Greatest all rounder of the last 25 years

Started by rrhf, May 10, 2013, 12:42:37 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who is the best all rounder  from 1988, versatile, multi skilled and adaptable to the game.

Graeme geraghty
20 (19%)
Peter Canavan
15 (14.3%)
Daragh o se
4 (3.8%)
Thomas o se
7 (6.7%)
Brian dooher
7 (6.7%)
Mickey linden
4 (3.8%)
Anthony tohill
23 (21.9%)
James mc cartan
2 (1.9%)
Paul mc grane
3 (2.9%)
Sean cavanagh
14 (13.3%)
Seamus moynihan
14 (13.3%)
Colum cooper
3 (2.9%)
Michael donnellan
14 (13.3%)
Pauric Joyce
5 (4.8%)
Martin o Connell
5 (4.8%)
Declan Browne
2 (1.9%)
Larry Tompkins
1 (1%)
Ciaran mc donald
9 (8.6%)
Dermot early
2 (1.9%)
Eamon o hara
6 (5.7%)
Philip Jordan
4 (3.8%)
Steve Cluxton
0 (0%)
Keiran mc geeney
7 (6.7%)
Oisin m conville
9 (8.6%)
Stephen o Neill
5 (4.8%)
Tony scullion
7 (6.7%)
Charlie Redmond
0 (0%)
Darren Faye
3 (2.9%)
Steve mc Donald
1 (1%)
Joe Mc Mahon
4 (3.8%)
Trebor Giles
5 (4.8%)
Pj Gillic
0 (0%)
Nudie Hughes
2 (1.9%)
Paul Galvin
1 (1%)
Darren Hughes
0 (0%)
Greg Blaney
6 (5.7%)

Total Members Voted: 105

Voting closed: May 22, 2013, 12:42:37 AM

rrhf


Captain Obvious


ranch


BennyCake

Philip Jordan?! What the...???

How is Cluxton an all rounder?

And no PJ McGrane??

Syferus


RMDrive


theticklemister


theticklemister


OakleafCounty

This should just be called 'best player' because the majority of that list can in no way be described as all rounders! Canavan, Linden, Redmond, Scullion, etc. A bit of cop on would be welcome here!

theticklemister

Keiran mcgeeney should be on the

- the best One trick pony thread.

Never an all rounder.

theticklemister

#10
Greg blaney should win this hands down but he is not on the list.

Jinxy

This thread should be renamed 'Greatest exclusively one position only player of the last 25 years'.
Or is it one of these ones where you have to use your imagination?
If you were any use you'd be playing.

theticklemister

Quote from: Jinxy on May 10, 2013, 08:49:12 AM
This thread should be renamed 'Greatest exclusively one position only player of the last 25 years'.
Or is it one of these ones where you have to use your imagination?

You have to think outside the small parelleogram

east down gael

Is Jordan included for his ability to defend and also to get players sent off?

thejuice

This doesn't make sense so I just voted for the Meath lads.
It won't be the next manager but the one after that Meath will become competitive again - MO'D 2016