Antrim Hurling

[paddyjohn]

Every ref in the county should be sent a DVD of that game yesterday and be told that is the level they should get to. Talking to players, advantage rule being played and keeping up with play also.

[Hectic]

Can anyone explain how ballycastle got the free on the 21 near the end? To me it seemed like saul got fouled after he flicked the ball on, whoever hit it wide from the wing didn't look to have been fouled. 

A bit strange that they changed free taker twice for it too.

Loughgiel's 11 was very efficient at the placed balls bar the miss early in 1st half.

I would imagine that is the advantage rule at work 

Surely if no advantage is gained, it goes back to where the foul was commited.

It was given for a late tackle after the ball was struck. For a late tackle, the free is awarded where the ball lands.

Explains it then, i didn't see the late tackle on the striker of the ball, just on saul.

i was the same, i didnt see the late foul, only the original on that advantage was given.

on that then, i take it if advantage is given and there is another foul within the advantage time does that foul then stand 

Pretty sure if there is a foul in advantage time that it is brought back to the original foul.

[Hectic]

Also what happens if you put it wide during the advantage?? What is the rule on that?

Bug bear of mine this one, especially if it is a free shot, if it is inside the time limit it has been pulled back from what I have seen.
As long as it doesnt get a ridiculous as the rugby advantage rule and is applied consistently then I think it is fair enough.

if another foul is committed after the first one then its the second one or the best advantageous one

Right ignore my last post as I would be inclined to believe this man.

[north aontroim gael]

I thought Skinny had a good game but the decision to allow Ballycastle 3 goes at that 21 yard free was a bit ridiculous.

[paddyjohn]

I thought Skinny had a good game but the decision to allow Ballycastle 3 goes at that 21 yard free was a bit ridiculous.

How? DD wouldn't stay on his line. Rules are there to be obeyed.

[north aontroim gael]

Every keeper takes a step once the striker addresses the ball. I have never seen it so pedantically enforced before.

[Jesusjones]

The thing is NAG, Skinny applied the rule properly yesterday the rest don't.

[Hectic]

Yeah I thought the referee had a good game - in fairness both teams were there to hurl which made his job a bit easier.

[paddyjohn]

Every keeper takes a step once the striker addresses the ball. I have never seen it so pedantically enforced before.

It was a crucial time in the match so he was correct to do what he did. I know what your saying though.

[theskull1]

The referee has to stand his ground and show the player(s) he's in charge. It's the player who has to yield. Anything else is poor refereeing

[Hirty Darry]

The referee has to stand his ground and show the player(s) he's in charge. It's the player who has to yield. Anything else is poor refereeing

Extremely over the top in my opinion regarding that particular series of events.

The rules also state all players must not move closer or cross the 20m line until the ball is struck, Ballycastle attackers, on each of these instances,  crossed the line before the ball was struck.  Ref was only interested in the keeper breaking the rule, when others had also offended.

Advantage was played when LW was fouled at the other end and it wasn't taken back for the free.  Footage showed it was barely two seconds, the rule is 5 seconds.

Just a couple of inconsistencies that should be pointed out.

CC has youth on his side and is making good headway but is not the finished product yet, Mr Elliott and Mr Hasson are ahead in my book and would be my shortlist for the final.

Interesting though how decisions like these give you a reason to look up the rules, some would surprise you and it's even more surprising how quite a few of them aren't being applied correctly.

MR2 is it true that only a small minority of you and you fellow whistlers passed the referee rules test?

Surely passing this should be a prerequisite before being allowed to officiate any game, or is it still the case as a ref once told me "no one fails these tests".

[Milltown Row2]

The referee has to stand his ground and show the player(s) he's in charge. It's the player who has to yield. Anything else is poor refereeing

Extremely over the top in my opinion regarding that particular series of events.

The rules also state all players must not move closer or cross the 20m line until the ball is struck, Ballycastle attackers, on each of these instances,  crossed the line before the ball was struck.  Ref was only interested in the keeper breaking the rule, when others had also offended.

Advantage was played when LW was fouled at the other end and it wasn't taken back for the free.  Footage showed it was barely two seconds, the rule is 5 seconds.

Just a couple of inconsistencies that should be pointed out.

CC has youth on his side and is making good headway but is not the finished product yet, Mr Elliott and Mr Hasson are ahead in my book and would be my shortlist for the final.

Interesting though how decisions like these give you a reason to look up the rules, some would surprise you and it's even more surprising how quite a few of them aren't being applied correctly.

MR2 is it true that only a small minority of you and you fellow whistlers passed the referee rules test?

Surely passing this should be a prerequisite before being allowed to officiate any game, or is it still the case as a ref once told me "no one fails these tests".

I believe you can't do the championship games if you don't pass the rules test and fitness test.

It's funny how everyone can read the rules and state them (cut and paste) but when their own players commit a foul they are the quietest on the sidelines!! You couldn't make it up lol!!

The top refs in the county should get the final! Pick from CC Elliot Hasson and O'Neill....

[Hirty Darry]

Good win for us although not a great game. Tiernan Coyle, Maol Connolly, Donal McKinley and Damon McMullan all put in very good performances. Great to see some of the younger lads driving the team forward now. Johnny Campbell has done a brilliant job in refreshing the team this year and giving the younger lads their chance.

The final will be a much tougher proposition but the team are where they want to be.

The other Mr Campbell hasn't done so bad in giving the youth a chance either!

[Na Glinntí Glasa]

Johnny has given them the chance because he has no choice in it. If your playing a team thats mostly over 30 your getting into problems down the line with who to replace them. not everyone is so patient and will sit on the bench for years on their chance.

skinny imo is one of the best refs in the county. he calls the game fair and right any time ive seen him. hes talks to the players all the time, expains to them what they have done wrong in a foul and lets the game go.

E Hasson is up there as well for me, hes really good any time ive seen him

[paddyjohn]

Johnny has given them the chance because he has no choice in it. If your playing a team thats mostly over 30 your getting into problems down the line with who to replace them. not everyone is so patient and will sit on the bench for years on their chance.

skinny imo is one of the best refs in the county. he calls the game fair and right any time ive seen him. hes talks to the players all the time, expains to them what they have done wrong in a foul and lets the game go.

E Hasson is up there as well for me, hes really good any time ive seen him

Hasson is likely the favourite for it, Could Skinny get 2 finals in a row?