All Ireland Club Championships 2024

[Halfquarter]

Joe Sheridan 2011 all over again.Do you think Crossmalina might give the game to Ballinderry?

Certainly nothing l8ke the Joe Sheridan incident, I don't know where you are getting that from? I didn't see anyone throwing the ball into the net .

[Milltown Row2]

He gave the ref a decision to make, it's not your stereotypical charge to be fair, he did collect the ball on the small square so 4 steps takes you to goal line, not sure what defender can do also but he clearly wraps him though

Who gave the ref a decision to make? It's as bad a call as you'll see. Wrapping him, what do you when someone comes at you full pelt, keep your arms out stretched and take the collision full on or try and soften it?

Regardless of that barge, the tackling of a player is shoulder to shoulder any other physical 'tackle' is a foul. The decision was will I blow for charging or will I blow for wrapping arms around player.. he didn't in this occasion have his arms outstretched

[JoG2]

He gave the ref a decision to make, it's not your stereotypical charge to be fair, he did collect the ball on the small square so 4 steps takes you to goal line, not sure what defender can do also but he clearly wraps him though

Who gave the ref a decision to make? It's as bad a call as you'll see. Wrapping him, what do you when someone comes at you full pelt, keep your arms out stretched and take the collision full on or try and soften it?

Regardless of that barge, the tackling of a player is shoulder to shoulder any other physical 'tackle' is a foul. The decision was will I blow for charging or will I blow for wrapping arms around player.. he didn't in this occasion have his arms outstretched

The only decision for the ref to make was a free out.

[Milltown Row2]

He gave the ref a decision to make, it's not your stereotypical charge to be fair, he did collect the ball on the small square so 4 steps takes you to goal line, not sure what defender can do also but he clearly wraps him though

Who gave the ref a decision to make? It's as bad a call as you'll see. Wrapping him, what do you when someone comes at you full pelt, keep your arms out stretched and take the collision full on or try and soften it?

Regardless of that barge, the tackling of a player is shoulder to shoulder any other physical 'tackle' is a foul. The decision was will I blow for charging or will I blow for wrapping arms around player.. he didn't in this occasion have his arms outstretched

The only decision for the ref to make was a free out.

I think he made a mistake or at least certainly rushed his decision.

[JoG2]

He gave the ref a decision to make, it's not your stereotypical charge to be fair, he did collect the ball on the small square so 4 steps takes you to goal line, not sure what defender can do also but he clearly wraps him though

Who gave the ref a decision to make? It's as bad a call as you'll see. Wrapping him, what do you when someone comes at you full pelt, keep your arms out stretched and take the collision full on or try and soften it?

Regardless of that barge, the tackling of a player is shoulder to shoulder any other physical 'tackle' is a foul. The decision was will I blow for charging or will I blow for wrapping arms around player.. he didn't in this occasion have his arms outstretched

The only decision for the ref to make was a free out.

I think he made a mistake or at least certainly rushed his decision.

Agreed.. End of an AI final, take a breath, consult your umpires

[Armagh18]

Jesus that was never a penalty, drops the shoulder and runs straight into the man, not sure if he was supposed to magically disappear or just step aside or what.

Fair play to Loftus for even being there today, can't imagine what the lad has been through and fitting for him to score the winner. Ballinderry will be sick though.

[Brendan]

Jesus boys that was scandalous against Ballinderry

[GTP]

Didn't think it was a penalty on first viewing and can't see anything to change opinion based on the replay. Not sure what the forward was doing and why he didn't shoot. Although worked out well for Crossmolina. Ballinderry should have cleared their lines with the last free.

[statto]

Awful decision charging all day long delighted loftus tucked it away man must went through hell the last few weeks.

[Halfquarter]

Jesus that was never a penalty, drops the shoulder and runs straight into the man, not sure if he was supposed to magically disappear or just step aside or what.

Fair play to Loftus for even being there today, can't imagine what the lad has been through and fitting for him to score the winner. Ballinderry will be sick though.

Ah now ! Drop's the shoulder ? That definitely didn't happen.

[Duine Inteacht Eile]

Wrong decision.

Cut & dried charging.

[p3427977]

When's the replay?

[Truthsayer]

When's the replay?

Be no replay, Ballinderry took their defeat in a sporting manner. Dreadful decision but thems the breaks. Maybe was meant to be...

[DuffleKing]

Dreadful decision. Charge all day long ffs. What's the keeper to do - move out of the way?

[Milltown Row2]

Dreadful decision. Charge all day long ffs. What's the keeper to do - move out of the way?

If he had have the 'goal' would have been disallowed