northern Ireland it seems to be more middle and lower-middle class people involved in the Masons.  I think the Masons have very much been in decline for years.  Their secretive side of things let preconceptions and ignorance about what they do to develop into hostility towards it and then didn't adapt with times and numbers have subsequently fallen.  There also seems less interest with younger people in the Masons and they wouldn't be anywhere near as powerful as they are maybe considered. They do still seem to be prominent in the public sector and in particular the police and judiciary.

A couple of years ago the Masons tried to be more open about what they are about in order to educate people and allay some people's fears about them.  They had an open day at their Temple in Rosemary Street in Belfast.  I went along for a tour and found it all very informative and it's a very interesting building.  Well worth going to if they ever do it again.  They were actually quite open and when I was asked about what I do etc they immediately identified people I might know who were members of lodges that meet in Rosemary Street.  They weren't at all secretive about membership.  They are simply secretive about their rituals and workings.  In order to join the Masons all you have to do ask one and that starts the process.  You are not asked in the first instance but must show interest.  You also need to believe in a 'higher being' or God. After that they basically vet you to see if you are of good standing in the community and if any Masons have an issue with you (e.g. a legal case or previous trouble with you). Doesn't seem to be too difficult to join.   Having enquired about MAsonry to a couple of Masons that I know I've been asked if would like to come along to the lodge (but not their meeting bit) as it is meant to be very sociable (few drinks, food etc) but I declined as this is the first part of starting to join. 

From what I can make out from reading about Masonry the problem is it seems to be a bit of a religion to me.  Someone mentioned earlier that it is a cult and that may not be far from the truth. Most people think once you are a Master Mason (3rd Degree) that that is about it.  However there are 33 degrees and these degrees meet in different lodge meetings.  It is during these upper degrees that there is a god-like figure that is revealed as the real meaning / secret of masonry which is some sort of combination of 3 gods including the Christian God.  I've no problem with Masonry or fraternal organisations at all but that bit just takes it away from something I'd be interested in joining.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Diet Coke on April 30, 2009, 02:05:23 PM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 29, 2009, 09:14:23 PM
Quote from: Diet Coke on April 29, 2009, 06:28:21 PM
Ther are plenty of catholics who are masons including priests :o
I very much doubt that.

The Orange Order is part of freemasonry.

Yeah the following are all members of OO :o :o :o
A List of Masons in the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church


The following is a list of Masons reprinted with some updates from the Bulletin de l'Occident Chrétien Nr.12, July, 1976, (Directeur Pierre Fautrad a Fye - 72490 Bourg Le Roi.) All of the men on this list, if they in fact be Masons, are excommunicated by Canon Law 2338. Each man's name is followed by his position, if known; the date he was initiated into Masonry, his code #; and his code name, if known.

Albondi, Alberto. Bishop of Livorno, (Leghorn). Initiated 8-5-58; I.D. # 7-2431.

Abrech, Pio. In the Sacred Congregation Bishops. 11-27-67; # 63-143.

Acquaviva, Sabino. Professor of Religion at the University of Padova, (Padua). 12-3-69; # 275-69.

Alessandro, Father Gottardi. (Addressed as Doctor in Masonic meetings.) President of Fratelli Maristi. 6-14-59.

Angelini Fiorenzo. Bishop of Messenel Greece. 10-14-57; # 14-005.

Argentieri, Benedetto. Patriarch to the Holy See. 3-11-70; # 298-A.

Bea, Augustin. Cardinal. Secretary of State (next to Pope) under Pope John XXIII and Pope Paul VI.

Baggio, Sebastiano. Cardinal. Prefect of the Sacred Congregation of Bishops. (This is a crucial Congregation since it appoints new Bishops.) Secretary of State under Pope John Paul II from 1989 to 1992. 8-14-57; # 85-1640. Masonic code name "SEBA." Controls consecration of Bishops.

Balboni, Dante. Assistant to the Vatican Pontifical . Commission for Biblical Studies. 7-23-68; # 79-14 "BALDA."

Baldassarri Salvatore. Bishop of Ravenna, Italy. 2-19-58; # 4315-19. "BALSA."

Balducci, Ernesto. Religious sculpture artist. 5-16-66; # 1452-3.

Basadonna, Ernesto. Prelate of Milan, 9-14-63; # 9-243. "BASE."

Batelli, Guilio. Lay member of many scientific academies. 8-24-59; # 29-A. "GIBA."

