Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Real Talk

#256
Query over decision to limit player reimbursement scheme
The chairman of the GAA's Medical, Scientific and Welfare Committee is to sit down for discussions with President Christy Cooney on the Association's decision to limit physiotherapy reimbursement as part of its player injury scheme.
Date: 05 March 2010 Score: 7.4389142990112
I think in general the GAA only play lip service to Players Welfare and they begrudge all Players additional help outside of the Insurance scheme.   As far as players go they don't give enough thought about the effects of injury until they experience the problem for themselves.  There is no education process in place to alert players of the possible consequences of serious injury as the County Boards and the general Governing Bodies are scared of puting players off playing the games.  But in the final analysis Players should make themselves fully aware of the risks involved and literally take it on the chin when it goes wrong cost thats what they will be expected to do.  As the intensity and the fitness levels required increases then the future for the amateur game particularly at County level will be confined to a select number of counties eg large population/very dedicated single gaelic entity areas will be able to compete at the to table.  This is already happening with Cork, Dublin, Kerry, Kilkenny and Tyrone likely to dine at the top table.  All of this not helped by the difficult economic situation which is going to paralise the many Sponosors.   I doubt I have went on a very negative tangent !!!!!!!
#257
Quote from: Archie Mitchell on January 29, 2012, 02:29:05 PM
Quote from: Blue and White on January 29, 2012, 11:14:38 AM
I think last nights final was a bit of a damp squib, totally ruined by an inept referee.  Derry were looking good in the first 20 minutes, winning alot of ball at midfield, solid in defence and kicking some good scores.  Obviously the big turning point was the sending off but gerard o'kane going off before that was a big blow.  Not sure what his injury was but he took a very cynical knee to the head 5 minutes before it and tyrone were definitly targetting him.  O'Kane was playing very well. Cavanagh should have got at least a yellow for the late shoulder charge to the back of Mc Callion (i think).  On the sending off, there was nothing in it, happened straight in front of me and both players were niggling at each other.  The linesman watched it the whole time from about 10 yards away and when Cavanagh hit the ground, the linesman shook his head and told him to get up.  It was the linesman on the far side of the pitch who made the call to send conway off.  Poor refereeing imo.  Cavanagh I think was embarassed by it all, from the resulting free kick he fell twice and decided to stay down the third time.  Havnt heard much about his injury but he cried wolf a few times too many to deserve sympathy and out of embarassment I think he took the decision himself to stay down. 

This ruined the game and it must have been awful to watch on TV.  Derry put O'Boyle to midfield but I wish they had brought on a midfielder and kept O'Boyle where he was at.  After the derry goal i could see brennan telling the derry midfield to put the ball in high on top of him as Tyrone looked vulnerable.  Unfortunately we didnt get the chance after the sending off.  Would have loved to have seen Patsy coming on.

All in all a good McKenna cup for derr, Morrow looked good and up until the sending off the defence seemed able to cope, though we couldnt get men back quick enough as the game wore on and this meant that Dillon was left isolated on O'neill alot.  Add in the kielts, muldoon, skinner and decky mullan and we might get a good run in the league!!

:D :D

Were you even at the game? After the sending off Bradley decided to push him down, can even be seen on the TV coverage. Then with the incident where he got injured, him and McGoldrick were both going for the ball, got tangled up and was accidental that McGoldrick's foot came in contact with Cavanagh's chest as both were falling. Again this can be seen by the TV coverage. He hardly saved himself the "embarrassment" by staying down pretending to be injured. 
I'd say it was more out of fear than embarassmet ... like his brother he's fairlly good at crying
sure they will meet again in the league for the next episode. I think Derry should appeal the James Conway red card unfortunately his reputation doesn't do him any favours
#258
GAA Discussion / Re: Paddy O'Rourke Out!
August 23, 2011, 11:36:41 PM
Quote from: Rufus T Firefly on August 23, 2011, 05:16:58 PM
Quote from: TacadoirArdMhacha on August 23, 2011, 04:53:25 PM
With respect Rufus, I strongly disagree with the point you make which I've highlighted. Armagh are a Division 1 team with a reasonably talented bunch of players. Whether they are absolutely top class is debatable but as managerial propositions go, I'd say there'd be no shortage of contenders, inside and outside the county.

