Munster Championship

[Boards]

The current format of a playoff is unfair on kerry leinster is 6 teams so why not make munster 6 teams if kerry win

[johnnycool]

The current format of a playoff is unfair on kerry leinster is 6 teams so why not make munster 6 teams if kerry win

Have Kerry ever asked to get into Munster and if so, have they been refused?

[mouview]

Including Kerry would surely then mean introducing relegation for someone, and that would usually be Kerry who would most often be the whipping boys.

[Riseagain]

Including Kerry would surely then mean introducing relegation for someone, and that would usually be Kerry who would most often be the whipping boys.

It would make sense but the munster teams would never agree to that we see how they managed to get a playoff against the winner

[johnnycool]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

[Riseagain]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

[johnnycool]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

So back to my original point, what issue are you trying to resolve?

[mouview]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

So back to my original point, what issue are you trying to resolve?

It's in answer to the original question; if you include Kerry, will they be there in perpetuity or must there be relegation, a-la Leinster?

[johnnycool]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

So back to my original point, what issue are you trying to resolve?

It's in answer to the original question; if you include Kerry, will they be there in perpetuity or must there be relegation, a-la Leinster?

Then that takes me back to the other question I asked, have Kerry asked to be allowed into the Munster championship and if so, have they been refused.

Is the OP trying to solve an issue that doesn't exist?

[Riseagain]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

So back to my original point, what issue are you trying to resolve?

It's in answer to the original question; if you include Kerry, will they be there in perpetuity or must there be relegation, a-la Leinster?

Then that takes me back to the other question I asked, have Kerry asked to be allowed into the Munster championship and if so, have they been refused.

Is the OP trying to solve an issue that doesn't exist?

When the Joe Mcdonagh Cup was created the munster teams managed to have a playoff between the joe mc winners and bottom of munster

[Riseagain]

Howl on lads, what issue are you trying to resolve considering Kerry have just got relegated out of the Joe McDonagh Cup?

Yes they were relegated but from 2020 to 2022 they were in the final three years in a row yes they may have gone back a bit but thats bound to happen sometimes when you have a small pool of players.

So back to my original point, what issue are you trying to resolve?

It's in answer to the original question; if you include Kerry, will they be there in perpetuity or must there be relegation, a-la Leinster?

There shoukd bd a playoff between bottom munster and Leinster.

[didlyi]

The price of going to the Munster Final has gone through the roof and for some reason is more expensice than the football final and the Leinster hurling Final. Anyways the GAA say the money is needed to fund projects in the Munster region. Does that meaan the hurling people of Munster anre funding projects in Kerry who do so little to promote hurling?

[Riseagain]

The price of going to the Munster Final has gone through the roof and for some reason is more expensice than the football final and the Leinster hurling Final. Anyways the GAA say the money is needed to fund projects in the Munster region. Does that meaan the hurling people of Munster anre funding projects in Kerry who do so little to promote hurling?

I know its gotten dearer but people are willing to pay well above this for soccer and rugby and dont complain but the gaa gets dragged theough the dirt. Its an amateur organisation and we can see where the money goes to supporting the development and promotion of gaa.

[didlyi]

The price of going to the Munster Final has gone through the roof and for some reason is more expensice than the football final and the Leinster hurling Final. Anyways the GAA say the money is needed to fund projects in the Munster region. Does that meaan the hurling people of Munster anre funding projects in Kerry who do so little to promote hurling?

I know its gotten dearer but people are willing to pay well above this for soccer and rugby and dont complain but the gaa gets dragged theough the dirt. Its an amateur organisation and we can see where the money goes to supporting the development and promotion of gaa.

I take your point. Though the Munster hurling championship raises a huge amount of revenue year in year out for the Munster council in comparison to any other province, you wonder how well our Hurling lovers in Kerry do out of it. It doesnt strike me that a lot of money is being pumpoed into Kerry Hurling and Kerry being a county in Musnter must be doing OK out of the MHC.

[johnnycool]

The price of going to the Munster Final has gone through the roof and for some reason is more expensice than the football final and the Leinster hurling Final. Anyways the GAA say the money is needed to fund projects in the Munster region. Does that meaan the hurling people of Munster anre funding projects in Kerry who do so little to promote hurling?

I know its gotten dearer but people are willing to pay well above this for soccer and rugby and dont complain but the gaa gets dragged theough the dirt. Its an amateur organisation and we can see where the money goes to supporting the development and promotion of gaa.

I take your point. Though the Munster hurling championship raises a huge amount of revenue year in year out for the Munster council in comparison to any other province, you wonder how well our Hurling lovers in Kerry do out of it. It doesnt strike me that a lot of money is being pumpoed into Kerry Hurling and Kerry being a county in Musnter must be doing OK out of the MHC.

If you don't ask, you don't get.

Munster would be no different to Ulster in that you need to apply for funding through the correct channels.