Derry Club Football & Hurling original

Started by Loup Bandit, May 08, 2007, 04:25:59 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

?

?
16 (51.6%)
?
15 (48.4%)

Total Members Voted: 31

toby47

Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

It's a poor choice of Management & backroom team. Can't hope 3 good years and another baron spell will help us at senior level. We need to be continuously challenging at minor level to start climbing the ranks again.

City Slicker

Quote from: toby47 on April 17, 2018, 12:58:28 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

It's a poor choice of Management & backroom team. Can't hope 3 good years and another baron spell will help us at senior level. We need to be continuously challenging at minor level to start climbing the ranks again.

Im sure the backroom team is bigger than that 3/4 men.What are their roles? S+C coach? Stats guy? GK coach?

allseasons

Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Real Talk

Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

theticklemister

Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

Claudy lad

City Slicker

Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

No he is a fella from Claudy,he did alot off work with our club last year, I wasnt there,but it was supposedly top notch.
Cant see what harm a young coach would cause,learning from Rocks, Muldoon,Jody Wilson etc.

lenny

Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

The question isn't why was he appointed? It's who was he appointed ahead of? Was there a queue of high quality applicants? There should be a good team there but Monaghan look to have an outstanding team given they stuffed both tyrone and donegal on the way to the ulster minor league.

City Slicker

Quote from: lenny on April 17, 2018, 09:09:35 PM
Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

The question isn't why was he appointed? It's who was he appointed ahead of? Was there a queue of high quality applicants? There should be a good team there but Monaghan look to have an outstanding team given they stuffed both tyrone and donegal on the way to the ulster minor league.


Did a bit of asking, he works with the Goalkeepers, so I assume he isnt involved with the tactical side of things.

restorepride

Quote from: City Slicker on April 17, 2018, 09:16:40 PM
Quote from: lenny on April 17, 2018, 09:09:35 PM
Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

The question isn't why was he appointed? It's who was he appointed ahead of? Was there a queue of high quality applicants? There should be a good team there but Monaghan look to have an outstanding team given they stuffed both tyrone and donegal on the way to the ulster minor league.


Did a bit of asking, he works with the Goalkeepers, so I assume he isnt involved with the tactical side of things.
Ah now I see where the senior team gets it from - goalkeepers don't do tactics. Explains a lot!!

Keyser soze

What about this week's fixtures/predictions Toby.

oakleaflad

Quote from: City Slicker on April 17, 2018, 09:16:40 PM
Quote from: lenny on April 17, 2018, 09:09:35 PM
Quote from: Real Talk on April 17, 2018, 08:51:27 PM
Quote from: allseasons on April 17, 2018, 03:26:29 PM
Quote from: oakleaflad on April 17, 2018, 12:33:51 PM
Aidan McLaughlin as part of a backroom team is hardly an issue. Did anyone have an issue with Gavin McGeehan being involved with last years team? (someone who had a similar coaching role with either Ulster or Derry GAA as far as I know).

Anyone who has seen any of Campbell's teams play before could not be surprised there was no score in their last game until 27 minutes in. It's an absolute joke that he was appointed by our county board to develop our underage players.

I see no problem with someone like Aidy being involved in a fairly minor role in the set up, maybe gathering a bit of experience as he goes. I would though question letting a man who played ultra defensive/negative football at his last 4 jobs (Steelstown, Castledawson, Glentes and Slaughtmanus) with little or no success manage our best underage players.

Cant understand why Campbell was appointed either ....

The other fellas are good coaches with Fabian and Ronan also having had Club management experience.   Aidy McLaughlin (he is from Craigbane isn't he ?) was a very good player and was on  the County Senior panel around about 2010, was unfortunate with injuries and was working away from home a lot.  Good honest committed Clubman and still youngish

The question isn't why was he appointed? It's who was he appointed ahead of? Was there a queue of high quality applicants? There should be a good team there but Monaghan look to have an outstanding team given they stuffed both tyrone and donegal on the way to the ulster minor league.


Did a bit of asking, he works with the Goalkeepers, so I assume he isnt involved with the tactical side of things.
Aidan McLaughlin (not Aidy) is Claudy's goalkeeper and has been for the last 10 years or so. Think he was on the Derry minor panel that was beat in the AI final if memory serves me rightly though he didn't start. He's not a bad keeper himself and by all accounts is a decent coach. Wouldn't be too harsh on him working with the minor keepers.
As stated previously I'd have a much bigger issue with Campbell being appointed manager, ultra defensive and discouraged kicking the ball at the previous clubs he worked with. Not sure if he actually had any success with those clubs?

Early days yet in the leagues but Coleraine, Glen and Lavey going unbeaten so far will have to be happy. Great starts too from Newbridge and Glenullin. Claudy and Kilrea will already be starting to worry on 0 points given it's the bottom 4 going down. 6 clubs on 2 points after 3 games - this is the interesting area for me over the next few weeks.

Banagher look like they should walk Div2 and will give 5th from bottom in Div1 their fill of it in a playoff.

Limavady look really strong in Div3 with maybe only Moneymore fit to give them a game.

Rawhide

They will be fun when we are getting to the end of the league season this year. I predict a number of field fights before its all over, unfortunately
cccc is a true supporter lol

JoG2


thepundit

St Oliver Plunkett's GAC, Greenlough V Ballinderry  BALLINDERRY
John Mitchel's GAC, Claudy  V Bellaghy  CLAUDY
The Loup  V Glenullin  THE LOUP
Kilrea  V Lavey  LAVEY
Slaughtneil  V Coleraine  COLERAINE
Swatragh  V O'Donovan Rossa GAC  ROSSA
Dungiven V Sean O'Leary GAC Newbridge   NEWBRIDGE
Ballinascreen  V Glen   GLEN

toby47

Quote from: JoG2 on April 19, 2018, 11:55:02 AM
Good man Sean Leo.

Good addition, pity he couldn't drag a couple more club mates with him