Boxing Thread

[ONeill]

Reading a report that said he was floored in 2nd round so would have lost that round 10-8 so impossible for him to score 39 points in a 4 rounder! 

If you knock someone down but are judged to have lost the round then it is scored 10-9 in your favour.  Therefore 39-38 score is feasible.

It's not.

9-10 10-9 10-9 10-9

[Atticus_Finch]

General consensus was that Flintoff won 3 rounds.  1, 3 and 4 = 30 points.  Got floored in the 2nd but looks like he was also considered to have won the round otherwise so 9 points.  So gives a total of 39 points, no ?

Didn't say i agreed with it, just said it was feasible.

[Atticus_Finch]

One of the rounds maybe was scored a draw ?

[ONeill]

10-10 for one possibly. Watched it again but cannot see it.

[Tony Baloney]

Well I for one don't believe a fight was fixed. Not in boxing.

[Tony Baloney]

10-10 for one possibly. Watched it again but cannot see it.

Any footage online?

[Atticus_Finch]

Well I for one don't believe a fight was fixed. Not in boxing.

  Can't see any highlights about at the minute.  I say there would be some up on youtube tomorrow.

Agree the scoring does look a bit suspect alright.

[ONeill]

They've been up on youtube this yonks. If you hoors....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xPxU0QFcmJA

[ONeill]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cQX3_DO-hc

[Atticus_Finch]

How far do you think Price can go Atticus?

Not sure to be honest.  He seems to have the physique, power and attributes to be a top class heavyweight but I can't get over excited on account of his most recent victories as although they were impressive it was against very mediocre opposition in Harrison and Skelton.

Think his next fight is going to be against Tony Thompson who has been Ko'd twice by Wladimir Klitschko. 

I'd say that will be the path that Maloney has him on for a while, facing former Klitschko victims.  I think himself and Fury will be kept apart for a good while yet.  Whether he is capable of beating a Klitschko is another story.  Vitali Klitschko has said he hasn't hung up the gloves AFAIK but by the time Price would be in a position to challenge him you would imagine he will be long retired.  Wladimir should still be about for the next few years and if he keeps progressing he would definitely give him a fight IMO and at the minute there doesn't seem to be an abundance of boxers in the heavyweight division that would be capable of doing that.

[Tony Baloney]

I had it Flintoff 10-9 Dawson, 8-10, 10-9, 10-9 which still has Flintoff winning by a point.

[ONeill]

You think he lost the round he was knocked down in (despite the KO)?

[Atticus_Finch]

Reading a report that said he was floored in 2nd round so would have lost that round 10-8 so impossible for him to score 39 points in a 4 rounder! 

If you knock someone down but are judged to have lost the round then it is scored 10-9 in your favour.  Therefore 39-38 score is feasible.

Got a text from a lad demanding i back this up with a source  !  As O'Neill has already highlighted, my searching skills could do with a bit of work ! But the first google search i did provided the following:

http://neutralcorneronline.com/how-to-score-a-fight/

http://www.secondsout.com/ringside/boxing-mavens-corner/what-you-scored-a-10-8-round

[Tony Baloney]

You think he lost the round he was knocked down in (despite the KO)?

Yes. He hardly landed leather in Round 2 regardless - draw at best and the two commentators gave it a 10-8 round. I think he did enough to win it so I think the 39 score does him a disservice if it calls into question the result. Quality was poor though, some desperate open handed slaps.

[Atticus_Finch]

Would agree with how you scored it.  Although,  felt there was very little between them in the fourth round. 

I felt the commentary gave Flintoff more credit than he deserved in the fourth e.g. just after the 5 minute stage http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2cQX3_DO-hc the commentary says he landed flush, I don't think he even landed and was prevented from doing so by Dawson's arms. He landed a low percentage of clean shots.  Dawson wasn't too active either but landed a couple of counters, would say Flintoff just shaded it but not much in it.