All stars 25

[snoopdog]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

[Mario]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

[ardtole]

No, Down didn't go deep enough in the competition to get an all star, he could possibly get a nomination.
Without a doubt he is our best prospect since since Benny Coulter, totally different type of player, but both have that x factor where there is a buzz in the crowd when they get possession. He's had a fantastic year.

[Armagh18]

No, Down didn't go deep enough in the competition to get an all star, he could possibly get a nomination.
Without a doubt he is our best prospect since since Benny Coulter, totally different type of player, but both have that x factor where there is a buzz in the crowd when they get possession. He's had a fantastic year.

Yeah fantastic player but there will probably be others ahead of him that went further. Will get a nomination surely, Havern and Magill possibly as well?

[tonto1888]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

did Niall Morgan not get an all star last year? Tyrone def werent semi finalists. Were they even quarter finalists?

[Dunneroyal]

I feel at this stage Meath are guaranteed 1 (rafferty) and probably 2 in keoghan.
Caulfield may miss out but could get ypoty
Kinsella will get a nom but without final won't get the nod same goes for Morris.

[marty34]

Sam Mulroy might get 1, as Louth won Leinster. That needs recognition I think.

[Mario]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

did Niall Morgan not get an all star last year? Tyrone def werent semi finalists. Were they even quarter finalists?

You are right they were put out at PQF stage. He's the one anomaly then.

[AnDúnAbú94]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

did Niall Morgan not get an all star last year? Tyrone def werent semi finalists. Were they even quarter finalists?

You are right they were put out at PQF stage. He's the one anomaly then.

The past two years there's been a player who went out in the PQF awarded an all star (Morgan in 2024 and Enda Smith in 2023). Its no guarantee that he'll get one but if they give one to a player who lost at that stage, he's the best placed to get one imo.

[greatpoint]

Young Thompson from Galway will make the YPOTY shortlist.

Whether he wins or not depends on how the likes of Roarty, Moore, McElholm and some of the younger Meath and Kerry players get on from here. How old are the Geaney brothers?

Maybe Roarty will get a big RTÉ writeup like Thompson did, now that Galway are out.

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

did Niall Morgan not get an all star last year? Tyrone def werent semi finalists. Were they even quarter finalists?

You are right they were put out at PQF stage. He's the one anomaly then.

The past two years there's been a player who went out in the PQF awarded an all star (Morgan in 2024 and Enda Smith in 2023). Its no guarantee that he'll get one but if they give one to a player who lost at that stage, he's the best placed to get one imo.

Michael Langan & Joe O'Connor are already ahead of him and that's even before a ball has been kicked in the semi finals.
3/6 midfield nominations will come from the All Ireland final. 2 from the semi finalists probably. Leaves one up for grabs. He has a chance of getting a nomination but it's tight.

Langan
O'Connor
Menton
Kennedy

have 4 of the 6 places already eaten up I'd say.

[Armagh18]

It's too early to talk about All-Stars. Winners and runners up usually get 11. Louth will get one. That leaves 3. 3 from Armagh Monaghan or Galway is deluded

Would Odhran Murdock be in with a shout?

No chance. You need to get to a QF to be in with any chance. The only non semi finalists in recent years were Enda Smith and Craig Lennon.

did Niall Morgan not get an all star last year? Tyrone def werent semi finalists. Were they even quarter finalists?

You are right they were put out at PQF stage. He's the one anomaly then.

The past two years there's been a player who went out in the PQF awarded an all star (Morgan in 2024 and Enda Smith in 2023). Its no guarantee that he'll get one but if they give one to a player who lost at that stage, he's the best placed to get one imo.

Michael Langan & Joe O'Connor are already ahead of him and that's even before a ball has been kicked in the semi finals.
3/6 midfield nominations will come from the All Ireland final. 2 from the semi finalist probably. Leaves one up for grabs. He has a chance of getting but it's tight.

He could get nominated in the half forward line. 

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

He could but that'd be harder again IMO. Those 6 spots fill up very quickly.

[trueblue1234]

Billy Hogan
Seamus Lavin
Sean Rafferty
Ronan Ryan
Donal Keogan
Sean Coffey
Ciaran Caulfield
Bryan Menton
Adam O'Neill
Conor Duke
Ruairi Kinsella
Mathew Costello
Jordan Morris
Keith Curtis
Eoghan Frayne

Possibly Clifford to get a spot if he has a good semi and final.

[Dunneroyal]

Billy Hogan
Seamus Lavin
Sean Rafferty
Ronan Ryan
Donal Keogan
Sean Coffey
Ciaran Caulfield
Bryan Menton
Adam O'Neill
Conor Duke
Ruairi Kinsella
Mathew Costello
Jordan Morris
Keith Curtis
Eoghan Frayne

Possibly Clifford to get a spot if he has a good semi and final.

That's more like it. Although billy may miss out. But I'd agree with that selection wholeheartedly