Sunday Game team of the Year

[paddypastit]

PJ Ryan
Ollie Canning
JJ Delaney
JackieTyrrell
Tommy Walsh
Brick Walsh
Padraic Maher
Michael Rice
Alan McCrabbe
Henry Shefflin
Seamas Callinan
Eddie Brennan
John Mullane
Lar Corbett
Noel McGrath

Hurler of the Year - Tommy Walsh

[highorlow]

Hurler of the Year - Tommy Walsh

Is he the same Tommy Walsh that the 'panel' said should have been sent off against Galway?

[orangeman]

Hurler of the Year - Tommy Walsh

Is he the same Tommy Walsh that the 'panel' said should have been sent off against Galway?

Seems so. These boys get their money handy.

[longrunsthefox]

No Joe Canning 

[johnneycool]

Hurler of the Year - Tommy Walsh

Is he the same Tommy Walsh that the 'panel' said should have been sent off against Galway?

Seems so. These boys get their money handy.

I don't see the contradiction here at all lads. Tommy should have seen the line against Galway but he still was the best hurler throughout the year. It's not as if he killed anyone.

[lilpaulie85]

No Joe Canning 

Canning didn't do enough from play to merit an all-star i dont think even though he finished the top scorer.

[mouview]

No Joe Canning 

Canning didn't do enough from play to merit an all-star i dont think even though he finished the top scorer.

Sheflin did SFA more but still seems to get one. Touch of the DJs creeping into it now.

[johnneycool]

No Joe Canning 

Canning didn't do enough from play to merit an all-star i dont think even though he finished the top scorer.

Sheflin did SFA more but still seems to get one. Touch of the DJs creeping into it now.

Shefflin had a good semi-final vrs Waterford, but was fairly quiet yesterday and against the Dub's. Come to think of it can't remember him doing anything great against Galway either but he'll get his allstar nonetheless.

[AZOffaly]

Shefflin scored 0-10 against Galway, 0-06 v Dublin, 1-14 v Waterford and 1-08 v Tipperary. That's decent going.

[orangeman]

Shefflin scored 0-10 against Galway, 0-06 v Dublin, 1-14 v Waterford and 1-08 v Tipperary. That's decent going.

Decent going alright. Imagine what he'd score in a good year.

[johnneycool]

Shefflin scored 0-10 against Galway, 0-06 v Dublin, 1-14 v Waterford and 1-08 v Tipperary. That's decent going.

Barring the semi-final most of those scores were from dead balls, granted someone has to put them over/in and Henry's as good as is out there but not sure if its the basis for an allstar.

For what it's worth I think he'll get his allstar but I'm not sure he deserves it if it was based on open play.

Joe Canning is the championships highest scorer who'd a great game against Kilkenny but his star waned as the year went on, does he merit an allstar?

[GalwayBayBoy]

Shefflin scored 0-10 against Galway, 0-06 v Dublin, 1-14 v Waterford and 1-08 v Tipperary. That's decent going.

Strangely enough the only game I thought he played really well in throughout was against Waterford. Not that he was bad in any of the other games mind.

[AZOffaly]

Shefflin scored 4 from play against Galway, and 1-06 against Waterford. Not sure of the Dublin game.

I think he's been good this year.

If this discussion is really about Joe Canning though, then I think he is worth his place on the team of the year as well. People are adding weight to Noel McGrath's year because it's his first. He's a great talent, and had a great year himself, but Joe Canning is still the benchmark for all young players.

[Premier Emperor]

Padriag Maher should be full back.

[slow corner back]

Padriag Maher should be full back.

Agreed, really steadied the ship for Tipp since he moved back there