My guess would be that if the contenders were asked to do the job on POR's terms and conditions, then the list of candidates would shrink dramatically.

You are correct, that is the crux of the matter
#259
Quote from: Kerry Mike on July 18, 2011, 08:56:08 PM
A fine win well done . Nice to see a new winner. Bradleys bros were a huge loss to Derry

Eoin Bradley is a massive loss.  He plays much better without Paddy and Donegal will prove to be a diffucult team to beat.  They have conceeded an average of 8pts in their champioship games, must admit the oposition was not terrifice except for Tyrone who usually rack up 15/16 points a game but not against Donegal
#260
Quote from: tbrick18 on June 13, 2011, 08:33:33 PM
Quote from: tonysoprano on June 13, 2011, 08:23:11 PM
Hopefully Muldoon can turn it on again like he did against Fermanagh and the midfield, whoever it may be will not get cleaned out!

Team i expect to see lining out:

1. Conlon
2. Sean Leo
3. Kevin McCloy
4. McBride
5. Michael Bateson
6. Charlie Kielt
7. Barry McG
8. Joe Diver
9. Michael Friel
10. Lynch
11. O'Boyle
12. Emmett McGuckin
13.Gilligan
14.Skinner
15. Muldoon

Wouldn't be surprised to see Kevin McGuckin in defence. I would probably prefer him than McCloy however both in my opinion will struggle against Stevie. There are quite a few attacking options to come off the bench with Kielt, Declan Mullan, Donaghy, Mulholland and Ciaran McG all having something to offer. However things will be difficult in midfield and defence!

Heres hoping for a big victory. Everyone get out and support regardless of the venue.

Doire Abú

I think the same team will start against Armagh that started against Fermanagh....unless Gerard O'Kane is ruled out in which case Barry McGoldrick will come back in.

Can't see Enda getting the space and time on the ball that he did against Fermanagh, so even though he's captain do you think Barry won't start, I wonder if he is not fit or just not in the frame?  I think C Kielt is much better as an attacking wing back, he doesn't have the defensive nous to play CHB.  But its 15 v 15 and anything can happen, who would have thought M Murphy would have got sent off yesterday!!!   So lets hope we get the 'rub of the Clones green' and somehow squeez through
#261
 Don't matter where the game is at I'l be there.   The big majority of the Derry fans in Clones will be the friends and families of the players who get 'free' tickets for the game and in this regard the U C will have plenty of good seats as compared to Casement

Quote from: The Stallion on June 09, 2011, 08:03:38 PM
I'm fairly confident Derry will beat Armagh based on a few factors:

1. Armagh are getting a bit too much praise for beating a vastly overrated Down team, and I think they might be a wee bit complacent going into this match.

2. Brennan was canny enough to make a convincing victory for Derry sound like a dreadful day at the office, to make sure the players come out firing against Armagh rather than the usual Derry habit of one good performance followed by one dreadful performance.

3. I think this is potentially the best all round Derry forward line in a few years, despite what many are saying. There's a bit of everything - scorers, high fielders, hard workers, and clever creative players. Armagh have Clarke, Padden and an aging McDonnell, and nothing else in my opinion.




[/quot

And possibly the worst defence and most mediocre mid-field since 1990
#262
I'd say Meath are due a good game(esp if the Reillys are back) and Banty knows Derry inside out.  Thats not a bad team picked by Tony S but surely we need a better RCB maybe McCallion from G'lough should get another go and there isn't any other options at mid-field.

