Quote from: Whishtup on August 29, 2013, 11:18:42 PMQuote from: Bod Mor on August 29, 2013, 09:01:19 AMQuote from: rrhf on August 29, 2013, 06:39:24 AMAh look here, are ye seriously still going on about this? Have you ever played football?? No way in hell is a ref going to give a free for that. It was shoulder to shoulder, fair and square.
Yeah 'twas the use of the hip done the business on petie Harte as well
Harte came off worse because he didn't enter the tackle with the intensity that Cunnife did. What do you expect, Cunnife to allow Harte stroll in on goal? He did his job and fair f&$@s to him for doing so. If he pulled out of that challenge he would be hauled off straight away. Cunnife set the tone for the rest of the game, Mayo weren't going to lie down and were going to battle for every dingle ball. His team-mates would have been inspired by that challenge.
You know as well as I do the difference between that and what Penrose did against Monaghan. If ya cant take good clean football then you're following the wrong sport.
I don't know. when I was growing up, a fair shoulder was used when two players were running in the direction of the ball side by side-that was the training drill. The shoulder 'hit' where somebody gets nailed because they are shouldered from an opposite angle with the ball or reaching for the ball has crept into football and hurling this past ten years (as players have become physically stronger) and is seen as something acceptable where it should be viewed as something dangerous. I think that they have clamped down somewhat on this tackle in hurling this year.
What's your feelings on Aiden O'Shea's tr**p-actin' -grasping at Col Cav's throat, dropping the knee and then clutching his face after big Packie gave him a dunder? is that good clean football? CCCCCCCCCC?
My feelings on that were Colm Cavanagh went down very easy, as soon as he felt any sort of contact on the way up he leapt backwards. It was very similar to when McFadden tried to con the ref into getting O'Shea booked in the 1/4 final. Yes there was contact and yes it was a free. What O'Shea did after he got tackled by the keeper was inexcusable and when he watches it again on TV he will naturally feel emabarrassed. There's no place for that in the game.
By the way what are your feelings on what Penrose did to Dessie Moane?