Bedeschi, Lorenzo. 2-19-59; # 24-041. "BELO."

Belloli, Luigi. Rector of Seminar; Lombardy, Ita- ly. 4-6-58; # 22-04. "BELLU."

Belluchi, Cleto. Coadjutor Bishop of Fermo, Italy. 6-4-68; # 12-217.

Bettazzi, Luigi. Bishop of Ivera, Italy. 5-11-66; # 1347-45. "LUBE."

Bianchi, Ciovanni. 10-23-69; # 2215-11. "BIGI."

Biffi, Franco, Msgr. Rector of Church of St. John Lateran Pontifical University. He is head of this University and controls what is being taught. He heard confessions of Pope Paul VI. 8-15-59. "BIFRA."

Bicarella, Mario. Prelate of Vicenza, Italy. 9-23-64; # 21-014. "BIMA."

Bonicelli, Gaetano. Bishop of Albano, Italy. 5-12-59; # 63-1428, "BOGA."

Boretti, Giancarlo. 3-21-65; # 0-241. "BORGI."

Bovone, Alberto. Substitute Secretary of the Sacred Office. 3-30-67; # 254-3. "ALBO."

Brini, Mario. ArchBishop. Secretary of Chinese, Oriental, and Pagans. Member of Pontifical Commission to Russia. Has control of rewriting Canon Law. 7-7-68; # 15670. "MABRI."

Bugnini, Annibale. ArchBishop.Wrote Novus Ordo Mass. Envoy to Iran, 4-23-63; # 1365-75. "BUAN."

Buro, Michele. Bishop. Prelate of Pontifical Commission to Latin America, 3-21-69; # 140-2. "BUMI."

Cacciavillan, Agostino. Secretariat of State. 11-6-60; # 13-154.

Cameli, Umberto. Director in Office of the Ecclesiastical Affairs of Italy in regard to education in Catholic doctrine. 11-17-60; # 9-1436.

Caprile, Giovanni. Director of Catholic Civil Affairs. 9-5-57; # 21-014. "GICA."

Caputo, Giuseppe. 11-15-71; # 6125-63. "GICAP."

Casaroli, Agostino. Cardinal. Secretary of State (next to Pope) under Pope John Paul II since July 1, 1979 until retired in 1989. 9-28-57; # 41-076. "CASA."

Cerruti, Flaminio. Chief of the Office of the University of Congregation Studies. 4-2-60; # 76-2154. "CEFLA."

Ciarrocchi, Mario. Bishop. 8-23-62; # 123-A. "CIMA."

Chiavacci, Enrico. Professor of Moral Theology, University of Florence, Italy. 7-2-70; # 121-34. "CHIE."

Conte, Carmelo. 9-16-67; # 43-096. "CONCA."

Csele, Alessandro. 3-25-60; # 1354-09. "ALCSE."

Dadagio, Luigi. Papal Nuncio to Spain. ArchBishop of Lero. 9-8-67. # 43-B. "LUDA."

D'Antonio, Enzio. ArchBishop of Trivento. 6-21-69; # 214-53.

De Bous, Donate. Bishop. 6-24-68; # 321-02. "DEBO."

Del Gallo Reoccagiovane, Luigi. Bishop.

Del Monte, Aldo. Bishop of Novara, Italy. 8-25-69; # 32-012. "ADELMO."

Faltin, Danielle. 6-4-70; # 9-1207. "FADA."

Ferraioli, Giuseppe. Member of Sacred Congregation for Public Affairs. 11-24-69; # 004-125. "GIFE."

Franzoni, Giovanni. 3-2-65; # 2246-47. "FRAGI."

Gemmiti, Vito. Sacred Congregation of Bishops. 3-25-68; # 54-13. "VIGE."

Girardi, Giulio. 9-8-70; # 1471-52. "GIG."

Fiorenzo, Angelinin. Bishop. Title of Commendator of the Holy Spirit. Vicar General of Roman Hospitals. Controls hospital trust funds. Consecrated Bishop 7-19-56; joined Masons 10-14-57.

Giustetti, Massimo. 4-12-70; # 13-065. "GIUMA."

Gottardi, Alessandro. Procurator and Postulator General of Fratelli Maristi. ArchBishop of Trent. 6-13-59; # 2437-14. "ALGO."

Gozzini, Mario. 5-14-70; # 31-11. "MAGO."

