Railway cup returns!

Started by ross4life, November 16, 2011, 01:50:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Is it a good idea to bring back the Railway cup?

Yes
58 (66.7%)
No
20 (23%)
Undecided
5 (5.7%)
I like to drink in a railway tavern
4 (4.6%)

Total Members Voted: 87

Orchardman

Quote from: Syferus on February 17, 2013, 10:52:37 PM
Quote from: Orchardman on February 17, 2013, 10:44:40 PM
I'd say there is a good chance of anyone of those playing on saturday of being able to play again on sunday. Sure it's a day out in croker for them. What happened micky murphy, was he just being rested? think he named in the squad

Probably two Sigerson matches on Friday/Saturday coming up, I doubt anyone but the most rabid Ulster Inter-Provincial supporter can blame him from excusing himself on second thoughts.

Of course not, he and everyone else knew he would be playing in the sigerson next weekend sure.

Syferus

Quote from: Orchardman on February 17, 2013, 11:17:23 PM
Quote from: Syferus on February 17, 2013, 10:52:37 PM
Quote from: Orchardman on February 17, 2013, 10:44:40 PM
I'd say there is a good chance of anyone of those playing on saturday of being able to play again on sunday. Sure it's a day out in croker for them. What happened micky murphy, was he just being rested? think he named in the squad

Probably two Sigerson matches on Friday/Saturday coming up, I doubt anyone but the most rabid Ulster Inter-Provincial supporter can blame him from excusing himself on second thoughts.

Of course not, he and everyone else knew he would be playing in the sigerson next weekend sure.

Would have been chosen before DCU even made the semis - maybe he agreed conditionally, didn't want to appear presumptuous, etc. The most obvious reason would be that on top of that he may have had some sort of twinge or minor injury and they didn't want to risk him after him playing mid-week.

A different scenario here but Cathal Cregg was named in the Connacht team but didn't feature, he was chosen after he'd been injured against Fermanagh but that didn't stop him being named.

I'm surprised a lot of Sigerson-tied players don't opt out of the inter-pros voluntarily, honestly.

emainmacha

Links to photos of Ulster V Munster

Football Link


http://www.flickr.com/photos/16144312@N07/sets/72157632792317049/detail/

Hurling Link, can't see a thread on Railway Cup in hurling pages, which sums up how the competition has been ignored and brought low since I used to go to Croke Park to watch the double header semi finals two great days out.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/16144312@N07/sets/72157632788329531/detail/

BennyCake

When and where is the Railway Cup Hurling final?

emainmacha

Looked at Main Webpage and it says 3rd of March with venue and time TBC

http://www.gaa.ie/fixtures-and-results/national-fixtures/mdonnelly-gaa-interprovincial-championship/hurling/

Football next week in Croker, looks like a double header with Junior club final

our_fella

Ulster GAA Inter Provincial Football Final Team Starting Line up Sunday 24th Feb Croke Park

1. Pascal McConnell
2. Chrissy McKaigue
3. Neil McGee
4. Eamonn McGee
5. Aaron Kernan
6. Darren Hughes
7. Ciaran McKeever
8. Sean Cavanagh
9. David Givney
10. Mark McHugh
11. Martin Penrose
12. Joe McMahon
13. Jamie Clarke
14. Kevin Niblock
15. Conor McManus
16. Brendan McVeigh
17. Cathal McCarron
18. Dermot McBride
19. Mark Poland
20. Justin McMahon
21. Tommy McElroy
22. Ryan Jones
23. Gearoid McKiernan
24. Conor McAliskey
25. Paul McComiskey
26. Kieran Hughes
27. Peter Harte

Ulster 4/5 with PP.. serious odds esp with Kernan & Jamie Clarke included

Captain Obvious

Two games in two days for the Armagh players?

rodney trotter

Surprised David Giveny is starting. Sigerson semi on Friday and a possible final on Saturday.
Still a great opportunity for him to play in Croke Park.

our_fella

Quote from: rodney trotter on February 20, 2013, 09:56:15 PM
Surprised David Giveny is starting. Sigerson semi on Friday and a possible final on Saturday.
Still a great opportunity for him to play in Croke Park.

I doubt Kernan & Clarke will start for Armagh on sat. Would be unfair on the lads originally named

T Fearon

Is it not bordering on outrageous if Kernan and Clarke miss the Armagh game on Saturday night but play for Ulster on Sunday? It would mean that playing for their county now ranks third on their list of priorities.ftp://

rodney trotter

Is it that outrageous though, Armagh have named the same side that was suppose to play Wexford 2 weeks ago. Grimley said earlier in the week, that the Cross players would be given a few weeks break from County football.

T Fearon

He said he wouldn't pressure them to comeback too quickly but am sure he wouldn't have turned any if them away if they had indicated they wanted to be involved this weekend.County football is evidently third on the list of priorities in Crossmaglen

BennyCake

Quote from: T Fearon on February 20, 2013, 10:30:11 PM
Is it not bordering on outrageous if Kernan and Clarke miss the Armagh game on Saturday night but play for Ulster on Sunday? It would mean that playing for their county now ranks third on their list of priorities.ftp://

It's a strange one indeed, T.

Maybe their inclusion is to gather more supporters in Croke Park on Sunday?

drici

Quote from: T Fearon on February 20, 2013, 10:30:11 PM

Is it not verging on outrageous if Kernan and Clarke miss the Armagh game on Saturday night but play for Ulster on Sunday? It would mean that playing for their county now ranks third on their list of priorities.


That would be pure class if it happens.
Pure class.

mackers

Quote from: T Fearon on February 20, 2013, 10:30:11 PM
Is it not bordering on outrageous if Kernan and Clarke miss the Armagh game on Saturday night but play for Ulster on Sunday? It would mean that playing for their county now ranks third on their list of priorities.ftp://
It appears to be Paul Grimley's decision not to play the Cross players.  It is not the players themselves in fairness Tony.  I think Grimley's decision is odd myself and Kernan is right to play the best players available to him.
Keep your pecker hard and your powder dry and the world will turn.