DJ Carey

[Truthsayer]

I've given you 3 All Ireland finals against one of Kilkenny's biggest rivals where he didn't show up.
That's the elephant in the room for Carey.

That's the elephant in the room for you, not Carey. You desperately conjure up three games, one were he was All Ireland winning captain, while ignoring his overall career. In Honours category they should add:  Three games that didn't impress Lamps:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/D._J._Carey

Seriously, what does captaining a team have to do with it? He was elected captain by his own club.
He failed to score in the final. A decision made by club months before that doesn't cover that up.

I've given you 3 All Ireland finals against one of Kilkenny's biggest rivals where he didn't show up.
That's the elephant in the room for Carey.

This does read like 'I always said he was shite' despite never actually saying it

I've never claimed he was shite. He just didn't do it in many crunch games.
Colin Montgomerie wasn't a shite golfer, he just didn't have what's needed to win a major.

You're some boy at moving the goalposts!
Colin Montgomerie didn't win 5 All Irelands, 10 Leinster titles and 9 All Stars... thems some majors for Carey!
Where does your logic leave Patrick Horgan especially after this year's All Ireland final debacle?
Jees! If a Cork player had DJ's record yis would have a statue up to him ✨️