Grazinai, Carlo. Rector of the Vatican Minor Seminary. 7-23-61; # 156-3. "GRACA."

Gregagnin, Antonio. Tribune of First Causes for Beatification. 10-19-67; # 8-45. "GREA."

Gualdrini, Franco. Rector of Capranica. 5-22-61; # 21-352. "GUFRA."

Ilari, Annibale. Abbot. 3-16-69; # 43-86. "ILA."

Laghi, Pio. Nunzio, Apostolic Delegate to Argentina, and then to U.S.A. until 1995. 8-24-69; # 0-538. "LAPI."

Lajolo, Giovanni. Member of Council of Public Affairs of the Church. 7-27-70; # 21-1397. "LAGI."

Lanzoni, Angelo. Chief of the Office of Secretary of State. 9-24-56; # 6-324. "LANA."

Levi, Virgillio (alias Levine), Monsignor. Assistant Director of Official Vatican Newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano. Manages Vatican Radio Station. 7-4-58; # 241-3. "VILE."

Lozza, Lino. Chancellor of Rome Academy of St. Thomas Aquinas of Catholic Religion. 7-23-69; # 12-768. "LOLI."

Lienart, Achille. Cardinal. Grand Master top Mason. Bishop of Lille, France. Recruits Masons. Was leader of progressive forces at Vatican II Council.

Macchi, Pasquale. Cardinal. Pope Paul's Prelate of Honour and Private Secretary until he was excommunicated for heresy by Pope Paul VI. Was reinstated by Secretary of State Jean Villot, and made a Cardinal. 4-23-58; # 5463-2. "MAPA."

Mancini, Italo. Director of Sua Santita. 3-18-68; # l551-142. "MANI."

Manfrini, Enrico. Lay Consultor of Pontifical Commission of Sacred Art. 2-21-68; # 968-c. "MANE."

Marchisano, Francesco. Prelate Honour of the Pope. Secretary Congregation for Seminaries and Universities of Studies. 2-4-61; 4536-3. "FRAMA."

Marcinkus, Paul. American bodyguard for imposter Pope. From Cicero, Illinois. Stands 6'4". President for Institute for Training Religious. 8-21-67; # 43-649. Called "GORILLA." Code name "MARPA."

Marsili, Saltvatore. Abbot of Order of St. Benedict of Finalpia near Modena, Italy. 7-2-63; # 1278-49. "SALMA."

Mazza, Antonio. Titular Bishop of Velia. Secretary General of Holy Year, 1975. 4-14-71. # 054-329. "MANU."

Mazzi, Venerio. Member of Council of Public Affairs of the Church. 10-13-66; # 052-s. "MAVE."

Mazzoni, Pier Luigi. Congregation of Bishops. 9-14-59; # 59-2. "PILUM."

Maverna, Luigi. Bishop of Chiavari, Genoa, Italy. Assistant General of Italian Catholic Azione. 6-3-68; # 441-c. "LUMA."

Mensa, Albino. ArchBishop of Vercelli, Piedmont, Italy. 7-23-59; # 53-23. " MENA."

Messina, Carlo. 3-21-70; # 21-045. "MECA."

Messina, Zanon (Adele). 9-25-68; # 045-329. " AMEZ."

Monduzzi, Dino. Regent to the Prefect of the Pontifical House. 3-11 -67; # 190-2. "MONDI."

Mongillo, Daimazio. Professor of Dominican Moral Theology, Holy Angels Institute of Roma. 2-16-69; # 2145-22. "MONDA."

Morgante, Marcello. Bishop of Ascoli Piceno in East Italy. 7-22-55; # 78-3601. MORMA."

Natalini, Teuzo. Vice President of the Archives of Secretariat of the Vatican. 6-17-67; # 21-44d. "NATE."

Nigro, Carmelo. Rector of the Seminary, Pontifical of Major Studies. 12-21-70; # 23-154. "CARNI."

Noe, Virgillio. Head of the Sacred Congregation of Divine Worship. He and Bugnini paid 5 Protestant Ministers and one Jewish Rabbi to create the Novus Ordo Mass. 4-3-61; # 43652-21. "VINO."

Palestra, Vittorie. He is Legal Council of the Sacred Rota of the Vatican State. 5-6-43; # 1965. "PAVI."

Pappalardo, Salvatore. Cardinal. ArchBishop of Palermo, Sicily. 4-15-68; # 234-07. "SALPA."

Pasqualetti, Gottardo. 6-15-60; # 4-231. "COPA."

