The O'Sheas versus the O'Neills

Started by Armaghtothebone, June 26, 2025, 10:26:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Armaghtothebone

Let me start by saying...do not take seriously, just a wee bit of fun.

To take my mind off the upcoming 1/4 final I started thinking about how many great players there were called O'Shea and if any other surname could compete.
The only other name I could come up with was ONeill. If anyone has another feel absolutely free to say so. THIS IS JUST FOR A BIT OF CRACK.

For the O'Sheas I have ( in no order)

Paudi ( for youngsters..a legend)
Jack ( for youngsters, as good a midfielder as ever put on a pair of boots)
Darragh
Marc
Thomas
Seanie
Aidan

Who have I missed?
Older Kerry fans...please step up!

For the O'Neills, again no order than a pure Armagh bias!

Rian
Oisin
Gareth
Stephen
Sean ( for benefit of youngsters on GAA team of century...wobbler can tell you more) My 90 year old dad described him as " take the best of Clifford, Matt Connor, Linden and  that would be him)
Dr. Pat ( again for youngsters a key part of Heffos brilliant Dublin team of the seventies).

So who have I missed?
Is there an O'Neill or an O'Shea who played on an All Ireland winning club team?

Is there another surname that could be added. You'd think Murphy would be a cert. but after Michael and Vinny ( Dublin) I'm struggling.

Over to you.








Armagh18

Jimmy Barry Murphy? Paul Murphy Kerry

armaghniac

MAGA Make Armagh Great Again

tiempo

Quote from: Armagh18 on June 26, 2025, 10:32:49 AMJimmy Barry Murphy? Paul Murphy Kerry

Slab Murphy, for the jersey sponsor
What nights training btw?

oakleafgael

Gerry and Leo O'Neill both excellent footballers in the late 50s/early 60's for Derry. Their younger brother was better but went on to win the European Cup rather than the Anglo Celt or Sam Maguire.

clonian

Harry O'Neill from Antrim is one I remember my da talking about - must be the 40s though

AustinPowers

McCartan , Down
Joyce, Galway
Donnellan, Galway
Canavan, Tyrone
McHugh, Donegal
McCarthy, Cork/Dublin/Kerry
O'Rourke, Armagh/Meath/Down

As for more O'Neill's - Pearse, Cork
O'Shea - Billy. Wasn't  he the player Maurice Fitzgerald accidentally injured in 1997?

paddyjohn

Downeys and McGurks both from Lavey

blanketattack

There's been twice as many O'Sullivans that played for Kerry as there has been O'Sheas.
Some of the better known O'Sullivans:
Cian O'Sullivan (Dublin)
Declan O'Sullivan (Kerry)
Tom O'Sullivan x2 (Rathmore, Dingle)
Darran O'Sullivan (Kerry)
Donie O'Sullivan (Kerry) (60s and 70s - 2 All-Stars)
Mickey Ned O'Sullivan (Kerry) (Captain in 75 but was stretchered off and 19 year old Pat Spillane stood in for him to accept Sam and make the speech - we haven't been able to shut him up since!)
Graham O'Sullivan (Kerry)
Sean O'Sullivan (Kerry)
Charlie O'Sullivan (Kerry) (won 4 A-Is from 1932 - 1941)
Ciarán O'Sullivan (Cork)
Kevin Jer O'Sullivan (Cork)
Tony O'Sullivan (Cork) Famous hurler but excellent footballer also, won minor and u21 All-Irelands in both codes.
Cormac Sullivan (Meath)

For the O'Sheas, Billy and Barry were on the 97 All-Ireland winning team.
Jerome O'Shea won 2 All-Irelands for Kerry in the 50s.
Does Shea Fahy count for the Sheas???

AustinPowers


Knock Yer Mucker In

John Joe O Neill, a legend in his own head
local expert is as sick as a dog, ate to many mc dollars


Truth hurts

Quote from: Armaghtothebone on June 26, 2025, 10:26:19 AMLet me start by saying...do not take seriously, just a wee bit of fun.

To take my mind off the upcoming 1/4 final I started thinking about how many great players there were called O'Shea and if any other surname could compete.
The only other name I could come up with was ONeill. If anyone has another feel absolutely free to say so. THIS IS JUST FOR A BIT OF CRACK.

For the O'Sheas I have ( in no order)

Paudi ( for youngsters..a legend)
Jack ( for youngsters, as good a midfielder as ever put on a pair of boots)
Darragh
Marc
Thomas
Seanie
Aidan

Who have I missed?
Older Kerry fans...please step up!

For the O'Neills, again no order than a pure Armagh bias!

Rian
Oisin
Gareth
Stephen
Sean ( for benefit of youngsters on GAA team of century...wobbler can tell you more) My 90 year old dad described him as " take the best of Clifford, Matt Connor, Linden and  that would be him)
Dr. Pat ( again for youngsters a key part of Heffos brilliant Dublin team of the seventies).

So who have I missed?
Is there an O'Neill or an O'Shea who played on an All Ireland winning club team?

Is there another surname that could be added. You'd think Murphy would be a cert. but after Michael and Vinny ( Dublin) I'm struggling.

Over to you.









Sean's brothers Kevin was wing back on the 1960 team . They are from the fame family as Rian and Oisin

blanketattack

Micheál Ó'Sé (Kerry) - won two All-Irelands in 69, 70.
More famous for being the commentator in Irish for the minor games when they were on RTE before the senior finals.

mup

Ryan as a surname and christain name has to be up there.

Glen Ryan
Aidan Ryan
Bobby Ryan
Diarmuid Ryan
Josh Ryan
TJ Ryan
Philly Ryan
Shane Ryan
Ryan McHugh
Ryan McMenamin
Ryan O Donoghue
Ryan Johnston
Ryan Taylor