Club Championships 2025

Started by SouthOfThe Bann, July 29, 2025, 11:06:11 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Schkite

From what I hear, O'Toole will be available for Scotstown in the rescheduled game - he's deemed as having served his suspension at the weekend. So that will be a boost to Scotstown, and it also gives McCarthy another week to regain fitness, though I'd still doubt he'll start this weekend

Blowitupref

Is the ref going to finally blow his whistle?... No, he's going to blow his nose

smort


twohands!!!

Quote from: DaleCooper on November 23, 2025, 06:50:59 PMMarty34 yep its ridiculous TG4 cant spend a few grand and buy the spinner lens that solves this. I note they used the behind goals camera a lot prob because it was clean

The fact that it's an ongoing issue for years and years with the TG4 coverage says it all.

As a comparison I think games on Clubber don't seem to be affected half as much by rain on the cameras.
I don't know is the placement of their cameras or are they using different equipment and maybe I've just been very lucky with the games I've watched on Clubber but I'm struggling to think of any game I've watched that has been as badly affected with rain as the TG4 coverage seems to be.

Main Street

Quote from: Schkite on November 24, 2025, 02:45:42 PMFrom what I hear, O'Toole will be available for Scotstown in the rescheduled game - he's deemed as having served his suspension at the weekend. So that will be a boost to Scotstown, and it also gives McCarthy another week to regain fitness, though I'd still doubt he'll start this weekend
In soccer if a game is abandoned at any time, a suspension is deemed not served, but if you pick up a red card during the (abandoned) game, that still counts, the player would at least be out for the next match.
Gotta love the GAA for doing things their contrary way.

Milltown Row2

Quote from: twohands!!! on November 24, 2025, 08:26:15 PM
Quote from: DaleCooper on November 23, 2025, 06:50:59 PMMarty34 yep its ridiculous TG4 cant spend a few grand and buy the spinner lens that solves this. I note they used the behind goals camera a lot prob because it was clean

The fact that it's an ongoing issue for years and years with the TG4 coverage says it all.

As a comparison I think games on Clubber don't seem to be affected half as much by rain on the cameras.
I don't know is the placement of their cameras or are they using different equipment and maybe I've just been very lucky with the games I've watched on Clubber but I'm struggling to think of any game I've watched that has been as badly affected with rain as the TG4 coverage seems to be.

Clubbed they are sitting in the stand most occasions
None of us are getting out of here alive, so please stop treating yourself like an after thought.

ElJeffe

Quote from: Main Street on November 25, 2025, 04:22:33 PM
Quote from: Schkite on November 24, 2025, 02:45:42 PMFrom what I hear, O'Toole will be available for Scotstown in the rescheduled game - he's deemed as having served his suspension at the weekend. So that will be a boost to Scotstown, and it also gives McCarthy another week to regain fitness, though I'd still doubt he'll start this weekend
In soccer if a game is abandoned at any time, a suspension is deemed not served, but if you pick up a red card during the (abandoned) game, that still counts, the player would at least be out for the next match.
Gotta love the GAA for doing things their contrary way.

There is no rule as such but I believe it`s like a legal case where Scotstown will request a hearing and use precedent set by the GAA in 2012 when Eamonn Fennel missed league game against Mayo but then was abandoned due to fog. He was clear to play the following match rule by the GAA. James McCarthy was actually sent off in the abandoned game and had to serve a suspension the following game so Scotstown will have a very strong case for O`Toole.

LC

I see the guys on Off the Ball reckon Brian Hayes possibly the best dual star in the county at the moment.  Surely Brendan Rodgers and Shane McGuigan would have to be up there, All Stars in football at county level and made the All Ireland Club Hurling All Stars team last year.

Main Street

#548
Quote from: ElJeffe on November 25, 2025, 06:35:43 PM
Quote from: Main Street on November 25, 2025, 04:22:33 PM
Quote from: Schkite on November 24, 2025, 02:45:42 PMFrom what I hear, O'Toole will be available for Scotstown in the rescheduled game - he's deemed as having served his suspension at the weekend. So that will be a boost to Scotstown, and it also gives McCarthy another week to regain fitness, though I'd still doubt he'll start this weekend
In soccer if a game is abandoned at any time, a suspension is deemed not served, but if you pick up a red card during the (abandoned) game, that still counts, the player would at least be out for the next match.
Gotta love the GAA for doing things their contrary way.

There is no rule as such but I believe it`s like a legal case where Scotstown will request a hearing and use precedent set by the GAA in 2012 when Eamonn Fennel missed league game against Mayo but then was abandoned due to fog. He was clear to play the following match rule by the GAA. James McCarthy was actually sent off in the abandoned game and had to serve a suspension the following game so Scotstown will have a very strong case for O`Toole.
Schkite had already said O'Toole will play if selected, that he's served his time in the abandoned match. Seems like the precedent is embedded in the GAA memory bank. I see Newbridge Joe will ref the game again.

ElJeffe

Quote from: Main Street on November 25, 2025, 08:11:35 PM
Quote from: ElJeffe on November 25, 2025, 06:35:43 PM
Quote from: Main Street on November 25, 2025, 04:22:33 PM
Quote from: Schkite on November 24, 2025, 02:45:42 PMFrom what I hear, O'Toole will be available for Scotstown in the rescheduled game - he's deemed as having served his suspension at the weekend. So that will be a boost to Scotstown, and it also gives McCarthy another week to regain fitness, though I'd still doubt he'll start this weekend
In soccer if a game is abandoned at any time, a suspension is deemed not served, but if you pick up a red card during the (abandoned) game, that still counts, the player would at least be out for the next match.
Gotta love the GAA for doing things their contrary way.

There is no rule as such but I believe it`s like a legal case where Scotstown will request a hearing and use precedent set by the GAA in 2012 when Eamonn Fennel missed league game against Mayo but then was abandoned due to fog. He was clear to play the following match rule by the GAA. James McCarthy was actually sent off in the abandoned game and had to serve a suspension the following game so Scotstown will have a very strong case for O`Toole.
Schkite had already said O'Toole will play if selected, that he's served his time in the abandoned match. Seems like the precedent is embedded in the GAA memory bank. I see Newbridge Joe will ref the game again.


Surely Ulster could have read the room a little and appoint a different referee