Antrim Football Thread

[Milltown Row2]

These are a mixture of lads coming back home temporary transfers due to club's folding or no grade available? Along with of course lads just leaving?

[ck]

The GAA transfer system was designed to allow lads move to clubs where they now live and work.
For 5 Lavey men who live in Lavey to use a Belfast address to transfer to a Belfast club so they can give 2 fingers up to their own club is just wrong in my book.
St.Brigids should not be facilitating the move but of course they'll struggle to see past filling their senior team with 5 county Derry players, and alienating 5+ of their own young players in the process.

It's wrong, it shouldnt be allowed and is bending the rules IMO. Many will disagree I'm sure.

As for those saying 'would you rather see them not play'?
Firstly they'll play with Derry regardless and secondly should this exit route not be available then the rift may have been easier to resolve and clear up.

[imtommygunn]

Do they not live in south Belfast?

[ck]

Do they not live in south Belfast?

No

[geezer]

Who are the 5?

[Hoof Hearted]

Could their great uncle not have taken them up to swatragh ?

[delgany]

Antrim CCC would havd to sign off those inter county transfers.

[Milltown Row2]

The GAA transfer system was designed to allow lads move to clubs where they now live and work.
For 5 Lavey men who live in Lavey to use a Belfast address to transfer to a Belfast club so they can give 2 fingers up to their own club is just wrong in my book.
St.Brigids should not be facilitating the move but of course they'll struggle to see past filling their senior team with 5 county Derry players, and alienating 5+ of their own young players in the process.

It's wrong, it shouldnt be allowed and is bending the rules IMO. Many will disagree I'm sure.

As for those saying 'would you rather see them not play'?
Firstly they'll play with Derry regardless and secondly should this exit route not be available then the rift may have been easier to resolve and clear up.

Btw I'm not in agreement with what's going on, but none of us are in the real know of what's been going on in the background. The players were going to go to a club, not sure if the rules of not being affiliated to a club and playing for your county.

[delgany]

The GAA transfer system was designed to allow lads move to clubs where they now live and work.
For 5 Lavey men who live in Lavey to use a Belfast address to transfer to a Belfast club so they can give 2 fingers up to their own club is just wrong in my book.
St.Brigids should not be facilitating the move but of course they'll struggle to see past filling their senior team with 5 county Derry players, and alienating 5+ of their own young players in the process.

It's wrong, it shouldnt be allowed and is bending the rules IMO. Many will disagree I'm sure.

As for those saying 'would you rather see them not play'?
Firstly they'll play with Derry regardless and secondly should this exit route not be available then the rift may have been easier to resolve and clear up.

Btw I'm not in agreement with what's going on, but none of us are in the real know of what's been going on in the background. The players were going to go to a club, not sure if the rules of not being affiliated to a club and playing for your county.

Peter Canavan was registered with Killyclogher Hurling Club at the start of his Tyrone career,due to similiar circumstances !

[Milltown Row2]

The GAA transfer system was designed to allow lads move to clubs where they now live and work.
For 5 Lavey men who live in Lavey to use a Belfast address to transfer to a Belfast club so they can give 2 fingers up to their own club is just wrong in my book.
St.Brigids should not be facilitating the move but of course they'll struggle to see past filling their senior team with 5 county Derry players, and alienating 5+ of their own young players in the process.

It's wrong, it shouldnt be allowed and is bending the rules IMO. Many will disagree I'm sure.

As for those saying 'would you rather see them not play'?
Firstly they'll play with Derry regardless and secondly should this exit route not be available then the rift may have been easier to resolve and clear up.

Btw I'm not in agreement with what's going on, but none of us are in the real know of what's been going on in the background. The players were going to go to a club, not sure if the rules of not being affiliated to a club and playing for your county.

Peter Canavan was registered with Killyclogher Hurling Club at the start of his Tyrone career,due to similiar circumstances !

That rule I'm sure is still in place though not 100% sure

[Hoof Hearted]

Must be a bad row cause lavey were a serious clannish outfit. Never in a million years I would've thought this could happen

[Spike]

No one here should underestimate the egos of those involved here have.   Turned a minor tiff into a complete debacle.  Lavey will go on. St brigids won't be the last club these fellas will be at. 

[marty34]

Even though they are on county team, none are starters and when they come on, to me anyway, they don't stand out.

Typical modern day county player panellist. Handpassing side to side and passing it back.

Compare to Ethan Doherty etc. who has pace and great ball carrier plus runs at good angles.

I'm sure St. Brigid's have a load of typical modern day footballers so not sure what these lads will add.

[jmcgdoire]

Even though they are on county team, none are starters and when they come on, to me anyway, they don't stand out.

Typical modern day county player panellist. Handpassing side to side and passing it back.

Compare to Ethan Doherty etc. who has pace and great ball carrier plus runs at good angles.

I'm sure St. Brigid's have a load of typical modern day footballers so not sure what these lads will add.

Just to clear a few misconceptions here only 4 of them are on the county panel. Altho the other lad is a decent wee player too.

Ive seen all 5 of them play for Lavey and theres no doubt they are all good players (particularly Seamus's two youngest who are supposedly both injured at the minute). Lavey will miss them.

That Derry panel doesnt seem to have a lot of depth so im sure they will continue to get 5-10 minutes here and there but wouldnt be given the trust to try anything out of the ordinary yet. Just lateral handpassing as you say.

Im told that a real issue now is that Henry's oldest boy (and county player) is moving to St Brigids while his next one is staying put in Lavey. Totally understandable and happy to hear that the young lad wants to stay playing with his friends. But makes you wonder why the rest of the boys couldnt work through their issues and do the same. Im sure all parties could swallow their pride and they could resolved their differences

[Milltown Row2]

No one here should underestimate the egos of those involved here have.   Turned a minor tiff into a complete debacle.  Lavey will go on. St brigids won't be the last club these fellas will be at.

Every club, big or small has ego's, inflated opinions on themselves and what they bring to the club, that is up and down the country. The clubs will always be the focus for the majority. Lavey (from my own limited knowledge) are a well respected dual club and something like this won't define them, if this is a personal rift between players then its very sad to see it as it is.

But by the same token and not taking sides, players should not just give up playing because they can't/won't play for their home club