gaaboard.com

GAA Discussion => GAA Discussion => Topic started by: Angelo on September 01, 2019, 05:16:08 PM

Title: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 01, 2019, 05:16:08 PM
2014 Cormac Reilly - Mayo v Kerry
2015 Maurice Deegan - Tyrone v Kerry
2019 Maurice Deegan - Tyrone v Kerry
2019 David Gough - Dublin v Kerry
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Silkyskillssunshinee on September 01, 2019, 05:27:17 PM
In fairness Gough's umpires should've seen Cluxton off his line. Need to help him out there.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 01, 2019, 05:29:41 PM
In fairness Gough's umpires should've seen Cluxton off his line. Need to help him out there.

Exactly ref fair helped Dublin out there.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 01, 2019, 05:30:50 PM
You could go 2008 the other way...
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 01, 2019, 05:38:53 PM
You could go 2008 the other way...

 ;D

Good one.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: LilySavage on September 01, 2019, 05:41:35 PM
Thats not a very exhaustive list. And ive no idea how you think he favoured Kerry today. Obrien got chopped down ehen through and Lyne fouled near sideline at the death, nothing given. Crucial call at that stage.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 01, 2019, 05:48:22 PM
It's just an anti Kerry agenda from a very paranoid Tyronie.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 01, 2019, 05:50:18 PM
You could go 2008 the other way...

 ;D

Good one.

Ah that old impartiality as good as ever ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: LilySavage on September 01, 2019, 06:00:46 PM
Cluxton a yard off his line for the peno. I think overall he had an ok game and didnt favour either.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 01, 2019, 06:28:14 PM
You could go 2008 the other way...

 ;D

Good one.

Ah that old impartiality as good as ever ;D

I'm impartial, a lot of people are diseased when it comes to calling Kerry out on things.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 01, 2019, 06:36:12 PM
Youíre impartial  ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Tatler Jack on September 01, 2019, 07:30:23 PM
Leaving out Marty Duffy for his 2009 performance is a bit unfair.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Jim Bob on September 01, 2019, 07:37:44 PM
Good to see the pulling on the arm being nailed
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: clarshack on September 01, 2019, 08:13:07 PM
Leaving out Marty Duffy for his 2009 performance is a bit unfair.

Yep, Kennelly physically assaulting Murphy from the throw-in and getting away with it is right up there.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: henrym14 on September 01, 2019, 09:06:03 PM
Kerry couldn't buy a free in second half.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: under the bar on September 01, 2019, 09:11:15 PM
It's just an anti Kerry agenda from a very paranoid Tyronie.

Don't start again. You've already made a pure cnut of yourself on the other thread. ;D Your inability to accept  Tyrone constantly  hammering Armagh is a fact you have to live with.   ;D ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 01, 2019, 09:25:07 PM
It's just an anti Kerry agenda from a very paranoid Tyronie.

Don't start again. You've already made a pure cnut of yourself on the other thread. ;D Your inability to accept  Tyrone constantly  hammering Armagh is a fact you have to live with.   ;D ;D
You donít really understand irony do you ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 01, 2019, 09:26:23 PM
Leaving out Marty Duffy for his 2009 performance is a bit unfair.

Oh absolutely.

Feel free to add to the list, the amount of times it happens is endless so hard to remember them all.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 01, 2019, 10:32:01 PM
It's just an anti Kerry agenda from a very paranoid Tyronie.

Don't start again. You've already made a pure cnut of yourself on the other thread. ;D Your inability to accept  Tyrone constantly  hammering Armagh is a fact you have to live with.   ;D ;D
You donít really understand irony do you ;D ;D ;D

 ;D ;D 8)
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Tyrdub on September 02, 2019, 12:14:47 PM
1978 - Seamus Aldridge (Kildare)
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Tatler Jack on September 02, 2019, 12:33:38 PM
Murray from Monaghan in 1980 did them no harm.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: five points on September 02, 2019, 01:00:02 PM
1946 All Ireland semi-final v Antrim.
1937 All Ireland semi-final replay v Laois.
1926 All-Ireland final replay v Kildare.

Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: yellowcard on September 02, 2019, 01:21:23 PM
Kerry might have benefited slightly overall from the major decisions in the match yesterday but anyone thinking that Gough set out to favour one team over another in the showpiece occasion of the GAA calendar needs their head examined. he would have set out yesterday to refereee the game to the best of his ability not to try and show one particular side favouritism. Overall I though he had a decent game and I'm glad the 2 sides have another 70 minutes to prove who is the better side.

That said I think the Kerry media assault on Gough's impartiality was very poor stuff before he had even been appointed to referee the match.   
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Aaron Boone on September 02, 2019, 01:24:19 PM
Who will Kerry appoint for the replay?
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Armagh18 on September 02, 2019, 01:34:30 PM
Thought Gough was very good yday. Penalty maybe slightly soft but by the letter of the law was a pen. Coopers two yellows were stonewall in fact the second probably should have been black, no arguing against them. OíSullivan could easily have gotten a second yellow it was a tough call to make but think he got it correct. Only real mistake was not ordering a retake of the penalty but it wasnít a great effort by Geaney and weíll not begrudge Cluxton that save.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: BennyHarp on September 02, 2019, 01:36:33 PM
If Deegan gets the replay Iíll be lumping on Kerry to win it.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Keyser soze on September 02, 2019, 02:03:56 PM
Was it only me who thought that O'Sullivan's yellow card was extremely harsh, tried to break the ball and the momentum of his arm carried it in over the Dublin players shoulder but he pulled it away again immediately. Though the second one was more a yellow though again he tried to break contact as soon as he committed the foul.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Tyrdub on September 02, 2019, 03:30:01 PM
2019 - Conor Lane (Cork) replay  ::) ::)
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Carbery on September 02, 2019, 06:54:19 PM
Is the referee for the All-Ireland Finals appointed bt the CCCC or former Referee Brian Gavin (Irish Examiner columnist)?
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: LilySavage on September 03, 2019, 07:33:05 AM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 03, 2019, 07:38:50 AM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Rossfan on September 03, 2019, 08:26:20 AM
The thread title should have been enough for the Mods to delete the feckin thing and suspend yer man for a month or 2 (or till he reaches his 16th birthday).
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trailer on September 03, 2019, 10:30:37 AM
2014 Cormac Reilly - Mayo v Kerry
2015 Maurice Deegan - Tyrone v Kerry
2019 Maurice Deegan - Tyrone v Kerry
2019 David Gough - Dublin v Kerry

This is was the worst case of blatant cheating ever. Completely rode Tyrone that day. An utter disgrace that he was even allowed to referee another game after that.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: J70 on September 03, 2019, 11:02:16 AM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trailer on September 03, 2019, 05:14:13 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 03, 2019, 05:53:26 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

You should all club together for some therapy, Tyrone make it easy for themselves not to win.  ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 03, 2019, 06:49:16 PM
Was it only me who thought that O'Sullivan's yellow card was extremely harsh, tried to break the ball and the momentum of his arm carried it in over the Dublin players shoulder but he pulled it away again immediately. Though the second one was more a yellow though again he tried to break contact as soon as he committed the foul.

Why had he his hands wrapped around O'Callaghan's hips in the box before the ball came in?
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 03, 2019, 07:06:24 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

You should all club together for some therapy, Tyrone make it easy for themselves not to win.  ;D

If Armagh hadn't faded in to irrelevance they would be suffering from the same biases Tyrone do.

To beat Kerry you have to be at least a 5 point better team, that's how much refs generally are worth to them. The very strange obsession guys like Colm O'Rourke have with Kerry where they fawn over them and turn a blind eye to things they would otherwise be going mental at is odd. The way their pundits always come out and try and drive an agenda in the media that suits them, Eamonn Fitzmaurice was out with some disgraceful pre match comments on Mayo and David Gough before big games this year that were intended to influence the refereeing performance. Kerry have been the most snide, cynical team for the last decade. Justin McMahon got slaughtered for his man marking job on Michael Murphy in 2015 by the national media, there was a big segment on it on the Sunday Game that night, Aidan O'Mahony did it even worse on Murphy in the most high profile game of the year a number of months before that, not a peep about it.

