The Offical Glasgow Celtic thread

[tonto1888]

So you can't say where I said I want Celtic to flip players. You can't give his stats under Rodgers. You haven't defined what two very successful seasons at Aberdeen were? Grand job.

[Angelo]

So you can't say where I said I want Celtic to flip players. You can't give his stats under Rodgers. You haven't defined what two very successful seasons at Aberdeen were? Grand job.

Well you are vehemently against Celtic paying their best players what they are worth so if you don't want the club to flip players then why don't you want them to try and keep their best players.

On the other side of the City they have not sold a key player since they came back up, guys like Tavernier, Morelos, Kent, Kamara and Barisic have all remained despite interest elsewhere, meanwhile we have been busy getting rid of all out key men in that time and plugging gaps with loan deals. Biscuit tin mentality.

I told you he scored double figures under Rodgers, in his half a season or whatever, became a regular in the team, man of the match in our best display that season - beating RB Leipzig 2-1 at home in the EL. The only goal in the League Cup final against Aberdeen. Two successful seasons at Aberdeen where we was a consistent regular and one of their key players.

So give me an answer maybe at the 10th time of asking. Why are you so against Celtic offering Edouard a contract at about 3m a year?

[tonto1888]

So you can't say where I said I want Celtic to flip players. You can't give his stats under Rodgers. You haven't defined what two very successful seasons at Aberdeen were? Grand job.

Well you are vehemently against Celtic paying their best players what they are worth so if you don't want the club to flip players then why don't you want them to try and keep their best players.

On the other side of the City they have not sold a key player since they came back up, guys like Tavernier, Morelos, Kent, Kamara and Barisic have all remained despite interest elsewhere, meanwhile we have been busy getting rid of all out key men in that time and plugging gaps with loan deals. Biscuit tin mentality.

I told you he scored double figures under Rodgers, in his half a season or whatever, became a regular in the team, man of the match in our best display that season - beating RB Leipzig 2-1 at home in the EL. The only goal in the League Cup final against Aberdeen. Two successful seasons at Aberdeen where we was a consistent regular and one of their key players.

So give me an answer maybe at the 10th time of asking. Why are you so against Celtic offering Edouard a contract at about 3m a year?

I have never said I am against Celtic paying their players. Point out where I said this. Vehemently or otherwise.
I have said I want us to keep our best players. Is this another of example of you just ignoring things which don't fit your argument? And making up other stuff?
How many hols did he score? How many appearances?
Where did I say I was against Celtic offering edouard any sort of contract? Another example of you making stuff up???

How many games did Christie play in his first season at Aberdeen? Are you going to admit you were very wrong about his first season at Celtic being fantastic?

[dublin7]

 

Celtic don't need this Donegal fella as DoF they have one here that will sort them out very quickly.

Deluded springs to mind if you think those players are worth that. Clubs don't pay that for players from the SPL, too much of a risk and in current climate as well, money not been spent.

And even the dog on the street knows that clubs have to operate in a wage structure. You pay one man £65k a week and you'll have a queue of agents down the hall looking for new contracts and any new signings looking these levels.

By all means, put contracts on table, negotiate and get them adding years to protect value but you can't risk the club on back of potential CL earnings.

I'd have no doubts that Desmond has sounded out new managers but is struggling to get the right man, interest not there at top end to manage a SPL team for 4 old firm games a year.

If they won't they pay then they shouldn't go.

They have no problem paying £40m for players from the English Championship so they should not have any problems paying that for players with European football pedigree.

You once again let your bias for beloved English Premier League cloud your judgement.

Sorry wee Man, you're all over the place, could you rewrite the first line in English, thanks.

You're triggered by criticism of your beloved EPL which you claim not to have an interest in.

You seem to have a bizarre obsession with Celtic.

Have you struggled to even figure what you tried to say yourself? Don't worry about it, reading and writing can be a challenge for some, chin up.

You don't seem to have anything to offer only inane posts when your obsession is outlined. Anglophiles like yourself have deep conflictions. So unless you have anything worthwhile to contribute that will be all.

From the man who obsesses over a British club.

Celtic are an Irish club.

You seem to have been been triggered by the anglophile comment. Is it Liverpool or Man Utd?

They may have Irish links but they are not an Irish club.  How can they be if they are based in Scotland?  As for your question, unlike you, I support a team in the country where i live!

Can someone explain to me how the football team Celtic FC that was formed in Glasgow Scotland, plays it's home games in Glasgow Scotland in the Scottish Premier League is Irish?