Pasquinelli, Dante. Council of Nunzio of Madrid. 1-12-69; # 32-124. "PADA."

Pellegrino, Michele. Cardinal. Called "Protector of the Church", ArchBishop of Torino (Turin, where the Holy Shroud of Jesus is kept). 5-2-60; # 352-36. "PALMI."

Piana, Giannino. 9-2-70; # 314-52. "GIPI."

Pimpo, Mario. Vicar of Office of General Affairs. 3-15-70; # 793-43. "PIMA."

Pinto, Monsignor Pio Vito. Attaché of Secretary of State and Notare of Second Section of Supreme Tribunal and of Apostolic Signature. 4-2-70; # 3317-42. "PIPIVI."

Poletti, Ugo. Cardinal. Vicar of S.S. Diocese of Rome. Controls clergy of Rome since 3-6-73. Member of Sacred Congregation of Sacraments and of Divine Worship. He is President of Pontifical Works and Preservation of the Faith. Also President of the Liturgical Academy. 2-17-69; # 32-1425. "UPO."

Rizzi, Monsignor Mario. Sacred Congregation of Oriental Rites. Listed as "Prelate Bishop of Honour of the Holy Father, the Pope." Works under top-Mason Mario Brini in manipulating Canon Law. 9-16-69; # 43-179. "MARI," "MONMARI."

Romita, Florenzo. Was in Sacred Congregation of Clergy. 4-21-56; # 52-142. "FIRO."

Rogger, Igine. Officer in S.S. (Diocese of Rome). 4-16-68; # 319-13. "IGRO."

Rossano, Pietro. Sacred Congregation of Non-Christian Religions. 2-12-68; # 3421-a. "PIRO."

Rovela, Virgillio. 6-12-64; # 32-14. "ROVI."

Sabbatani, Aurelio. ArchBishop of Giustiniana (Giusgno, Milar Province, Italy). First Secretary Supreme Apostolic Segnatura. 6-22-69; # 87-43. "ASA"

Sacchetti, Guilio. Delegate of Governors - Marchese. 8-23-59; # 0991-b. "SAGI."

Salerno, Francesco. Bishop. Prefect Atti. Eccles. 5-4-62; # 0437-1. "SAFRA"

Santangelo, Franceso. Substitute General of Defense Legal Counsel. 11-12-70; # 32-096. "FRASA."

Santini, Pietro. Vice Official of the Vicar. 8-23-64; # 326-11. "SAPI."

Savorelli, Fernando. 1-14-69; # 004-51. "SAFE."

Savorelli, Renzo. 6-12-65; # 34-692. "RESA."

Scanagatta, Gaetano. Sacred Congregation of the Clergy. Member of Commission of Pomei and Loreto, Italy. 9-23-71; # 42-023. "GASCA."

Schasching, Giovanni. 3-18-65; # 6374-23. "GISCHA," "GESUITA."

Schierano, Mario. Titular Bishop of Acrida (Acri in Cosenza Province, Italy.) Chief Military Chaplain of the Italian Armed Forces. 7-3-59; #14-3641. "MASCHI."

Semproni, Domenico. Tribunal of the Vicarate of the Vatican. 4-16-60; # 00-12. "DOSE."

Sensi, Giuseppe Mario. Titular ArchBishop of Sardi (Asia Minor near Smyrna). Papal Nunzio to Portugal. 11-2-67; # 18911-47. "GIMASE."

Sposito, Luigi. Pontifical Commission for the Archives of the Church in Italy. Head Administrator of the Apostolic Seat of the Vatican.

Suenens, Leo. Cardinal. Title: Protector of the Church of St. Peter in Chains, outside Rome. Promotes Protestant Pentecostalism (Charismatics). Destroyed much Church dogma when he worked in 3 Sacred Congregations: 1) Propagation of the Faith; 2) Rites and Ceremonies in the Liturgy; 3) Seminaries. 6-15-67; # 21-64. "LESU."

Trabalzini, Dino. Bishop of Rieti (Reate, Peruga, Italy). Auxiliary Bishop of Southern Rome. 2-6-65; # 61-956. "TRADI."

Travia, Antonio. Titular ArchBishop of Termini Imerese. Head of Catholic schools. 9-15-67; # 16-141. "ATRA."

Trocchi, Vittorio. Secretary for Catholic Laity in Consistory of the Vatican State Consultations. 7-12-62; # 3-896. "TROVI."

