Quote from: blanketattack on August 09, 2011, 02:17:51 PM
Murphy was better in the air and a better shot stopper, plus he has 4 All-Ireland medals.
[/quote]
I never rated Murphy, he wasn't much of a shot stopper imo and I can't recall much about his aerial prowess. Having 4 all ireland medals means that he played in damned good team, next you'll be telling me that Charlie Nelligan was the finest keeper ever.
I'd agree that Cluxton has got handy all stars simply because he plays for Dublin (and not necessarily based on his performances that year) but that doesn't mean he's not been the best keeper for the past 10 years.