who would you take?

[Eoghan Mag]

I'd take whichever forward line had amassed the most All-Ireland medals up to this point. What is the medal count for each choice?

[TacadoirArdMhacha]

Kerry's has 5 (assuming Donaghy wasn't around in 2004)

Tyrone's has 7 (You can argue as to whether 2008 should count for Mulligan and O'Neill - I haven't included them).

Cooper and Donaghy Vs O'Neill and Cavanagh is near enough level with possibly the Tyrone duo shading it, assuming O'Neill is as likely to retain his 2005 form in the championship as he appears to be. Then you have what appears to be the massive potential of Walsh against a Mulligan who was overhyped at his peak and now seems well past his best. Kerry just about the stronger I think.

[Eoghan Mag]

Hardstation the initial question didn't require me to give a reason for the choice.