Tucci, Roberto. Director General of Vatican Radio. 6-21-57; # 42-58. "TURO."

Turoldo, David. 6-9-67; # 191-44. "DATU."

Vale, Georgio. Priest. Official of Rome Diocese. 2-21-71; # 21-328. "VAGI."

Vergari, Piero. Head Protocol Officer of the Vatican Office Segnatura. 12-14-70; # 3241-6. "PIVE."

Villot, Jean. Cardinal. Secretary of State during Pope Paul VI. He is Camerlengo (Treasurer). "JEANNI," "ZURIGO."

Zanini, Lino. Titular ArchBishop of Adrianopoli, which is Andrianopolis, Turkey. Apostolic Nuncio. Member of the Revered Fabric of St. Peter's Basilica.

"Pope John Paul II - Voted in by a Freemason and handed the keys to the Catholic Church by a Freemason.

On September 28, 1978, Pope John Paul I, elected only one month earlier in August, suddenly and mysteriously dies. Less then one month after his death, on October 16, 1978, Karol Jozef Wojtyla takes over the papacy as Pope John Paul II - the defining vote cast for him by Cardinal Sebastiano Baggio, a Freemason.

Baggio, Sebastiano. Cardinal. Prefect of the Sacred Congregation of Bishops. (This is a crucial Congregation since it appoints new Bishops.) Secretary of State under Pope John Paul II from 1989 to 1992. 8-14-57; # 85-1640. Masonic code name "SEBA." He controls consecration of Bishops. (Source: Masons list from the Bulletin de l'Occident Chrétien Nr.12, July, 1976, (Directeur Pierre Fautrad a Fye - 72490 Bourg Le Roi.)

At 6:18 p.m. on the day he is elected Pope, a Cardinal Tisserant announces in the chapel that Karol Wojtyla of Krakow had been elected pontiff of the Roman Catholic Church. Cardinal Jean Villot, the chamberlain, approached Wojtyla and asked in Latin: "In accordance with the canon law, do you accept?" (Source: "Journey to Rome", Newsweek article which ran in The Phoenix Gazette on 4/8/95)

Villot, Jean. Cardinal. Secretary of State during Pope Paul VI. He is Camerlengo (Treasurer). Masonic Code Names: "JEANNI," "ZURIGO." (Source: Masons list from the Bulletin de l'Occident Chrétien Nr.12, July, 1976, (Directeur Pierre Fautrad a Fye - 72490 Bourg Le Roi.)

So there you have it. Pope John Paul II - voted in by a Freemason (Baggio) and handed the keys to the Roman Catholic Church by a Freemason (Villot)."

There you have it Pope John Paul II voted in by an excommunicated Catholic under Canon Law 2338, Cardinal Sebastiano Baggio. John Paul II has since removed the prohibition (on November 27, 1983) regarding Catholics joining the Freemasons. But you see (no pun intended) since his election was invalid he really isn't Pope at all!

"Lest there be any place for error when decision will have to made as to what the opinions of these pernicious sects are, which are under such prohibition, it is especially certain that Freemasonry and other sects of this kind which plot against the Church and lawful powers, whether they do this secretly or openly, whether or not they exact from their followers an oath to preserve secrecy, are condemned by automatic excommunication." (Instruction of the Holy Office, May 10, 1884)

"Those who give their name to (who are members of) the Masonic sect, or other societies of the same nature, that scheme against the Church or lawful civil authority, ipso facto (automatically) contract excommunication [the absolution from which is] reserved to the Holy See." (Canon 2335, 1917 Code of Canon Law) Effective (May 19, 1918)




Copyright © 2004 by Light of Life Ministries.
This page was created on the 28th. of Mar 2004



Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Boolerhead Mel on April 30, 2009, 03:38:09 PM
I would have to agree with Roger-the masons have been in decline for years in the north. My Father in law is one and to this end I had lunch with him a few years ago in rosemary st (think that building is closed now) lovely food by the way. I do not know what they get up at thier meeting but they do organise charity events BBQ's that kind of thing. From what I gather most of them would be very old my father in law is in his early 60's and would be one of the younger ones. I don't think that they have issues with the Catholic church as he attended my kids christening no problem. They have no links with the OO-my father in law detests them however yuo can be in both 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on April 30, 2009, 04:02:40 PM
Didn't know Rosemary Street was closed. There seems to be another Temple around the Mount area in east Belfast which maybe is the other big one in Belfast.   The Masons have no issue with religious organisations, it just seems that some religious organisations have issues with them.