If I'm mistaken in thinking Celtic are Scottish and are actually Irish are Hibernian FC Irish and not Scottish as well?

How much do you know about Celtics history?

I know they were founded in Glasgow and even with my limited geography knowledge I know that's in Scotland or the UK. They may have been founded by an Irishman, but that doesn't make them Irish. They are a UK club with links to Ireland, there is a difference.

An Irish club to me is Bohemians or Dundalk for example as they were founded and play in Ireland.

[tonto1888]

So not a lot. That's all you had to say

[dublin7]

So not a lot. That's all you had to say

You asked, I answered. If you can give can give me a reasonable explanation as to why the club is Irish and not Scottish please do

[tonto1888]

So not a lot. That's all you had to say

You asked, I answered. If you can give can give me a reasonable explanation as to why the club is Irish and not Scottish please do

People class then as Irish because of their history. Founded by an Irish priest to provide for the poor Irish of Glasgow. Lots of Irishmen involved in their foundation and what have you. There has always been a big Irish connection. Personally I don't really think Celtic are an Irish club more a club in Scotland woth Irish roots and connections.  It thats a brief overview of why people class them as Irish

[bennydorano]

I can remember a night in Armagh in the 90s when Matt McGlone was over visiting (flogging his book - still have it) and Geordie Carson, god rest him, a hardcore Celtic supporter was arguing the bit out with Matt that Celtic were an Irish club located in Scotland! I would have thought he would have heard that nonsense regularly enough but he looked totally bemused!

[Main Street]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

[dublin7]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

Indeed. Imagine believing a club formed and based in Scotland was Scottish. Shame on me and my ignorance. I never claimed Celtic didn't have Irish links but to claim them as an Irish club is reaching. It's a good marketing strategy though for the club.

Hibernian were also formed by Irish men and have the shamrock on their badge, but they don't seem to push the Irish angle as much.

[Angelo]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

Indeed. Imagine believing a club formed and based in Scotland was Scottish. Shame on me and my ignorance. I never claimed Celtic didn't have Irish links but to claim them as an Irish club is reaching. It's a good marketing strategy though for the club.

Hibernian were also formed by Irish men and have the shamrock on their badge, but they don't seem to push the Irish angle as much.

We do not expect an Anglophile like you to get it. Jog on.

[tonto1888]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

Indeed. Imagine believing a club formed and based in Scotland was Scottish. Shame on me and my ignorance. I never claimed Celtic didn't have Irish links but to claim them as an Irish club is reaching. It's a good marketing strategy though for the club.

Hibernian were also formed by Irish men and have the shamrock on their badge, but they don't seem to push the Irish angle as much.

Marketing strategy. Aye. That's all it is. Ejit. I will give you one thing though. You have United me and Angelo. So well done on that one.

[dublin7]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

Indeed. Imagine believing a club formed and based in Scotland was Scottish. Shame on me and my ignorance. I never claimed Celtic didn't have Irish links but to claim them as an Irish club is reaching. It's a good marketing strategy though for the club.

Hibernian were also formed by Irish men and have the shamrock on their badge, but they don't seem to push the Irish angle as much.

Marketing strategy. Aye. That's all it is. Ejit. I will give you one thing though. You have United me and Angelo. So well done on that one.

Celtic push the Irish links as it's a guaranteed money spinner.
Why wouldn't they? They'd be stupid not to.

I'm regularly in Edinburgh for work and rugby and Hibs don't go for the Irish club thing at all.

[JimStynes]

Celtic are a Scottish team with a massive Irish connection. Is that not widely accepted? Do people from here actually think it's an Irish club even though they are literally based in Scotland and play soccer in the Scottish league? I don't agree with the marketing statement, but what has dublin7 said that is wrong?

Then there are the obvious sectarian reasons for fans supporting Celtic and Rangers over here.

[red hander]

Any idiot could do a bit of research and find out about the history and ethos of Celtic fc and and the direct connection to the history of emigration to Glasgow and Scotland from the 1850's onward, how that connection endured obstacles and is as strong today as it was in the foundation days.but apparently not  jackeen7

Indeed. Imagine believing a club formed and based in Scotland was Scottish. Shame on me and my ignorance. I never claimed Celtic didn't have Irish links but to claim them as an Irish club is reaching. It's a good marketing strategy though for the club.

Hibernian were also formed by Irish men and have the shamrock on their badge, but they don't seem to push the Irish angle as much.

What do you think the club's name means?