Kerry V Cork 2pm Killarney

[manfromdelmonte]

Different set of rules for Kerry games

[smelmoth]

Paudi has long had a reputation for making the game all about him. A ridiculous decision.

Funny how RTE are now trying to shut Brolly up when he goes off on one. Shame they hadn't learned that lesson when he started on Cavanagh.

It was a terrible decision. Brolly is what he said and what he was eventually was allowed to say. Very obvious that Maloney was tring to cut him off. Should have let him say what he was trying to say and move on. Maloney seems to think that post match analysis should not contain any analysis of things that have already happened.

Personally thought Brolly was right about Cavanagh. As he was right in his comments about JO'D at half time.

[Zulu]

Good game but there was no way that was a penalty and with two lads reaching for the ball I don't see how the ref could have felt O'Donoghue was pulled down.

[smelmoth]

In fairness to Hughes you have to look at the penalty decision from his vantage point and it looks like from his view that O Donoghue was pulled down as his body was turned around as he fell to the ground and I think he only consulted with his umpires to see if it was a deliberate pulldown

Can't see how that was a penalty from any viewpoint other than possibly the Kerry dug out or the O'Donaghue living room

[twohands!!!]

I thought at first he had given it for the tackle on Donaghy in the air - that was more of a foul than on O'Donoghue.

[maigheo]

replay in Killarney july 18th

[Throw ball]

Quote of the year
" Paudie wouldn't know a penalty if it bit him in the arse"

He is an annoying p***k of a referee. It is always more about him than the players. Someone should tell him at half-time that he had enough TV time

You must be a hell of a referee.

[Syferus]

replay in Killarney july 18th

A reverse-Mayo so to speak.

[Throw ball]

It appears Armagh refereeing is just as poor as their footballers.

Would love it if the footballers only made one or two bad decisions in a game.

[larryin89]

Replay in Killarney again, why? Is it because pairc ui caomh is out of use, if so surely it should go to neutral venue? Or is that the arrangement in Munster.

[joemamas]

It appears Armagh refereeing is just as poor as their footballers.

Would love it if the footballers only made one or two bad decisions in a game.

Are you PH or a relative. EVerybody makes a mistake. No doubting that.
Can you deny that even when he is a linesman that he is on on the field to the ref more than any other linesman.
My personal opinion is that I hate when the ref or the linesman becomes the story.

[Throw ball]

Had Brolly a premonition at half time. He gives of about a Kerry player 'acting' at half time then the player 'buys' a penalty in second!

[Throw ball]

It appears Armagh refereeing is just as poor as their footballers.

Would love it if the footballers only made one or two bad decisions in a game.

Are you PH or a relative. EVerybody makes a mistake. No doubting that.
Can you deny that even when he is a linesman that he is on on the field to the ref more than any other linesman.
My personal opinion is that I hate when the ref or the linesman becomes the story.

You obviously have a personal beef with this referee. We all have refs we do not like particularly. For me that is Joe McQuillan. Others complain about Marty Duffy etc.. A general view of the match today will show most decisions were unbiased and correct.

[Aaron Boone]

replay in Killarney july 18th

Good boost for the winners having a competitive match before the quarters. Big gap otherwise.

[Syferus]

replay in Killarney july 18th

Good boost for the winners having a competitive match before the quarters. Big gap otherwise.

It's going to be crushing for Cork in particular if they lose though.