A mate of mine actually went to a school run by Masons in Dublin.  His da was big into the Masons and his two brothers were in it too.  However his mother asked him not to join, so he didn't, because it takes over your life with the time involved in it.  It seems his dad and brothers' lives were spent at Masonic things and charity events etc.  The upside was his mother was well looked after financially by the Masons when his dad eventually died. 
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: ardmhachaabu on April 30, 2009, 08:32:22 PM
Quote from: Diet Coke on April 30, 2009, 02:05:23 PM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 29, 2009, 09:14:23 PM
Quote from: Diet Coke on April 29, 2009, 06:28:21 PM
Ther are plenty of catholics who are masons including priests :o
I very much doubt that.

The Orange Order is part of freemasonry.

Yeah the following are all members of OO :o :o :o
A List of Masons in the Hierarchy of the Catholic Church


The following is a list of Masons reprinted with some updates from the Bulletin de l'Occident Chrétien Nr.12, July, 1976, (Directeur Pierre Fautrad a Fye - 72490 Bourg Le Roi.) All of the men on this list, if they in fact be Masons, are excommunicated by Canon Law 2338. Each man's name is followed by his position, if known; the date he was initiated into Masonry, his code #; and his code name, if known.

Copyright © 2004 by Light of Life Ministries.
This page was created on the 28th. of Mar 2004




First of all, you have no idea about freemasonry if you believe that the Orange Order aren't very much a part of it, so too with the Black Perceptory Order and there are others...

Secondly, the bit I bolded - by Canon Law even if that list was correct, the people named on it aren't Catholics.

Finally, if you don't think that freemasons claiming such a list of 'Catholics and priests' is a bit suspicious, you are extremely naive.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: AbbeySider on May 01, 2009, 09:14:13 AM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 30, 2009, 08:32:22 PM
First of all, you have no idea about freemasonry if you believe that the Orange Order aren't very much a part of it, so too with the Black Perceptory Order and there are others...

Secondly, the bit I bolded - by Canon Law even if that list was correct, the people named on it aren't Catholics.

Finally, if you don't think that freemasons claiming such a list of 'Catholics and priests' is a bit suspicious, you are extremely naive.

I cant believe someone posted a quote from an organisation as wacky and right-wing as they "Light of Life Ministries"  :o

Lets get real, anything that comes from there (as bad as the Jehovah's... maybe worse in fact)  should be taken with a pinch of salt.
This is the internet, dont believe everything you read.

Maybe there are crossover members from the OO and Masons in the North. As much as I am not comfortable with either organisation, the Masons are not a sectarian movement. Its possible that there are members that are sectarian against Catholics but its also possible that there are members that are sectarian towards Muslims, Jews and Protestants on either side of the border and around the world.


Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on May 01, 2009, 09:57:01 AM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 30, 2009, 08:32:22 PM
First of all, you have no idea about freemasonry if you believe that the Orange Order aren't very much a part of it, so too with the Black Perceptory Order and there are others...
What others?

I have no doubt that there are members of the Orange and the Black who are members of the Masons.  However, there is no link other than that membership would overlap but Masonry membership would overlap with many many other organisations across this planet. 

The OO was set up after the Masons and as a fraternal society would probably have been influenced by what the Masons do e.g. degree process, lodge meeting style, the apron members of the Black wears etc.  However there has historically been resistence within the OO to too much influence from the Masons e.g. the Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange was seen as too Masonic and ritualistic and it wasn't brought in for some time to the OO. Think it was back in the early 1900s when it was officially introduced.   

There are people in Ireland and throughout the world who like these types of fraternal organisation however just because a membership may overlap, or some bits of one may influence the develop of another, it doesn't mean that they are the same. 

Without providing any evidence, saying that the 'OO is part of Freemasonry' is reckless, misleading and seemingly inaccurate.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Diet Coke on May 01, 2009, 10:10:46 AM
Quote from: Roger on May 01, 2009, 09:57:01 AM
Quote from: ardmhachaabu on April 30, 2009, 08:32:22 PM
First of all, you have no idea about freemasonry if you believe that the Orange Order aren't very much a part of it, so too with the Black Perceptory Order and there are others...
What others?

I have no doubt that there are members of the Orange and the Black who are members of the Masons.  However, there is no link other than that membership would overlap but Masonry membership would overlap with many many other organisations across this planet. 