There's good cause for Tyrone people to have a chip on their shoulder with the GAA free state media. If Armagh happened to be in a place where they were relevant at the business end of the season, they'd soon find it was something that would be a big issue for them.

How did you like the imagery of Joe Kernan's side as a bunch of violent thugs who were more interested in fisticuffs than football that was put forward by many down south?

Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: J70 on September 03, 2019, 07:30:40 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.


Your avatar photo is well chosen. ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 03, 2019, 08:22:37 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

You should all club together for some therapy, Tyrone make it easy for themselves not to win.  ;D

If Armagh hadn't faded in to irrelevance they would be suffering from the same biases Tyrone do.

To beat Kerry you have to be at least a 5 point better team, that's how much refs generally are worth to them. The very strange obsession guys like Colm O'Rourke have with Kerry where they fawn over them and turn a blind eye to things they would otherwise be going mental at is odd. The way their pundits always come out and try and drive an agenda in the media that suits them, Eamonn Fitzmaurice was out with some disgraceful pre match comments on Mayo and David Gough before big games this year that were intended to influence the refereeing performance. Kerry have been the most snide, cynical team for the last decade. Justin McMahon got slaughtered for his man marking job on Michael Murphy in 2015 by the national media, there was a big segment on it on the Sunday Game that night, Aidan O'Mahony did it even worse on Murphy in the most high profile game of the year a number of months before that, not a peep about it.

There's good cause for Tyrone people to have a chip on their shoulder with the GAA free state media. If Armagh happened to be in a place where they were relevant at the business end of the season, they'd soon find it was something that would be a big issue for them.

How did you like the imagery of Joe Kernan's side as a bunch of violent thugs who were more interested in fisticuffs than football that was put forward by many down south?

I think the only major injustices Armagh suffered through the noughties were Ricey trying to smash McEntees head in with his knees only for big Fergal to get him off, or Jordan going down like he was shot to get Marsden sent off, but don't let your rose tinted glasses blind you, Tyrone are and have been trampish for two decades, maybe you reap what you sow.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 03, 2019, 09:03:34 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

You should all club together for some therapy, Tyrone make it easy for themselves not to win.  ;D

If Armagh hadn't faded in to irrelevance they would be suffering from the same biases Tyrone do.

To beat Kerry you have to be at least a 5 point better team, that's how much refs generally are worth to them. The very strange obsession guys like Colm O'Rourke have with Kerry where they fawn over them and turn a blind eye to things they would otherwise be going mental at is odd. The way their pundits always come out and try and drive an agenda in the media that suits them, Eamonn Fitzmaurice was out with some disgraceful pre match comments on Mayo and David Gough before big games this year that were intended to influence the refereeing performance. Kerry have been the most snide, cynical team for the last decade. Justin McMahon got slaughtered for his man marking job on Michael Murphy in 2015 by the national media, there was a big segment on it on the Sunday Game that night, Aidan O'Mahony did it even worse on Murphy in the most high profile game of the year a number of months before that, not a peep about it.

There's good cause for Tyrone people to have a chip on their shoulder with the GAA free state media. If Armagh happened to be in a place where they were relevant at the business end of the season, they'd soon find it was something that would be a big issue for them.

How did you like the imagery of Joe Kernan's side as a bunch of violent thugs who were more interested in fisticuffs than football that was put forward by many down south?

I think the only major injustices Armagh suffered through the noughties were Ricey trying to smash McEntees head in with his knees only for big Fergal to get him off, or Jordan going down like he was shot to get Marsden sent off, but don't let your rose tinted glasses blind you, Tyrone are and have been trampish for two decades, maybe you reap what you sow.

Do you agree with the portrayal of Armagh as over macho thugs who were more interested in fighting than football?

Interesting.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trailer on September 03, 2019, 09:04:42 PM
Why is there a thread here after Sunday's game? Gough had a good game. I suspect it is because of the RTE panel's misplaced outrage on Sunday. Ciaran Whelan has detracted his unwarrented criticism. Do people really take Brolly's analysis seriously?

It's because the threads originator is anti Kerry and a paranoid Tyronie who thinks Tyrone should be on 25 all-irelands if it wasnt for the pesky referee!

