More Thuggery on the GAA field

[Maguire01]

I think the point which is being made is that this was no worse than the pushing and shoving at the Derrytresk match, however, there was no incursion here, which makes a difference. anyways time to let it go.

must look at the video again - I thought there were several subs from both sides in the thick of it on sunday, difference was they didnt have to jump any fences so it didnt look as bad.

Can you name those subs (their numbers)? I didn't see any, and haven't seen any in the video replays.

[Fear ón Srath Bán]

Should the other twenty or so players be banned for a bit of pushing. You'd see worse on the Coppers dancefloor.

That's the point: are they issuing penalties now where no one is really culpable, all for appearances' sake? Or are counties now liiable to be hit with a fine if a player's in receipt of a straight red card during a game?

shemozzle: a GAA euphemism for an on-field fracas.

[camanchero]

I think the point which is being made is that this was no worse than the pushing and shoving at the Derrytresk match, however, there was no incursion here, which makes a difference. anyways time to let it go.

must look at the video again - I thought there were several subs from both sides in the thick of it on sunday, difference was they didnt have to jump any fences so it didnt look as bad.

No, there weren't.

as I said, I'll look at it again if I can find it. just thought when watching it on sunday there were.

[Jinxy]

Brian Flanagan was the one man to raise his hands and he has received a ban. Niall Carew has also received a four week sideline ban for entering the playing area. Both county boards have been fined. What more do you want?

There was a 'shemozzle' involving somewhat more than 2 Kildare players, not to mention Monaghan players.

But no one bar Brian Flanagan raised their hands. He took a swipe at Paul Finlay (and missed not that it matters). Nothing else apart from plenty of pushing and shoving. Should the other twenty or so players be banned for a bit of pushing. You'd see worse on the Coppers dancefloor.

I've been slapped/hit with a handbag several times on the Coppers dancefloor.
Where's MY CCCCCC? 

[Maguire01]

I think the point which is being made is that this was no worse than the pushing and shoving at the Derrytresk match, however, there was no incursion here, which makes a difference. anyways time to let it go.

must look at the video again - I thought there were several subs from both sides in the thick of it on sunday, difference was they didnt have to jump any fences so it didnt look as bad.

No, there weren't.

as I said, I'll look at it again if I can find it. just thought when watching it on sunday there were.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

[Tubberman]

Should the other twenty or so players be banned for a bit of pushing. You'd see worse on the Coppers dancefloor.

That's the point: are they issuing penalties now where no one is really culpable, all for appearances' sake? Or are counties now liiable to be hit with a fine if a player's in receipt of a straight red card during a game?

shemozzle: a GAA euphemism for an on-field fracas.

Was there just a bit of shoving in Portlaoise?

[Fear ón Srath Bán]

Should the other twenty or so players be banned for a bit of pushing. You'd see worse on the Coppers dancefloor.

That's the point: are they issuing penalties now where no one is really culpable, all for appearances' sake? Or are counties now liiable to be hit with a fine if a player's in receipt of a straight red card during a game?

shemozzle: a GAA euphemism for an on-field fracas.

Was there just a bit of shoving in Portlaoise?

What's that got to do with it? Why are you bringing Port Laoise into it?

[camanchero]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

thanks for that.
ok kildare #17 was Johnny Doyle - so he was already on.
Monaghan had #17 & #18 - not sure if they were already on as subs.
at 3.42 a lad looking like a sub ran in - he obv looked like he was just going to pick up someones gloves that had fallen down.
this excerpt (thanks for sharing it) cuts out from the pitch at 3.43 when there is prob a bit more.
certainly I believe there was a lot more on tg4 on sunday.
still think even this clip shows there was at least one sub on- and I dont believe he was on his own and only copper fastens my view of this last sun.
This incident was feck all though- no real slaps - just like derrytreask v dromid imo.
glad the media didnt blow this one all out of proportion.

[screenexile]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

thanks for that.
ok kildare #17 was Johnny Doyle - so he was already on.
Monaghan had #17 & #18 - not sure if they were already on as subs.
at 3.42 a lad looking like a sub ran in - he obv looked like he was just going to pick up someones gloves that had fallen down.
this excerpt (thanks for sharing it) cuts out from the pitch at 3.43 when there is prob a bit more.
certainly I believe there was a lot more on tg4 on sunday.
still think even this clip shows there was at least one sub on- and I dont believe he was on his own and only copper fastens my view of this last sun.
This incident was feck all though- no real slaps - just like derrytreask v dromid imo.
glad the media didnt blow this one all out of proportion.

Me too! As long as it's just games involving Tyrone that's Ok by me

[camanchero]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

thanks for that.
ok kildare #17 was Johnny Doyle - so he was already on.
Monaghan had #17 & #18 - not sure if they were already on as subs.
at 3.42 a lad looking like a sub ran in - he obv looked like he was just going to pick up someones gloves that had fallen down.
this excerpt (thanks for sharing it) cuts out from the pitch at 3.43 when there is prob a bit more.
certainly I believe there was a lot more on tg4 on sunday.
still think even this clip shows there was at least one sub on- and I dont believe he was on his own and only copper fastens my view of this last sun.
This incident was feck all though- no real slaps - just like derrytreask v dromid imo.
glad the media didnt blow this one all out of proportion.

Me too! As long as it's just games involving Tyrone that's Ok by me

sure you got more slaps hitting you outside slaughtneil disco !

[Maguire01]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

thanks for that.
ok kildare #17 was Johnny Doyle - so he was already on.
Monaghan had #17 & #18 - not sure if they were already on as subs.
at 3.42 a lad looking like a sub ran in - he obv looked like he was just going to pick up someones gloves that had fallen down.
this excerpt (thanks for sharing it) cuts out from the pitch at 3.43 when there is prob a bit more.
certainly I believe there was a lot more on tg4 on sunday.
still think even this clip shows there was at least one sub on- and I dont believe he was on his own and only copper fastens my view of this last sun.
This incident was feck all though- no real slaps - just like derrytreask v dromid imo.
glad the media didnt blow this one all out of proportion.

Monaghan's #17 and #18 were on. Both teams started the game with 5 changes, so there were a lot of 'high numbers' on the pitch.

[Maguire01]

Kildare appealing their fine - http://www.hoganstand.com/Monaghan/ArticleForm.aspx?ID=162126

[Donnellys Hollow]

Kildare appealing their fine - http://www.hoganstand.com/Monaghan/ArticleForm.aspx?ID=162126

What McMahon meant to say is that KCB can't afford the fine!! 

[Fear ón Srath Bán]

Kildare appealing their fine - http://www.hoganstand.com/Monaghan/ArticleForm.aspx?ID=162126

What McMahon meant to say is that KCB can't afford the fine!! 

Their money's safe DH, we'll have the Kildare variant of 'The Men They Couldn't Hang' in 'The Men They Couldn't See'! 

[tyssam5]

I think the point which is being made is that this was no worse than the pushing and shoving at the Derrytresk match, however, there was no incursion here, which makes a difference. anyways time to let it go.

must look at the video again - I thought there were several subs from both sides in the thick of it on sunday, difference was they didnt have to jump any fences so it didnt look as bad.

No, there weren't.

as I said, I'll look at it again if I can find it. just thought when watching it on sunday there were.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkJnS5-HSlY
From 3.15

No meals at training until the 5k is paid off!

Some surprisingly good scores from Monaghan there. McGeeney should know the blanket type defense might offer shots from 45 yards or so, but free shots from 35 yards is bit different.