Quote from: Hectic on November 24, 2018, 09:43:34 PMQuote from: The gooch on November 24, 2018, 07:14:30 PMQuote from: imtommygunn on November 24, 2018, 07:04:27 PM
The top teams don't look to be coming from any of the top senior teams at all though.Not fair at all.
The best you could do is from 3 years previous in the minor.
Creggan won the senior league and the team that beats them in the u21s will be the winner. Aghagallon, st galls, st brigids will be the 1s to compete with them, all div 1.
Look at the 6 previous years winners. Rossa-div 1. Aghagallon-div1. St johns x 3-div1. Pg1-div 1 or on the cusp of being promoted.
No disrespect to antirm town and st pauls, theyl not be winning it.
Only fair that geniune contenders ie creggan,galls are seeded. But again lads, just my opinion
Pretty sure Aghagallon played Div 2 when they won it. 2016? Could be wrong.
And beaten finalists the year before as a div 3 team. Again could be wrong.
Think they won the league and intermediate when they won it.
Look my point was that this years format is a farce. Laughable that rossa and ld play again in 3 days time.
Back to the old format with some sort of seeding to allow for an ultra competitive cship with the best playing the best. Seeding also helps the lesser teams as they will also have a genuine chance of silverware. No point the loser of creggan v dunloy (hypothetical) going into the b comp as they will walk it