I was fortunate enough to play with and against most opf the players mentioned here, but I have no doubt that Eddie Donnelly was the best hurler in the last 50 years.For club county and provence he was exceptional,in railway cup games he regularly chiped in with 2-5, 3-4 etc playing on a team that was being well beaten and marked by on of the countrys best full backs. He was also a gentleman on and off the field.