Ulster JFC/IFC 2026

Started by DownFanatic, September 30, 2026, 03:23:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Armagh18

Quote from: Onhisboot on November 04, 2026, 09:01:38 AM
Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 08:49:13 AM
Quote from: DownFanatic on November 04, 2026, 08:30:02 AMSay it every year. Whilst the JFC and IFC provincial and All Ireland competitions are extremely enjoyable and provide a pathway to Croke Park, they are in essence completely unbalanced lotteries. Mainly due to the different grading systems across the board and the lack of uniformity in competition eligibility.

Down use the same system as Cavan. In 2026 you had division 4 teams competing at intermediate level (Tullylish) and division 3 teams competing at Junior (East Belfast). Drumgath were in division 3 this year whilst being a senior club, while Rostrevor won intermediate from divsion 2.

Personally I prefer this system than the Tyrone model that Armagh have since adopted where league and championship are linked. I've always believed clubs should only move up a championship grade once they've won the grade below.
I just look at it from player point of view, I personally would hate only having a few competitive games at the end of a season rather than having 15 highly competitive league games as well as championship
Agreed, league not the be all and end all in Armagh but still important and competitive. Think the split into 1a 1b etc definitely helps keep things interesting in the league.

ranch

Quote from: Armagh18 on November 04, 2026, 09:33:57 AM
Quote from: Onhisboot on November 04, 2026, 09:01:38 AM
Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 08:49:13 AM
Quote from: DownFanatic on November 04, 2026, 08:30:02 AMSay it every year. Whilst the JFC and IFC provincial and All Ireland competitions are extremely enjoyable and provide a pathway to Croke Park, they are in essence completely unbalanced lotteries. Mainly due to the different grading systems across the board and the lack of uniformity in competition eligibility.

Down use the same system as Cavan. In 2026 you had division 4 teams competing at intermediate level (Tullylish) and division 3 teams competing at Junior (East Belfast). Drumgath were in division 3 this year whilst being a senior club, while Rostrevor won intermediate from divsion 2.

Personally I prefer this system than the Tyrone model that Armagh have since adopted where league and championship are linked. I've always believed clubs should only move up a championship grade once they've won the grade below.
I just look at it from player point of view, I personally would hate only having a few competitive games at the end of a season rather than having 15 highly competitive league games as well as championship
Agreed, league not the be all and end all in Armagh but still important and competitive. Think the split into 1a 1b etc definitely helps keep things interesting in the league.
But league isn't the be all and end all for any club or player. It all boils down to championship. Of course leagues are nice to win and nobody ever sets out to lose a match, but championship is what people dream about winning.
I also don't like clubs being relegated to a lower championship grade due to their county players having missed 80% of their league games.

Mick Bustin

Championship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

tiempo

Quote from: DownFanatic on November 04, 2026, 08:30:02 AMSay it every year. Whilst the JFC and IFC provincial and All Ireland competitions are extremely enjoyable and provide a pathway to Croke Park, they are in essence completely unbalanced lotteries. Mainly due to the different grading systems across the board and the lack of uniformity in competition eligibility.

Which is why the Junior and Inter are often called the biggest dwarf, as they aren't usually small time fairytale, but more a case of a cooked system, deliberate to deliver soft All-Irelands, Kerry and Cavan case in point

Biggest to ever win the Junior, Ballinasloe or Na Gaeil
Biggest to ever win the Intermediate, Westport
Smallest to ever win the Senior, Caltra

There needs to be standardisation to manage Junior/Inter though doubt it'll happen

JoG2

Not linking seems like a 6 month kick about (10 months training + s&c) on firm pitches under the sunshine until a few serious games after the summer. 100+ pitch sessions for 2 / 3 / 4 'meaningful' games.  How Irish is that ?

Add into that, a team plying their trade in the lower divisions welcoming big hitters into their championship. That's a 6 months social football followed by a futile tilt at championship, rinse and repeat. Much drop out at adult level in the lower leagues ?

ranch

Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.

Armagh18

Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 01:10:47 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.
Cullyhanna deservedly dropped down due to a lot more reasons than the county players. Their championship performances weren't pulling up any trees either before they went down.

nrico2006

Anybody got a nice list of the last 20 league and championship winners in Tyrone to see any patterns?
'To the extreme I rock a mic like a vandal, light up a stage and wax a chump like a candle.'

Mick Bustin

Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 01:10:47 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.
Cullyhanna were deservedly relegated that year. Had their county men back for tail end of league and still went down. By the same token they secured back to back promotions, mostly without their county men to reach 1A.

Tír na nÓg's fortunes arent really going to be dictated by Conaty's availability, likewise St Paul's with Murnin and Belleeks with O'Neill. They all had poor showings in the league and equally poor showings with their county men on board for championship. Maybe at junior level a county player will make a huge difference but at intermediate and senior level I don't think it's the same. 


Onhisboot

Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 01:10:47 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.
I do understand your point and I suppose this is an issue annually in Tyrone because the only real solution is playing a certain amount of starred fixtures and holding the league start date back a while which causes a congested fixture list down the line. In Junior and Intermediate this is a bigger issue because there isn't starred games due to majority of clubs not being affected and the clubs that are wont play without their u20 players. For example I think Fintona were the only team in junior with u20 players and started 4 games behind everyone else and Beragh and Cookstown off the top of my head in intermediate to accomodate having full strength teams.
In senior i would say the problem of relegation, i dont think is really an issue, like the majority of the time the teams that go down arent affected really by missing county men for example omagh and either moortown and dungannon werent really hampered by missing players to the county this season.
It isnt perfect but it means that every game means something for players as they have something to gain or something to lose at the end of the season.