One of the most predictable things about gaaboard, year after year (and I've been here a good number now) is that there will always be a few Tyrone ones whining about referees, no matter the outcome of the game or how good the referee actually was.

There can be no doubt that Tyrone more than any other county have to overcome a sustained effort from GAA hierarchy, referees, media and other dark forces that continually attempt to prevent them from winning.

You should all club together for some therapy, Tyrone make it easy for themselves not to win.  ;D

If Armagh hadn't faded in to irrelevance they would be suffering from the same biases Tyrone do.

To beat Kerry you have to be at least a 5 point better team, that's how much refs generally are worth to them. The very strange obsession guys like Colm O'Rourke have with Kerry where they fawn over them and turn a blind eye to things they would otherwise be going mental at is odd. The way their pundits always come out and try and drive an agenda in the media that suits them, Eamonn Fitzmaurice was out with some disgraceful pre match comments on Mayo and David Gough before big games this year that were intended to influence the refereeing performance. Kerry have been the most snide, cynical team for the last decade. Justin McMahon got slaughtered for his man marking job on Michael Murphy in 2015 by the national media, there was a big segment on it on the Sunday Game that night, Aidan O'Mahony did it even worse on Murphy in the most high profile game of the year a number of months before that, not a peep about it.

There's good cause for Tyrone people to have a chip on their shoulder with the GAA free state media. If Armagh happened to be in a place where they were relevant at the business end of the season, they'd soon find it was something that would be a big issue for them.

How did you like the imagery of Joe Kernan's side as a bunch of violent thugs who were more interested in fisticuffs than football that was put forward by many down south?

I think the only major injustices Armagh suffered through the noughties were Ricey trying to smash McEntees head in with his knees only for big Fergal to get him off, or Jordan going down like he was shot to get Marsden sent off, but don't let your rose tinted glasses blind you, Tyrone are and have been trampish for two decades, maybe you reap what you sow.

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Milltown Row2 on September 03, 2019, 10:32:21 PM
The refereeing was grand, bar the penalty, cause if that was a penalty then there would be dozens in a match.

The two yellows for Cooper were correct and in fairness to him he didnít complain. He plays on the edge and heíd be my first name on the team sheet every game, but where Dublin management got it wrong was keeping him on the pitch!

Theyíd plenty of decent subs to do a good job in there. As for the other potential sending off, nope, ref did ok with that, but I can see why people would complain.

Some moaning cnuts on here
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 04, 2019, 08:10:15 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.   
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 04, 2019, 08:12:01 AM
The refereeing was grand, bar the penalty, cause if that was a penalty then there would be dozens in a match.

The two yellows for Cooper were correct and in fairness to him he didnít complain. He plays on the edge and heíd be my first name on the team sheet every game, but where Dublin management got it wrong was keeping him on the pitch!

Theyíd plenty of decent subs to do a good job in there. As for the other potential sending off, nope, ref did ok with that, but I can see why people would complain.

Some moaning cnuts on here

All are from one county - the rest of the country saw a great game off football and can't wait for the replay.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: clarshack on September 04, 2019, 09:13:25 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

more than armagh will   ;)

your just another bitter armagh man with a chip on his shoulder about Tyrone. who'd have thought it eh?.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trailer on September 04, 2019, 09:23:33 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

Ch, ch, ch, chokers. Couldn't win an argument for f**ks sake.

Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 04, 2019, 09:42:40 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

Ch, ch, ch, chokers. Couldn't win an argument for f**ks sake.

Point proven, good man - move along now - you'll miss the first therapy session, think over the bar is already in the corner shaking ripping up pictures of Deegan!
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 04, 2019, 09:48:25 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

more than armagh will   ;)

your just another bitter armagh man with a chip on his shoulder about Tyrone. who'd have thought it eh?.

Au contraire, I always enjoyed Tyrone and was at the 95 all-ireland final supporting them, but the Trampish win at all costs Saint Mickey brought in and the pure asswips on this forum defending the trampish behaviour is what I have issue with, I enjoy football and hurling and travel all round Ireland watching games, Tyrone are now not a nice county I am not alone in seeing this, you reap what you sow - the diving and skulduggery of the Tyronies is being called out, about time.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trueblue1234 on September 04, 2019, 10:38:08 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

more than armagh will   ;)

your just another bitter armagh man with a chip on his shoulder about Tyrone. who'd have thought it eh?.

