Messages

1

GAA Discussion / Re: Ulster XV to beat Dublin

« on: March 07, 2020, 02:43:39 PM »

Danny Quinn, Peter Canavan, Oisin McConville and Eamon McGee recently came up with an Ulster XV to beat Dublin.

They agreed on the following side:

1. Morgan (Tyrone)
2. R Wylie (Monaghan)
3. R McNamee (Tyrone)
4. C Cullen (Fermanagh)
5. E Ban Gallagher (Donegal)
6. C McKaigue (Derry)
7. K O’Connell (Monaghan)
8. J Og Burns (Armagh)
9. N Kearns (Monaghan)
10. R O’Neill (Armagh)
11. M Murphy (Donegal)
12. R McHugh (Donegal)
13. P McBrearty (Donegal)
14. C McShane (Tyrone)
15. C McManus (Monaghan)

4 Donegal and Monaghan
3 Tyrone
2 Armagh
1 Fermanagh and Derry

I’d go with the following

1. Morgan (Tyrone)
2. Hampsey (Tyrone)
3. McNamee (Tyrone)
4. Ban Gallagher (Donegal)
5. McHugh (Donegal)
6. McKaigue (Derry)
7. Mooney (Down)
8. McFadden (Donegal)
9. McKiernan (Cavan)
10. Donnelly (Tyrone)
11. Murphy (Donegal)
12. Campbell (Armagh)
13. McGuigan (Derry)
14. McShane (Tyrone)
15. McManus (Monaghan)

5 Tyrone
4 Donegal
2 Derry
1 Armagh, Cavan, Down and Monaghan

Personally think any team picked has to include Rian O'Neill. 

2

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 1 - 2020

« on: February 23, 2020, 06:53:38 PM »

As I was in Mullingar today I havent seen McGeary red. I seem to remember though that for health and safety reasons - and to avoid high tackles - it was decided that the tackler was responsible for the safety of the person tackled. If the referee thinks the impact is dangerous it is an automatic red even if the contact is accidental.

3

GAA Discussion / Re: U20 All Ireland football championship 2020

« on: February 22, 2020, 02:38:14 PM »

Full times

Armagh 0-8 Tyrone 1-5 extra time to be played

Cavan 0-8 Dublin 1-11

Donegal 2-8 Monaghan 1-11 extra time to be played

Just because no one can beat them in Leinster shouldn't mean Dublin move to Ulster ! 

4

GAA Discussion / Re: David Clifford protection

« on: February 10, 2020, 06:40:03 PM »

Do you think the umpire might have got his little book out to ask Clifford for an autograph and then thought better of it.

5

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 1 - 2020

« on: February 09, 2020, 05:17:07 PM »

Tonto I actually doubt if there would be and as he is a Kerry man I think the chances are even less.

6

GAA Discussion / Re: David Clifford protection

« on: February 09, 2020, 05:13:56 PM »

The footage I saw would suggest that the Tyrone player was the aggressor. I have no idea why Harte was sent off.  Last night there were handbags at halftime in the Armagh v Kildare game. Numerous players were involved yet Jamie Clarke is the only one to get a yellow -and it didn't start with him and I havent seen what he did. For his second yellow the Kildare player appealed to the linesman to get him sent off. 3 of the best players in the country and they get no protection. I am sure other counties see the same with their best players. These are the players you want to see. Not the diving mouthy players that always seem to walk away without censure.

7

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 1 - 2020

« on: February 09, 2020, 03:43:50 PM »

McCurry is unplayable. To score from a sideline kick in them conditions is some feat.

You should probably add ' at this time of year' . Tyrone people will know better than me on that score

8

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 1 - 2020

« on: February 09, 2020, 03:30:01 PM »

No matter who wins Tyrone v Kerry but the officials have had a bad day

9

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 1 - 2020

« on: February 09, 2020, 03:18:00 PM »

Some free 'won' by McCurry there.

10

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 2 - 2020

« on: February 09, 2020, 10:13:27 AM »

I think Dinny it was the 2 Lazarus like recoveries (11 and 23?) That riled Armagh support so much. The rest of the stuff you see in every game  sadly.

11

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 2 - 2020

« on: February 08, 2020, 09:11:40 PM »

Great win for Armagh. Was very disappointed with Kildare

12

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 2 - 2020

« on: February 03, 2020, 12:14:39 AM »

Thoughts on Referee. He was out of his depth. For the most part you had to wait for him to point before you knew which way the free was going. His timekeeping was extremely suspect too. To his credit though he wasnt biased- he got things wrong for both teams.

The great problem with Gealic football - who is the referee seems to determine how the rules are applied. Last week Armagh played a physical game with Cavan with no real angst among the players. Yesterday chess looked more physical and players - most particularly Armagh players - got extremely frustrated with the decisions.

So if one referee allows the more physical side of tackles go you play that way, when you’ve a referee who is a stickler for not allowing rough play you adopt? Are players that thick that they can’t adopt to the style of certain referees?

You’ll never get consistency, ever, players ain’t consistent managers ain’t consistent, different if the ref is only giving decisions one way, but if he’s not then the players need to adopt to gain advantage

It is hard to disagree with the core of your argument. What I was trying to suggest was that Cassidy, Brannigan , McQuillian, Hurson, Coldrick , Gough etc. all referee by letting a certain level of physical play go. In general they referee Division 1 games. In Division 2 they referee some games while the rest are refereed by a variety of referees that referee in a way that bears little resemblance to each other. A certain level of inconsistency is expected between referees but the general approach to the game should always be consistent.

I typed and then deleted a number of things I consider he did wrong. I deleted them because i don't want to try him on a public forum. He may become a good referee if the powers that be coach him to correct the things he is weakest on. The one thing i want to stress though is that he was equitable to both teams.

13

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 2 - 2020

« on: February 02, 2020, 11:05:38 PM »

Thoughts on Referee. He was out of his depth. For the most part you had to wait for him to point before you knew which way the free was going. His timekeeping was extremely suspect too. To his credit though he wasnt biased- he got things wrong for both teams.

The great problem with Gealic football - who is the referee seems to determine how the rules are applied. Last week Armagh played a physical game with Cavan with no real angst among the players. Yesterday chess looked more physical and players - most particularly Armagh players - got extremely frustrated with the decisions.

14

GAA Discussion / Re: NFL Division 2 - 2020

« on: February 02, 2020, 10:04:04 AM »

Genuinely don't understand the attitude of some Armagh fans who think we will be really pushing for promotion. I'd love if we were, but I have not seen any evidence to suggest that will be the case. Hopefully last night will serve as a reality check.

Nail on head, speaking to a lot of fans prior to game last night there was an air of optimism in regards of promotion,  last night shows it would be a slaughtering session in Division 1.  The defensive frailties are there for all to see, the kick outs never improve, the soft frees and the back chat to get frees moved up were inexcusable, can't understand why it took Geezer so long to make changes, Donaghy is too slow in my opinion - second to everything, though he was not the reason Armagh were given a trimming last night.

While I agree with most of what you say I feel you are completely wrong about Donaghy even if yesterday was not his best outing. He is critical to any defensive shape Armagh do have. I am also convinced that if he hadn't have gotten himself sent of in Cavan match last summer then Armagh would have made an Ulster Final. The bigger problem is that considering his age that doesn't augur well for our defence in the next year or 2.

15

Laois / Re: NFL Div 2 2020

« on: February 01, 2020, 09:02:17 PM »

Armagh always lose to Laois and we were brutal today. As was the referee - for both teams. Laois very impressive in the way they managed the game. The pitch seems to need a bit of remedial work.