Canavan or Gooch - who would you have?

[Bensars]

I think thats fair enough comment max regarding canavan and mc keever. always a great battle.

In regards to cooper and the eye, it was packie mc connell's flap and subsequent glove that gooch run into

[saffron sam2]

Max has answered the McKeever argument better than I could have, so we'll leave it at that.

As regards, Cooper vs. McMenamin, the crucial word I used is legitimately.  Again, Max seems to be along my line of thinking, although I was thinking of the 2003 semi-final.  I'm sure someone from Tyrone will bite.