Could be another bad City day for the Oakleafers.
#263
Shurely you Tyrone supporters should be very happy with what these players have delivered over a 10 year period.  It is not possible for amateur players to give any more, they have been fantastic but it can't go on for ever
#264
Quote from: drici on March 08, 2011, 02:28:46 PM
Ulster Under 21 Football Championship 2011 First Round
Date: Wednesday 9th March 2011 @ 8pm
Venue: Celtic Park

Derry v Armagh

Referee: Shaun Mc Laughlin


Aha - Derry site has colours and all and a home venue.




Is that the same Sean McLaughlin who was harshly blown up for an inlegal pass to P Canavan in the 1995 AIF Tyrone v Dublin !!!!!!!!
#265
Tyrone played well against a Derry team with no mid-field and if their shoot improves they should have no bother against Donegal.  Although Donegal have a good record against them in non-Championship games
#266
GAA Discussion / Re: Double header in Croker
February 17, 2011, 05:15:26 PM
Do 'Jedward' play Hurling or Football and which County do they represent ????

I'd  say they are corner forwards in the Ross Munelly mould

Good idea though
#267
Quote from: Rufus T Firefly on November 26, 2010, 11:24:20 PM

Anthony Lynch
Martin O'Connell
Dara Ó Sé (move Cavanagh positionally)
Maurice Fitzgerald
Colin Cooper.
Kevin O'Brien.
Sorry Canalman but anyone who leaves Greg Blaney out of a 90s team doesnt know much about football :-\ :-\
[/quote]

McCartan's team is packed with forwards that could win a 50/50 ball high or low and also create and take scores in tight championship games.   I agree that Thomas O'Shea should have been an cert and also Dara O'Shea instead of Cavanagh, who has not been the force he was since Dooher's impact is not as influencial now that he has come to the end of his career.  But its not a Maths test where there is only one correct answer, its all about opinions and how many time you have watch live performances
#268
GAA Discussion / Re: Official Meath Manager Thread
November 15, 2010, 07:39:45 PM
Quote from: Maguire01 on November 13, 2010, 06:19:29 PM
Quote from: haranguerer on November 12, 2010, 10:03:25 PM
Quote from: Maguire01 on November 12, 2010, 07:16:41 PM

Still so confident in that view after reading the Independent's article? It doesn't look like anyone's making a killing out of that. From the €11k/month, €2k to a physio, take away mileage and subsistence for four members of the team, phone charges etc...


Mileage?? Using the outside limits i.e this is likely to be significantly more than the actual cost; say 100 mile each (average) for the 4 (its like f**king entourage) members of the team, 4 times a week, at the rate of (is it still 45c?) say 50c per mile: thats about 3.5k absolute maximum. Add 2k for physio, and you're left with a £5.5k per month for feeds and phone chargers. They better buy their tracksuits a size bigger than they are now.

And this is just what we know about. Although, hold on, did that article say that was all they were getting? Did a co board man deny under the counter payments? Did the banty talk shite at a press conference? None of which is new, and none of which is reliable.
Mileage is 60c/mile, not that it makes that much of a difference to your calculations. So yes, they'll get a decent return for their work, but it has moved on a bit from earlier analysis suggesting Banty would be pocketing a grand a week.

In the North of Ireland mileage is 35p per mile.   How does the cost of fuel differ in the two parts of Ireland?  It would seem that there is an equality issue with the Northern players coming out second best,nothing to do with the Meath job though, something for the GPA to look into. Maybe they have given up on player welfare North of the Border!!!!!!







#269
GAA Discussion / Re: GAA Books 2010
November 10, 2010, 09:31:44 PM
I heard that the 'elder' James McCartan is doing an autobiography for the Christmas market and also coincides with the 50th Anniversary of Downs first Sam in 1960. Don't know who the author is though
#270
I think the only other person was Peter Doherty as O'Rourke and Barton pulled out , Scullion was not eligble and Baker was staying with Antrim.   What surprised me was that the County Board didn't insist on Brennan naming his backroom team. If its true they are Stevenson, McElhome and Conal Sheridan, then thats not an impressive list