Mark McHugh Diving

Started by here comes 6, July 23, 2012, 11:20:37 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

oakleafgael

Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:20:41 PM
he got hit snidely by coulter ffs. take a hit like that unawares and of course you're going to go down. to say he took a dive is bullshit and everyone knows, including those who saw it and would rather claim otherwise to put forward the argument that there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests. but it isn't a dive if you take a sneaky hit to the midriff.

some hardy boys on this board if you're able to take a rap to the gut you're not ready for and still stand. i'd say youse would be well able to take them alright. jokers.

He got a belt in the guts/ribs alright but the reaction to it was completly over the top in an attempt to get Coulter sent off. If you cant see that then your looking through Donegal tinted glasses. All counties have men who now seem to do this, including my own.

EC Unique

Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:20:41 PM
he got hit snidely by coulter ffs. take a hit like that unawares and of course you're going to go down. to say he took a dive is bullshit and everyone knows, including those who saw it and would rather claim otherwise to put forward the argument that there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests. but it isn't a dive if you take a sneaky hit to the midriff.

some hardy boys on this board if you're able to take a rap to the gut you're not ready for and still stand. i'd say youse would be well able to take them alright. jokers.

Coulter was acting the maggot no doubt but seriously.. He did not have to go down. A 5 year old could have hit him in the ribs with the same force plus they had been at each other for 10 or 15 seconds before the " sneaky hit to the midriff" so you can't really say he was not ready for some sort of impact.

He went down in order to get coulter sent off and not because his body could no longer stay vertical.

By the way this does not merit a thread of it's own.

rrhf

Mc Hugh could be the player of the year this year. 

cadence

Quote from: oakleafgael on July 23, 2012, 02:31:20 PM
Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:20:41 PM
he got hit snidely by coulter ffs. take a hit like that unawares and of course you're going to go down. to say he took a dive is bullshit and everyone knows, including those who saw it and would rather claim otherwise to put forward the argument that there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests. but it isn't a dive if you take a sneaky hit to the midriff.

some hardy boys on this board if you're able to take a rap to the gut you're not ready for and still stand. i'd say youse would be well able to take them alright. jokers.

He got a belt in the guts/ribs alright but the reaction to it was completly over the top in an attempt to get Coulter sent off. If you cant see that then your looking through Donegal tinted glasses. All counties have men who now seem to do this, including my own.

rose tinted glasses eh? what part of there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests, do you not get?

the issue is not whether there's too much diving going on, because that's a given. it's did he take a dive? and the answer to that is no... how can his reaction be ott if he was hit by a sucker punch, winded and hurt? 'course he has to go down, and stay down, until he gets his wind back.

i know the above is not convenient for your argument, but look at what happened. we can hardly expect players to stay up after taking sucker punches to the gut. fit and all as they are these days, they're not professional fighters, who, by the way, go down and stay down when they take a body shot that winds them. i honestly don't know what planet you're on if you think he shouldn't go down and stay down. madness!   

oakleafgael

Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:56:41 PM
Quote from: oakleafgael on July 23, 2012, 02:31:20 PM
Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:20:41 PM
he got hit snidely by coulter ffs. take a hit like that unawares and of course you're going to go down. to say he took a dive is bullshit and everyone knows, including those who saw it and would rather claim otherwise to put forward the argument that there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests. but it isn't a dive if you take a sneaky hit to the midriff.

some hardy boys on this board if you're able to take a rap to the gut you're not ready for and still stand. i'd say youse would be well able to take them alright. jokers.

He got a belt in the guts/ribs alright but the reaction to it was completly over the top in an attempt to get Coulter sent off. If you cant see that then your looking through Donegal tinted glasses. All counties have men who now seem to do this, including my own.

rose tinted glasses eh? what part of there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests, do you not get?

the issue is not whether there's too much diving going on, because that's a given. it's did he take a dive? and the answer to that is no... how can his reaction be ott if he was hit by a sucker punch, winded and hurt? 'course he has to go down, and stay down, until he gets his wind back.

i know the above is not convenient for your argument, but look at what happened. we can hardly expect players to stay up after taking sucker punches to the gut. fit and all as they are these days, they're not professional fighters, who, by the way, go down and stay down when they take a body shot that winds them. i honestly don't know what planet you're on if you think he shouldn't go down and stay down. madness!   

Your contradicting yourself,  you say there is to much diving going on but wont accept that what McHugh done falls into that bracket. He got a dig alright and he lay down to get Coulter sent off.

cadence

Quote from: oakleafgael on July 23, 2012, 03:02:14 PM
Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:56:41 PM
Quote from: oakleafgael on July 23, 2012, 02:31:20 PM
Quote from: cadence on July 23, 2012, 02:20:41 PM
he got hit snidely by coulter ffs. take a hit like that unawares and of course you're going to go down. to say he took a dive is bullshit and everyone knows, including those who saw it and would rather claim otherwise to put forward the argument that there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests. but it isn't a dive if you take a sneaky hit to the midriff.

some hardy boys on this board if you're able to take a rap to the gut you're not ready for and still stand. i'd say youse would be well able to take them alright. jokers.

He got a belt in the guts/ribs alright but the reaction to it was completly over the top in an attempt to get Coulter sent off. If you cant see that then your looking through Donegal tinted glasses. All counties have men who now seem to do this, including my own.

rose tinted glasses eh? what part of there's too much diving going on, a view that no one contests, do you not get?

the issue is not whether there's too much diving going on, because that's a given. it's did he take a dive? and the answer to that is no... how can his reaction be ott if he was hit by a sucker punch, winded and hurt? 'course he has to go down, and stay down, until he gets his wind back.

i know the above is not convenient for your argument, but look at what happened. we can hardly expect players to stay up after taking sucker punches to the gut. fit and all as they are these days, they're not professional fighters, who, by the way, go down and stay down when they take a body shot that winds them. i honestly don't know what planet you're on if you think he shouldn't go down and stay down. madness!   

Your contradicting yourself,  you say there is to much diving going on but wont accept that what McHugh done falls into that bracket. He got a dig alright and he lay down to get Coulter sent off.

please, it does not fall into that bracket because it was a sucker punch that winded him. you must be some hard man eh.