Au contraire, I always enjoyed Tyrone and was at the 95 all-ireland final supporting them, but the Trampish win at all costs Saint Mickey brought in and the pure asswips on this forum defending the trampish behaviour is what I have issue with, I enjoy football and hurling and travel all round Ireland watching games, Tyrone are now not a nice county I am not alone in seeing this, you reap what you sow - the diving and skulduggery of the Tyronies is being called out, about time.

I'll really struggle to sleep tonight over this....
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 04, 2019, 10:43:28 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

more than armagh will   ;)

your just another bitter armagh man with a chip on his shoulder about Tyrone. who'd have thought it eh?.

Au contraire, I always enjoyed Tyrone and was at the 95 all-ireland final supporting them, but the Trampish win at all costs Saint Mickey brought in and the pure asswips on this forum defending the trampish behaviour is what I have issue with, I enjoy football and hurling and travel all round Ireland watching games, Tyrone are now not a nice county I am not alone in seeing this, you reap what you sow - the diving and skulduggery of the Tyronies is being called out, about time.

I'll really struggle to sleep tonight over this....

You just keep giving - point proven time and time again - now get away with the rest to the therapy.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: trueblue1234 on September 04, 2019, 10:46:49 AM

Ricey wasn't going for his head but only his neck to kind of "choke" him. Nobody can really comment on Armagh thuggish behaviour as they tend to only play 2 or 3 championship games, and typically play in divison 3 which doesn't tend to be covered on TV or really matter at all.

So in the spirit of football to cut off the oxygen supply to an opposing player with one's knees is acceptable?  Maybe trampish incidents like this 15 years  ago continuing up to and including McCann trying to pull the teeth out of an opponent without any condemnation from Saint Mickey have opened refs eyes to the dark arts they are taught, as I say you reap what you sow - enjoy your 2020 McKenna Cup win, you will win nothing else.

more than armagh will   ;)

your just another bitter armagh man with a chip on his shoulder about Tyrone. who'd have thought it eh?.

Au contraire, I always enjoyed Tyrone and was at the 95 all-ireland final supporting them, but the Trampish win at all costs Saint Mickey brought in and the pure asswips on this forum defending the trampish behaviour is what I have issue with, I enjoy football and hurling and travel all round Ireland watching games, Tyrone are now not a nice county I am not alone in seeing this, you reap what you sow - the diving and skulduggery of the Tyronies is being called out, about time.

I'll really struggle to sleep tonight over this....

You just keep giving - point proven time and time again - now get away with the rest to the therapy.

That cuts deep bro. Real deep....
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 14, 2019, 06:32:31 PM
Conor Lane - Kerry v Dublin 2019
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 14, 2019, 06:38:52 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 14, 2019, 06:40:33 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

You're watching it too.

Pretty disgraceful stuff from Lane.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: tonto1888 on September 14, 2019, 06:40:50 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

To be fair he has a point with this one
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Solo_run on September 14, 2019, 06:41:20 PM
They really should have Pat McEnaney in the studio
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 14, 2019, 06:42:17 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

You're watching it too.

Pretty disgraceful stuff from Lane.

I thought as part of the Tyronies group therapy, you were all told to stay away from here. ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 14, 2019, 06:43:44 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

To be fair he has a point with this one

I've a point with all of them. To beat Kerry you have to be at least 6 points better than them.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: t_mac on September 14, 2019, 06:45:19 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

To be fair he has a point with this one

I've a point with all of them. To beat Kerry you have to be at least 6 points better than them.

Only a few months to the McKenna cup and silverware will be flowing again, keep the faith.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 14, 2019, 06:50:37 PM
The usual suspects defending the indefensible as usual.

Sweep, sweep.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 14, 2019, 06:54:10 PM
I had a feeling this was coming ;D

To be fair he has a point with this one

I've a point with all of them. To beat Kerry you have to be at least 6 points better than them.

