Armagh management :Paddy O'Rourke!!!

[Logan]

Think he meant before he took the job

[rootthemout]

lads we were jumping about talking about mcgeeney coming back at one stage in this thread,aidan orourke has more managerial experience then mcgeeney,why do we have to have a big name?sometimes the younger manager with fresh ideas and commiment can deliver,look at the fella who took wexford,name escapes me at the minute,jason rayan is it?

Who has Aidan O Rourke managed, Queens? hardly more experience than Mc Geeney

how do you work that one out?

[Onion Bag]

How do you work out that managing a University team gives you more experience than manaing a Senior intercounty team,

hardly a comparison

[Logan]

I think the point was that when McGeeney took on Kildare he had as much experience as AOR has now ... maybe more.

But not now of course

[Goats Do Shave]

I dread the inevitable nepotism arguments!

[Onion Bag]

lads we were jumping about talking about mcgeeney coming back at one stage in this thread,aidan orourke has more managerial experience then mcgeeney,why do we have to have a big name?sometimes the younger manager with fresh ideas and commiment can deliver,look at the fella who took wexford,name escapes me at the minute,jason rayan is it?

Root clearly argues that AOR has more managerial experience than Mc Geeny, i was only wondering how he came to  that conclusion

[rootthemout]

lads we were jumping about talking about mcgeeney coming back at one stage in this thread,aidan orourke has more managerial experience then mcgeeney,why do we have to have a big name?sometimes the younger manager with fresh ideas and commiment can deliver,look at the fella who took wexford,name escapes me at the minute,jason rayan is it?

Root clearly argues that AOR has more managerial experience than Mc Geeny, i was only wondering how he came to  that conclusion

onion what im saying is people are talking about orourke having no experience,this was the same scenario mcgeeney was with kildare,orourke has every bit as much experience as mcgeeney and i dont think we can dismiss him for not having taken a county team.

[Onion Bag]

Fair enough, i thought you meant he has more experience than Mc Geeney at the min, In My opinion, AOR is not the man for the job, he was not a good leader on the pitch like geezer was, he has little or no charisma, Mc Geeney is extremely charismatic,

Any younger players will look up to Geezer, so i think thats why Geezer could get into a postion like hes in,

had AOR gone for the same job, he wouldnt have had a snowballs chance

[Cúig huaire]

Mc Geeney is extremely charismatic,

[Cúig huaire]

Mc Geeney is extremely charismatic,

That deserves the roflcopter.

[mountainboii]

cha⋅ris⋅ma [kuh-riz-muh]
–noun, plural -ma⋅ta

1. A personal quality that gives an individual influence or authority over large numbers of people.
2. The special virtue of an office, function, position, etc., that confers or is thought to confer on the person holding it an unusual ability for leadership, worthiness of veneration, or the like.


What exactly is funny Cúig huaire? You don't have to swan about like Sean Connery to be charismatic. Have you confused charisma with charm?

[Cúig huaire]

What exactly is funny Cúig huaire? You don't have to swan about like Sean Connery to be charismatic. Have you confused charisma with charm?

No, but Onion Bag seems to be very confused. He seems to think McGeeney has charisma? Maybe he drives a Mitsubish Charisma, but thats about as close as he`ll ever get.

[mountainboii]

And again, charisma is generally defined as an exceptional ability to lead, something McGeeney has a pretty decent track record of. You know with captaining his club, county, province and country and all that.

Are you sure you understand the definition of the word charisma?

[Onion Bag]

And again, charisma is generally defined as an exceptional ability to lead, something McGeeney has a pretty decent track record of. You know with captaining his club, county, province and country and all that.

Are you sure you understand the definition of the word charisma?

Cheers for the support AFS, you know where im coming from

[BroJolly]

If AOR got the job would that not be a similar position to Joe Kernan getting it with his sons playing?

Could be good craic when Aiden takes Martin off