Best midfielder of last 20 years.

[ardchieftain]

I seem to recall that Darragh O'Se stated that his toughest ever opponent was Paul McGrane.
Anthony Tohill would be up there with the above pair.

[theticklemister]

Just looking at the irish independemts 125 best footballers which they commissioned a few years ago. Big Tohill comes in at 80, cavanagh at 43 and o se at 23.

[GalwayBayBoy]

Way too many Ulster representatives.

Have to try and split their vote somehow.

[BennyCake]

The midfield role has changed over the last few years. For example, Sean Cavanagh is a fine player, plays in midfield alot but wouldn't be renowned for his high fielding.

The best fielder of that lot was Darragh O'Se. The best all-rounder was definitely Anthony Tohill.

[BennyHarp]

Did Tohill and O'Se ever play directly against each other? Can't think any championship meeting between Kerry and Derry but their paths must have crossed in a league game at some point?

[rrhf]

Both cavanafh and o se had more influence than to hill however I can't mark down the big man. Pj was a good one and whilst mc Dermot near finished canavans career in 96 he was a serious athlete.

[theticklemister]

Did Tohill and O'Se ever play directly against each other? Can't think any championship meeting between Kerry and Derry but their paths must have crossed in a league game at some point?

Never met in championship in those early years. We played them in an all ireland semi and a couple of nfl finals in the late 00s but Tohill was retired then.

O se is winning the duel here!!!

[5 Sams]

Both cavanafh and o se had more influence than to hill however I can't mark down the big man. Pj was a good one and whilst mc Dermot near finished canavans career in 96 he was a serious athlete.

Either you can't handle the predictive rrhf or you're pissed?

[Throw ball]

As he retired early due to injury he only just squeezes into the last twenty years but the best midfielder I ever saw play was Mark Grimley. Of those listed I would definitely go for Tohill.

[Gold]

Tohill. Best player i ever seen during years 97-2002

Catching was unmatched.

What other player catches a ball a metre over a crossbar?

Broke our hearts but i loved him

[Syferus]

Sure none of these pretenders would have had a hope against Seamie O'Neill.

[mayogodhelpus@gmail.com]

Way too many Ulster representatives.

Have to try and split their vote somehow.

10 out of 21 options 

[rrhf]

Probably representative of the era. Only for the fact big tohill never managed to outfield Jody Gormley he would be out front. Given the sheer volume of dara se s performances in cp ill give the nod to dara se. Both class

[bennydorano]

Paul McGrane - Armagh's best ever player imo (an opinion i've had & expressed for a long time), superb midfielder, not the straightest of feet tho.

[Jinxy]

Probably representative of the era. Only for the fact big tohill never managed to outfield Jody Gormley he would be out front. Given the sheer volume of dara se s performances in cp ill give the nod to dara se. Both class