Armagh18

Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 02:09:49 PM
Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 01:10:47 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.
Cullyhanna were deservedly relegated that year. Had their county men back for tail end of league and still went down. By the same token they secured back to back promotions, mostly without their county men to reach 1A.

Tír na nÓg's fortunes arent really going to be dictated by Conaty's availability, likewise St Paul's with Murnin and Belleeks with O'Neill. They all had poor showings in the league and equally poor showings with their county men on board for championship. Maybe at junior level a county player will make a huge difference but at intermediate and senior level I don't think it's the same. 
Having seen the above 3 this year, the county men make an enormous difference. St Pauls would have been nowhere near knocking on the door of winning intermediate the last 6 or 7 years without Murnin, Belleek without O'Neill are a different team, they were robbed against Keady who themselves only lost the final thanks to missing an easy 2 pointer, Conaty regularly scores 1-7 plus when he plays for the club.

Mick Bustin

Tír na nÓg are close to junior standard and St Paul's are on the way out and won't be far behind them in the next year or two.

Ethan Tremblay

Quote from: Armagh18 on November 04, 2026, 02:42:34 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 02:09:49 PM
Quote from: ranch on November 04, 2026, 01:10:47 PM
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 12:23:03 PMChampionship will always be top dog but the league is taken a hell of a lot more seriously these days. It is not easy winning a senior competition in Armagh. We have a competitive championship and a very competitive league at senior level. Ask anyone from Madden, Killeavy, Dromintee, Clann Eireann and I guarantee they absolutely cherish their league medals. As for missing county players. I don't think any of the clubs relegated to intermediate or junior had any county men.

Cullyhanna did a few years ago and they pissed the intermediate the following year before going on to win the AI at that level. Tor na nog have been flirting with dropping down to junior lately-their best player misses the vast majority of their league games every season as he's with the county team. Personally I don't think it's fair that championship grades are dictated by league performance but I also accept that my view is a minority one within the county at the moment.
Cullyhanna were deservedly relegated that year. Had their county men back for tail end of league and still went down. By the same token they secured back to back promotions, mostly without their county men to reach 1A.

Tír na nÓg's fortunes arent really going to be dictated by Conaty's availability, likewise St Paul's with Murnin and Belleeks with O'Neill. They all had poor showings in the league and equally poor showings with their county men on board for championship. Maybe at junior level a county player will make a huge difference but at intermediate and senior level I don't think it's the same. 
Having seen the above 3 this year, the county men make an enormous difference. St Pauls would have been nowhere near knocking on the door of winning intermediate the last 6 or 7 years without Murnin, Belleek without O'Neill are a different team, they were robbed against Keady who themselves only lost the final thanks to missing an easy 2 pointer, Conaty regularly scores 1-7 plus when he plays for the club.

Players make a difference to a team, but they are where they are without them also.  In Armagh, the heavily favoured teams during the league went on to win the championships.  At junior, Ballyheagan won the league without their county man and were heavily favoured based off their league form to win the championship. 

St Peters/Ogs were heavily favoured to win the intermediate league and championship at the start of the year also.  One won the league, the other won the championship (not fully sure, but no established county men in either team if any). 

No one was giving TirNaNog, St.Pauls or Beleek a chance at intermediate with their county men back. 

Personally, I feel playing at a higher level in league and going into a lower championship will give that team an advantage. In Armagh anyway, the players are better, pace is a bit faster, some teams are better organised. 

For that reason I wouldn't be shocked to see either St.Peters or the Ogs drop down again next year.  Best of luck to the Armagh teams out this weekend. 
I tend to think of myself as a one man wolfpack...

ranch

Quote from: Armagh18 on November 04, 2026, 01:24:49 PMCullyhanna deservedly dropped down due to a lot more reasons than the county players. Their championship performances weren't pulling up any trees either before they went down.
I agree they hadn't been great for a few years. They were still nowhere near the level of an intermediate team, as was shown by the manner they won the intermediate championship a year later.
I feel having relegation between the grades linked to championship performances is a much fairer system. However, as I said already, I accept this is unlikely to happen as the majority clearly prefer the current set up.
Quote from: Mick Bustin on November 04, 2026, 03:59:14 PMTír na nÓg are close to junior standard and St Paul's are on the way out and won't be far behind them in the next year or two.

My point is that they could be relegated to a lower level of championship based off league performances. Without Conaty for the majority of their games is obviously a massive factor.

Quote from: Ethan Tremblay on November 04, 2026, 04:16:12 PMPlayers make a difference to a team, but they are where they are without them also.  In Armagh, the heavily favoured teams during the league went on to win the championships.  At junior, Ballyheagan won the league without their county man and were heavily favoured based off their league form to win the championship. 

St Peters/Ogs were heavily favoured to win the intermediate league and championship at the start of the year also.  One won the league, the other won the championship (not fully sure, but no established county men in either team if any). 

No one was giving TirNaNog, St.Pauls or Beleek a chance at intermediate with their county men back. 

Personally, I feel playing at a higher level in league and going into a lower championship will give that team an advantage. In Armagh anyway, the players are better, pace is a bit faster, some teams are better organised. 

For that reason I wouldn't be shocked to see either St.Peters or the Ogs drop down again next year.  Best of luck to the Armagh teams out this weekend. 

Belleek struggled in the league for a combination of reasons, injuries being the main one. Once at full strength they put in a decent showing in the championship.
I take your point about the teams that won the league backing it up come championship. Last year however we had a situation where Tullysaran won the intermediate league before getting trounced in championship against teams who had their county men available. They then spent this year at senior level when they likely would have only been 4th/5th favourites for an intermedidate championship. That said, I'm sure they welcomed the opportunity to compete against the likes of Cross and Madden in the group stage.