You do have some valid points. You donít have as many as you think you do though and then when people donít perceive every point/opinion as fact you deem them as prejudice too which doesnít exactly help your case ;D
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Rossfan on September 14, 2019, 07:51:15 PM


Sweep, sweep.
Where did we see that term before? ;)
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 15, 2019, 09:05:27 AM
Lane toned it down in the second half bit the first half yesterday was a scandal.

Dublin didn't get one free from scoring range yesterday despite all the fouling that was going on, particularly off the ball. The only point Rock got from a placed ball was a 45. When has that ever happened with Dublin before?

It baffles me how it took Stephen O'Brien until near the end of the game to get a yellow card. He must have committed 15 fouls by that stage.

A lot is made about Donor Buckley being a great coach and how he teaches his teams how to tackle. What he teaches his teams is how to tactically foul teams on a consistent basis. It was the same with Mayo when he was there but it's ramped up another level with Kerry. Fair enough if you can get away with it but it's not even subtle at this stage. O'Shea, O'Sullivan and O'Brien have spent over 200 minutes hanging off opponents for the past threegames in full view of the referee and it's been by and large ignored.

The favouritism Kerry receive from referees is beyond a joke at this point, it's being going on for years.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 15, 2019, 09:34:29 AM
The second half more than balanced the first half though. You pulled the line that Paul Geaney was allowed too many steps in the Tyrone game for the goal - well for dublinís 1-1 at the start of the second half they were both too many steps. There was a debatable penalty too .

Dublin were better team though and deserved to win but yesterday did more than balance out in the end.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Angelo on September 15, 2019, 01:37:26 PM
The second half more than balanced the first half though. You pulled the line that Paul Geaney was allowed too many steps in the Tyrone game for the goal - well for dublinís 1-1 at the start of the second half they were both too many steps. There was a debatable penalty too .

Dublin were better team though and deserved to win but yesterday did more than balance out in the end.

That is such nonsense, all Lane did was tone it down in the second half, Kerry were still getting the rub of decisions in that half so you'd need to have some green and gold tinted spectacles to think that was a leveller.

He could have been pulled for steps, certainly but he had also been tugged back prior to the goal.

I take it the penalty you are referring to is the one that should have been given against Tom O'Sullivan at the end of the first half, much like the one that should have been given against O'Sullivan in the first game? I can't recall any penalty incident involving Kerry.

Given the amount of incessant fouling Kerry were committing on Mannion, O'Callaghan and Kilkenny, it's unbelievable that Dublin did not get a free inside the 45 yard line against Kerry in about 80 minutes of action.

Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: imtommygunn on September 15, 2019, 08:27:54 PM
 ;D

Rational. Not so much.
Title: Re: The definitive list of disgraceful refereeing performances favouring Kerry
Post by: Dubhaltach on September 15, 2019, 08:56:02 PM
Lane toned it down in the second half bit the first half yesterday was a scandal.

Dublin didn't get one free from scoring range yesterday despite all the fouling that was going on, particularly off the ball. The only point Rock got from a placed ball was a 45. When has that ever happened with Dublin before?

It baffles me how it took Stephen O'Brien until near the end of the game to get a yellow card. He must have committed 15 fouls by that stage.

A lot is made about Donor Buckley being a great coach and how he teaches his teams how to tackle. What he teaches his teams is how to tactically foul teams on a consistent basis. It was the same with Mayo when he was there but it's ramped up another level with Kerry. Fair enough if you can get away with it but it's not even subtle at this stage. O'Shea, O'Sullivan and O'Brien have spent over 200 minutes hanging off opponents for the past threegames in full view of the referee and it's been by and large ignored.

The favouritism Kerry receive from referees is beyond a joke at this point, it's being going on for years.

Maybe that doesn't happen Dublin too often because they are used to having having shite referees who always give the free to the man in possession (most intercounty referees fall into this bracket), the Dubs tend to get frustrated when they get decent referees like Gough and Lane who actually allow defenders to tackle. You can't have Smiley Deegan or Dublin Joe every day I suppose!

Lane had a decent game overall although he possibly should have given a black card to O Callaghan for the pull down that prevented a clear Kerry goal scoring opportunity.

And spare us the 'holier than thou' shite about Kerry holding/fouling off the ball as if the Dubs weren't masters at that themselves!