The OO was set up after the Masons and as a fraternal society would probably have been influenced by what the Masons do e.g. degree process, lodge meeting style, the apron members of the Black wears etc.  However there has historically been resistence within the OO to too much influence from the Masons e.g. the Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange was seen as too Masonic and ritualistic and it wasn't brought in for some time to the OO. Think it was back in the early 1900s when it was officially introduced.   

There are people in Ireland and throughout the world who like these types of fraternal organisation however just because a membership may overlap, or some bits of one may influence the develop of another, it doesn't mean that they are the same. 

Without providing any evidence, saying that the 'OO is part of Freemasonry' is reckless, misleading and seemingly inaccurate.

Careful now Roger, you are crossing swords with "Hero Members" ;)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: nifan on May 01, 2009, 10:29:43 AM
Quotethe Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange

I never understood what the feck all this degree nonsense is about?
Is it like a level you achieve by passing some test or something?

Sounds like scientology to me.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on May 01, 2009, 11:02:11 AM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 10:29:43 AM
Quotethe Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange

I never understood what the feck all this degree nonsense is about?
Is it like a level you achieve by passing some test or something?

Sounds like scientology to me.
It's sort of like that.  You are expected to endeavour to do these things but it's not essential and those that wish to achieve higher status do more degrees.   I can only liken it to the scouts (was a member as a kid) where eventually you get stripes and awards for doing badge work and stuff. However in these adult orders you keep quiet about what you did to get the award.  It mightn't be for you or I but it seems some people like these things and it used to be a lot bigger.  Prior to more disposable income, transport, telly, internet etc the lodge meeting was probably the highlight of the month. Each to their own.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: nifan on May 01, 2009, 11:31:16 AM
QuoteYou are expected to endeavour to do these things

Yes, but what do you have to do to achieve them?

Like you ive no problem with what people enjoy doing in their own time, though I am wary of any secret memberships with a reputation for looking out for their own in terms of jobs etc. be it the OO or the Masons, though Im unsure how fair or unfair it is to compare motivation behind the 2 clubs.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on May 01, 2009, 11:37:22 AM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 11:31:16 AM
QuoteYou are expected to endeavour to do these things

Yes, but what do you have to do to achieve them?
As I said, I don't think it's essential however the initiation in both gets the first degree.

QuoteLike you ive no problem with what people enjoy doing in their own time, though I am wary of any secret memberships with a reputation for looking out for their own in terms of jobs etc. be it the OO or the Masons, though Im unsure how fair or unfair it is to compare motivation behind the 2 clubs.
I don't find them secretive at all except what their "badgework" involves.  All clubs, societies, families, networks etc look out for each other.  I have no problem with that at all.  The only problem comes when one group becomes highly exclusive, powerful and takes over to the unfair detriment of others. I don't think there are any really to worry too much about these days.  Certainly the objectives of Freemasonry is not of worry to general society anywhere; the danger would only come if some within it abused their position.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: nifan on May 01, 2009, 12:41:05 PM
Had a quick look around freemasons
One site comments:
several well-known United Irishmen including Henry Joy McCracken, Henry Monroe, and Archibald Hamilton Rowan

I also saw some that say Daniel O'Connell was a free mason until the catholic church condemned it.

No idea how accurate these claims are.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on May 01, 2009, 01:02:12 PM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 12:41:05 PM
Had a quick look around freemasons
One site comments:
several well-known United Irishmen including Henry Joy McCracken, Henry Monroe, and Archibald Hamilton Rowan

I also saw some that say Daniel O'Connell was a free mason until the catholic church condemned it.

No idea how accurate these claims are.
Leading United Irishmen, William Drennan was an active Mason.  It is said he influenced and shaped the United Irishmen with others in Masonic fashion and that is why it was called the brotherhood.  O'Connell was a very active Mason until the Catholic Church started to denounce it but apparently he had been inactive for some time and might have even been expelled / resigned from the Masons.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: MW on May 02, 2009, 12:45:12 AM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 10:29:43 AM
Quotethe Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange

I never understood what the feck all this degree nonsense is about?
Is it like a level you achieve by passing some test or something?


Sounds like scientology to me.

