Ulster Club IFC/JFC 2023

Started by DownFanatic, September 19, 2023, 12:35:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

general_lee

Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

mrdeeds

#106
Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Don't see why there should be a link. Teams play without county players for league so some teams would have a huge advantage. Arva winning comfortably despite playing a lot of game with 14.

Armagh18

Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:14:43 PM
Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Don't wee why there should be a link. Teams play without county players for league so some teams would have a huge advantage. Arva winning comfortably despite playing a lot of game with 14.
But if you're fit to play division 1 league without your county players why should you be playing junior championship with your county players lol

clarshack

Arva battered Ballymaguigan by 15 points and Ballymaguigan are no mugs. Looks very ominous for the rest of the teams left in the Ulster Junior Championship..

mrdeeds

Quote from: Armagh18 on November 05, 2023, 03:20:42 PM
Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:14:43 PM
Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Don't wee why there should be a link. Teams play without county players for league so some teams would have a huge advantage. Arva winning comfortably despite playing a lot of game with 14.
But if you're fit to play division 1 league without your county players why should you be playing junior championship with your county players lol

That's one outlier. When they got from division 3 to 1 they only had Ciaran Brady in county panel. Now have 3. A competition by it's nature is meant to be fair and even so linking two is in no way fair.

clarshack

Who are Arva's 2 other county players?

galwayman

The reason I like the fact that there is no link is that the league can go ahead to conclusion without county players. Not sure that would be the case if it affected your championship status.
We get a league game every two weeks uninterrupted from early March up until early July (dual county so alternate football and hurling weekends). And then a short 3-4 weeks until first round of championship.
Much better than it used to be

mrdeeds

Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 03:36:58 PMWho are Arva's 2 other county players?

Tristan Noack Hoffman and Johnaton McCabe.

marty34

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Div. 1 league teams should be in senior championship, Div. 2 in Intermediate and Div. 3 should be in Junior championship.

Mad that clubs in Cavan play Div. 1 but play Junior - crazy stuff.

Armagh18

Each to their own i suppose whatever works in each county. In Armagh its more or less accepted you won't have your county men for the bulk of the league so you just forget about them but its still linked.

Totally agree with Marty above.

clarshack

Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:52:42 PM
Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 03:36:58 PMWho are Arva's 2 other county players?

Tristan Noack Hoffman and Johnaton McCabe.


They'll have plenty of ex Cavan Minor & U-20/21 players too?

JoG2

Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:14:43 PM
Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Don't see why there should be a link. Teams play without county players for league so some teams would have a huge advantage. Arva winning comfortably despite playing a lot of game with 14.
Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 03:29:36 PMArva battered Ballymaguigan by 15 points and Ballymaguigan are no mugs. Looks very ominous for the rest of the teams left in the Ulster Junior Championship..

Great to see Arva prevail at the expense of the Derry Div 3 junior champions.
Maybe Derry should send Loup or Newbridge into junior next year, pick up some junior level silverware

mrdeeds

Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 04:08:39 PM
Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:52:42 PM
Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 03:36:58 PMWho are Arva's 2 other county players?

Tristan Noack Hoffman and Johnaton McCabe.


They'll have plenty of ex Cavan Minor & U-20/21 players too?

Yeah the Morris brothers and Bouchier. They were probably knocking about the senior panel too I think.

clarshack

Stewartstown were fortunate enough to beat Drumlane who knocked out Arva last season and Stewartstown were only in Junior due to Covid. Just can't see the Cavan champions getting caught out this year.

Will next year too see Knockbride playing in Division 1 having won the Division 2 Final and playing in the Junior Championship?

general_lee

Quote from: JoG2 on November 05, 2023, 04:16:25 PM
Quote from: mrdeeds on November 05, 2023, 03:14:43 PM
Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.

Quote from: general_lee on November 05, 2023, 01:33:20 PM
Quote from: galwayman on November 05, 2023, 12:27:03 PMAs a matter of interest - is every county different in terms of whether or not there is a link between league and championship?
In Galway we used to have senior league, intermediate league, junior league etc. You played at that same grade for Championship.2 up and 2 down each year.
To get senior you either had to win the intermediate league or win the intermediate championship.
Restructure maybe 10-11 years ago removed the link between c'ship and league.
Your league division has nothing to do with what championship grade you play in at all.
My own club play junior championship but in our league (division 3) all
of the other teams play either intermediate or senior championship.
These provincial club championships are amazing competitions.
Played in a Connacht final a good few years back and was a brilliant experience.
There should be a link between league and championship, probably the fairest way when it comes to provincial club competitions. Cavan have a similar set up with Division 1 clubs plying their trade at Junior level - pretty ridiculous that clubs good enough to play Division 1 football are able to compete against genuine Junior clubs in Ulster competition.


Don't see why there should be a link. Teams play without county players for league so some teams would have a huge advantage. Arva winning comfortably despite playing a lot of game with 14.
Quote from: clarshack on November 05, 2023, 03:29:36 PMArva battered Ballymaguigan by 15 points and Ballymaguigan are no mugs. Looks very ominous for the rest of the teams left in the Ulster Junior Championship..

Great to see Arva prevail at the expense of the Derry Div 3 junior champions.
Maybe Derry should send Loup or Newbridge into junior next year, pick up some junior level silverware
To be fair I see the Swa had a handsome win in Ulster Junior hurling championship yesterday.