Without doubt, we are not in possession of all the facts. If it was a straightforward case, things couldn't possibly have dragged on for so long.
I can't give an opinion one way or the other as I don't know what is really going on behind the scenes but one thing does strike me and it is this:
The GAA could very well be in conflict with EU regulations over the freedom of movement of individuals. I don't have a particular piece of legislation in mind but thinking back on various anti-discrimination cases that have hit the headlines in recent years; I'd not be at all surprised if Aghaloo were to be found in breach of something or other.
I know the parish rule is sacrosanct in GAA circles and without it, many of the smaller clubs might go to the wall but if it is ever brought to the attention of the bureaucrats in Brussels there might be a shakeup in the way clubs operate.
Now, I am not referring to the McKinnon case in particular; it may be just a matter of time until someone, somewhere with time on hands and money in the pocket decides to test the legality of the Parish Rule.
I can't give an opinion one way or the other as I don't know what is really going on behind the scenes but one thing does strike me and it is this:
The GAA could very well be in conflict with EU regulations over the freedom of movement of individuals. I don't have a particular piece of legislation in mind but thinking back on various anti-discrimination cases that have hit the headlines in recent years; I'd not be at all surprised if Aghaloo were to be found in breach of something or other.
I know the parish rule is sacrosanct in GAA circles and without it, many of the smaller clubs might go to the wall but if it is ever brought to the attention of the bureaucrats in Brussels there might be a shakeup in the way clubs operate.
Now, I am not referring to the McKinnon case in particular; it may be just a matter of time until someone, somewhere with time on hands and money in the pocket decides to test the legality of the Parish Rule.