Ass about face, old son, you should've gone to a proper university ;)

Traditionally, you were 'admitted to the degree' of Bachelor of Arts, or the higher degree of Master of Arts, etc. In at least some of the 'ancient' universities, that's still how degree ceremonies function in theory* - you're being admitted to the degree, not being "awarded a degree". The concept of "a degree" as something that is awarded, is a bit of an evolutionary mutation of the term, due to how universities have developed over the centuries.

A "degree" is a class of membership, in the original sense of the term, so I'd imagine this is how it works in the Masons or the Loyal Orders. 

*Latin oaths and all!


Incidentally, myself and a mate once went into a Scientology centre in New York - laughable garbage, but that's another thead...
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: nifan on May 04, 2009, 10:26:45 AM
Quote from: MW on May 02, 2009, 12:45:12 AM
Ass about face, old son, you should've gone to a proper university ;)

Touché  ;)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Rossfan on May 04, 2009, 12:18:06 PM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 10:29:43 AM
Quotethe Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange

I never understood what the feck all this degree nonsense is about?
Is it like a level you achieve by passing some test or something?


Probably depends on how much hatred you can spew on Catholics/Catholicism without stopping for breath  ;)
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: TacadoirArdMhacha on May 04, 2009, 01:04:29 PM
Quote from: Boolerhead Mel on April 30, 2009, 03:38:09 PM
I would have to agree with Roger-the masons have been in decline for years in the north. My Father in law is one and to this end I had lunch with him a few years ago in rosemary st (think that building is closed now) lovely food by the way. I do not know what they get up at thier meeting but they do organise charity events BBQ's that kind of thing. From what I gather most of them would be very old my father in law is in his early 60's and would be one of the younger ones. I don't think that they have issues with the Catholic church as he attended my kids christening no problem. They have no links with the OO-my father in law detests them however yuo can be in both 

Is Rosemary St the place near the entrance to Victoria Square?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: KCGaelicFootball on May 04, 2009, 04:33:59 PM
Quote from: Rossfan on May 04, 2009, 12:18:06 PM
Quote from: nifan on May 01, 2009, 10:29:43 AM
Quotethe Royal Arch Purple degree in the Orange

I never understood what the feck all this degree nonsense is about?
Is it like a level you achieve by passing some test or something?


Probably depends on how much hatred you can spew on Catholics/Catholicism without stopping for breath  ;)

Bastards !!!
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Roger on May 04, 2009, 10:38:11 PM
Quote from: TacadoirArdMhacha on May 04, 2009, 01:04:29 PM
Quote from: Boolerhead Mel on April 30, 2009, 03:38:09 PM
I would have to agree with Roger-the masons have been in decline for years in the north. My Father in law is one and to this end I had lunch with him a few years ago in rosemary st (think that building is closed now) lovely food by the way. I do not know what they get up at thier meeting but they do organise charity events BBQ's that kind of thing. From what I gather most of them would be very old my father in law is in his early 60's and would be one of the younger ones. I don't think that they have issues with the Catholic church as he attended my kids christening no problem. They have no links with the OO-my father in law detests them however yuo can be in both 

Is Rosemary St the place near the entrance to Victoria Square?
Runs between Royal Avenue and North Street.  Landark near it would be Delaney's cafe / restuarant.
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Gaoth Dobhair Abu on May 05, 2009, 10:19:49 AM
Quote from: hardstation on May 04, 2009, 10:46:39 PM
The 3 C's?

;D :D ;)


Whats the one in the Cornmarket then?
Title: Re: The Masonic Lodge and The Knights are they linked?
Post by: Boolerhead Mel on May 05, 2009, 12:58:30 PM
Quote from: TacadoirArdMhacha on May 04, 2009, 01:04:29 PM
Quote from: Boolerhead Mel on April 30, 2009, 03:38:09 PM
I would have to agree with Roger-the masons have been in decline for years in the north. My Father in law is one and to this end I had lunch with him a few years ago in rosemary st (think that building is closed now) lovely food by the way. I do not know what they get up at thier meeting but they do organise charity events BBQ's that kind of thing. From what I gather most of them would be very old my father in law is in his early 60's and would be one of the younger ones. I don't think that they have issues with the Catholic church as he attended my kids christening no problem. They have no links with the OO-my father in law detests them however yuo can be in both 

Is Rosemary St the place near the entrance to Victoria Square?


No the rest of them have pinpointed it-can't miss it-talking of the 3 C's-anybody been in it have walked past often enough is the drink cheap?
Some boys in our place are avoiding the usual hunts and heading to the busmens club for a pint as it is a lot cheaper than the pubS?